Some belated MLK-day reading. Here’s Heather Gray on King’s theory of non-violent social change and Greg Moses on “King and the Christian Left” both from Counterpunch.
Author: Lee M.
-
The ELCA Sexuality Task Force: Who Won?
An interesting post from Get Religion on how various media outlets spun the story.
Of course, it is, as I understand it, still up to the churchwide assembly this summer to accept or reject the recommendations of the task force (though, I would be very surprised if the cwa took a more liberal line than the task force).
-
An Epistemology of the Spirit
By “epistemological imperialism” I mean demanding that a particular subject matter be knowable by means unsuited to it. We don’t expect the same precision from ethics that we expect from mathematics, and to insist upon that would be an instance of epistemological imperialism.
Likewise, the “brights” like Richard Dawkins demand that theology conform to the methods of the empirical sciences in order to be considered intellectually respectable. But what if the subject matter of theology is not amenable to those methods? Why should a single method be allowed to determine our entire ontology (what we think is real)?
There are good reasons, I think, for maintaining that God is not knowable by the methods of science. Science deals with what is observable, measurable and predictable (follows law-like patterns). God is not traditionally thought to be any of those things.
But this might sound like special pleading or begging the question. Alright, consider an analogy: in order to get to know another person, there are limits to what external observation can tell us. To really know someone they must reveal themselves to us. They can hide from us if they choose.
How much more would this be true of God, who exceeds us immeasurably in wisdom, power, knowledge and goodness? God’s utter transcendence virtually guarantees that he won’t be encompassable in our mundane categories of thought, or susceptible to our tools of inquiry. To demand that all that is must be knowable by the scientific method seems to exclude the divine a priori.
Moreover, can this epistemic principle – only science delivers truth – itself be demonstrated by the canons of science? It would seem not; how could such a sweeping principle be justified empirically? (This is really just a form of the traditional refutation of postivism.)
If God reveals himself as a person, then it may be that the disciplines of the self required to know God are different from the disciplines required to measure the distance between two stars. “Blessed are the pure in heart, for they will see God” may be an epistemic principle. The saints and mystics report that their sense of God’s presence was heightened – a kind of special training analogous to that of the scientist. And maybe most of us occupy a similar position with respect to the saints as we do to the scientists – we take what they report as testimony.
Pascal advocated that we “wager” on God’s existence. I don’t think he meant this as a stopping point, but as a starting point. He suggests that, in the face of uncertainty, we start along the path, trusting that as we proceed things will become clearer. If we put ourselves in the right position, gain the right dispositions and virtues (through prayer, meditation, study, the sacraments, works of charity, etc.) we will come to know God. Is this so different from the disciplines that any honest inquirer has to undertake?
-
Our Enemy, The State?
Just as Democrats are wondering how they can win over culturally conservative red-state voters, some of those very same cultural conservatives are questioning aspects of their alliance with political conservatism.
In the January issue of Touchstone, Gillis J. Harp (sorry, article not online) critiques conservatives like Rich Lowry of National Review for thinking that tax cuts and less government are the solution to every problem. The issue at hand in Harp’s article is how advertisers and the consumer culture have interposed themselves between parents and children. Conservatives like Lowry, according to Harp, blame “high taxes” for the fact that mothers can’t stay home and tend to the moral development of their children. But this ignores the plethora of other economic issues (wages, health care) that make it difficult for families to survive on a single income, not all of which can be blamed on big government (Incidentally, Harp seems to assume something I find questionable: Why is it ideal that mothers be the ones to stay home? Why not dads?).
Traditionalist conservatives have often been wary of a society too imbued with the spirit of commercialism (see, e.g. the novels of Evelyn Waugh), but the going assumption for many years has been that the