And I’m not wild about a Constitutional amendment banning gay marriage for a whole bunch of reasons. Still, this shows that many social conservatives do not necessarily buy into the slash and burn approach to the welfare state.
Author: Lee M.
-
Just War Theory -> Pacifism?
Via LewRockwell.com I came across this essay on “libertarian just war theory” by Wendy McElroy. Her conclusion: “Given these [just war] requirements, a libertarian just war is virtually unimaginable.”
I’ve wondered for a while now whether the requirements of just war theory are so strict as to rule out virtually any modern war (see, esp. J.H. Yoder’s When War Is Unjust). And if so, does that mean one should modify (or jettison) just war theory or become a de facto pacifist?
-
We Are All Individuals!
Thomas at Endlessly Rocking has a very interesting series of posts on what he calls the “individualist paradox.” In short, he says that often those who are most vocal in their denunciations of “individualism” in their churches and as a result become converts to another, supposedly less individualistic, tradition are in fact engaging in a paradigm act of individual assertion and judgment.
That seems right to me, and, in fact, it may not be too much to say that individualism just is our condition as moderns (or post-moderns, or whatever we are nowadays). Gone are the days when our identities were given to us at birth. And even if I decide to submit myself to some outside authority, it’s still me (I?) that decides to do so.
I thought this was particularly insightful:
Still, I don’t want to single out the Orthodox, and in any case I hope it’s clear that I’m talking about particular experiences I’ve had, particular books I’ve read, particular blogs I’ve encountered, and not Orthodoxy itself, which again needn’t fall into this as a matter of course. Such a desire for the ‘Golden Age’ of the Church can take refuge in a rather Traditionalist Catholicism, or a confessing Anglican Church standing against apostasy, or a Baptist congregation that claims not to dilute the Bible’s word with ‘human traditions’. It can lead to anyplace, really. All one has to do is read a few books, listen to a few pastors or priests, figure out what the unadulterated Church looks like, and go find it. …
So, the whole point to those admittedly ragged, poorly written little posts is that often in the search for a relief from the illusions and terrors of a false individualism, folks are forced to decide on the basis of very little except private judgment to abandon ship and seek the fullness of Truth elsewhere. It is, in our context, an inherently lonely act, no matter how many people may support the move, for ultimately it rests on a decision, one which in early Christian eras would have been not only forbidden, but even unthinkable.
-
Toward a New Class Warfare
Reihan Salam, whose LA Times article I linked to a while back, has a post outlining his suggestions for a new class-oriented politics for the GOP. It should, he says, be all about empowering the “aspirational classes,” those who, in John O’Sullivan’s words
are striving to better their condition-whether that betterment has to do with founding a business or improving their own human capital. These people will generally include a majority of the middle class, a substantial minority of the new educated upper class, and many people now seen as social problems rather than economic actors.
Salam argues that this kind of neo-populism has democracy promotion as its logical counterpart. By this he means democracy promotion both at home (e.g. by reining in the courts) and abroad.
Definitely a worthwhile read, as is The American Scene generally.
-
"Progressive" should at least mean not killing the helpless, shouldn’t it?
A surprising article (considering the source) on the Terri Schiavo case at Salon:
Today, our humanity is perched on the precipice of a slippery slope. A disabled woman in Tampa, Fla., breathing on her own and cared for by her parents, is to be denied a simple feeding tube, thereby hastening her death and freeing her husband to marry his fiancée and the mother of his two children. Terri Schiavo is no longer convenient in her husband Michael’s life, and so is to be sentenced to a passive execution.
Terri’s cause has been adopted by religious conservatives with passionate advocacy. I am neither religious nor conservative, but as a compassionate progressive, I believe the Schiavo case spotlights a critical juncture in the preservation of a humanistic and humanitarian culture: Allowing Terri to die via starvation belies and mocks the ethics and principles of a civilized society.
-
Conservative Minds
The prolific Keith Burgess-Jackson has started another blog – The Conservative Philosopher. KBJ has enlisted several contributers so far, including Bill Vallicella. As a dabbler in philosophy and a student (though not quite an adherent) of conservatism, I’m sure I’ll be visiting regularly. Long may it prosper!
-
Idols of Home and Marketplace
I really want to like this column by Roberto Rivera y Carlo because I think it gets some important things right. Rivera y Carlo criticizes our culture of careerism that emphasizes work over family:
In the West, however much we “value” marriage and family, our approach to the matter says that we esteem them less than career and a high standard of living. Think about it: we see ads urging 20- and 30-somethings to plan for their retirement now. Have you ever seen anything advising the same level of forethought to marriage and family? Of course not. In our culture, the order is work then family.
Unfortunately, this order ensures that marriage and family, not work, will do the bulk of the accommodating. (Sometimes this can’t be helped: heroic single moms like my own have no choice but to try and balance the demands of work and family. They didn’t choose the conflict between work and family; it was chosen for them.) Marriage and family will be grafted onto already-existing obligations and routines created by our work lives.
He advocates a restructuring of priorities as an anitdote:
So if focusing on our careers before settling down is inadvisable, what’s the alternative? It’s following the cultural model that prevailed until only recently: regarding work as a mean to an end — the end being caring for your family — rather than an end in itself. It’s keeping in mind that, as “Hallmark-y” as it may sound, your marriage and family are the most important thing you will ever do. They, not what you do for a living, are your legacy.
In recent decades there has been a shift away from the old view of work as necessary to survive toward seeing paid work as the locus of our identity, providing our chief source of meaning and self-fulfillment. We are then encouraged to pour our heart and soul into our work, sacrificing the other aspects of our lives when necessary (e.g. the advent of being connected to the office 24 hours a day via pagers, cell phones and e-mail which is touted as “liberation” but is actually the opposite).
Plus, this view of work just doesn’t square with most people’s experience. It tends to reflect the outlook of white-collar professionals, especially those in the more “creative” fields, but would probably resonate less with the people who clean their offices or tend their gardens. For many, perhaps most, people work is primarily a means to providing for themselves and their families, not a creative adventure of self-exploration and fulfillment.
So, I think work could stand to be taken down a peg or two and Rivera y Carlo is right on that score. But I also have to take issue with his claim that “your marriage and family are the most important thing you will ever do. They, not what you do for a living, are your legacy.”
For a Christian (and Rivera y Carlo is writing as a Christian) our identity should be rooted first and foremost in our status as redeemed children of God. My own Lutheran tradition has been particularly good at emphasizing that, before God, we are passive – our staus is not secured by any work of our own, including being good spouses or parents.
Some evangelical Protestants seem to have embraced a kind of cult of the family, where it becomes a haven in a heartless (godless, secularist) world. Early Christianity was, however, rather subversive of family ties. As Camassia recently reminded us, romantic or sexual love should not be taken by Christians to be the highest good, and consequently neither should family life. What room is there in Rivera y Carlo’s scheme for those who, whether by choice or necessity, don’t marry? Do they contribute something valuable to the community?
Now, I wouldn’t deny that the sphere of the family is one of the primary places where we exercise Christian discipleship. Charity begins at home as they say. But the Gospel invites a relativization of all penultimate goods and ties, however much that may seem to go against our “natural” inclinations. By all means, lets depose the idol of work, but without replacing it with that of family.
-
Blue-State Secessionism
An fascinating article from Salon. Maybe they can make common cause with the League of the South?
The Vermont economist mentioned in the article, Thomas Naylor advocates a “peaceful, democratic, libertarian, grassroots movement opposed to the tyranny of the United States” and “the Vermont of small towns, small farms, small businesses, local governance, grass-roots democracy, green activism: Vermont as the gentle Switzerland of North America (but armed to the teeth, as Vermonters enjoy hunting in the woods).”
Naylor wrote an book along these themes with William Willimon (Duke chaplain, Methodist bishop and sometime collaborator with Stanley Hauerwas) called Downsizing the U.S.A., kind of a libertarianism meets E. F. Schumacher manifesto.
In principle, it’s hard to see why secession shouldn’t be permitted. If a group of people doesn’t want to live under the sovereignty of a larger political entity, why should they have to? Of course, how far down do you allow secession? Radical libertarians go so far as to advocate individual secession.
Plus, any state considering secession would have to reckon with the fact that the U.S. government would have claims to some of the land (national parks, etc.), much of the infastructure and other investments it had made. Would peaceful secession require the secessionists to buy out the feds? Another problem is the question of individuals who didn’t want to secede from the larger units. Would they be forced to come along or get out?
Still, an interesting idea to entertain.
-
Unintended Consequences
Radley Balko has a post very much worth reading on the inevitable consequences of war, no matter how well-intentioned.
Some highlights:
Let’s look at this in purely self-interested terms. What do you suppose is going to become of this little girl? Think she’ll dismiss her dead parents in light of the larger picture, this grand scheme to remap the Middle East? What do you suppose the prospects are, now, that we’ll win her over to our cause? What about her sister, who was also wounded? What about their extended family? Friends? Neighbors? What about moderate Arabs/Muslims who see this image on TV? …
I’ve written before that I think out troops are on par the most measured, humane, restrained military force in in history. I still think that. I think we do more to avoid collateral damage than can really be reasonably expected of us. We ought to be proud of that. But you know what? It doesn’t matter. Reality isn’t important. Perception is. My point with this picture isn’t “look at how brutal the United States is.” My point is, “what do you think the world’s billion Muslims think when they see this?” What happened before the picture doesn’t matter. What happens after doesn’t matter either. What matters is the picture. Screaming kid. Covered in blood. America killed her parents. For the people who we’re trying to win over, that’s the entire story.
Shit like this is always going to happen in war. No matter how well-intentioned the military waging it. It happens in every war, as do Mi Lais and Abu Ghraibs. It’s not the nature of America or the American military. It’s the nature ofwar. That’s why we’d better be damned sure any war we fight is essential only to defend us from grave, immediate harm, because even if it is all of that, shit’s going to happen to make new people hate us.
-
How Abortion Turned Conservatives Into Idealists
Or at least that’s what Jody Bottum suggests in this article on the President’s inagural speech:
No, President Bush’s opponents should be afraid of this speech because it signals the emergence of a single coherent philosophy within the conservative movement. Natural-law reasoning about the national moral character gradually disappeared from America in the generations after the Founding Fathers, squeezed out between a triumphant emotive liberalism, on the one side, and a defensive emotive Evangelicalism, on the other. Preserved mostly by the Catholics, natural law made its return to public discourse primarily through the effort to find a nontheological ground for opposition to abortion. And now, three decades after Roe v. Wade, it is simply the way conservatives talk–about everything. With his inaugural address, President Bush has just delivered a foreign-policy discourse that relies entirely on classical concepts of natural law, and, agreeing or not, everybody in America understood what he was talking about.
In other words, the argument over abortion changed the way the nation speaks of every moral issue. “We will persistently clarify the choice before every ruler and every nation: The moral choice between oppression, which is always wrong, and freedom, which is eternally right. America will not pretend that jailed dissidents prefer their chains, or that women welcome humiliation and servitude, or that any human being aspires to live at the mercy of bullies,” the president declares–and thereby carries natural law out to the world.
This is a claim about the universal, which the old foreign-policy realists rejected. This is a claim about the moral, which the libertarians despised. And this is a claim about the eternal, which the Social Darwinists renounced. But these older strains of conservatism have lost the battle to set the nation’s rhetoric. They are welcome to come along for the ride, but George W. Bush announced, there in the bright cold of a Washington January, that the nation would be moving to the beat of a different political philosophy.
The older conservative tradition, when it was influenced by Christian thought, tended to emphasize the fallenness of humankind, and the limits that imposed on our ability to reconstruct the social order according to some kind of abstract pattern. Bush’s vision (to the extent it really is his vision) seems to lack that older pessimism and skepticism about the limits of human power, and that’s what worries me.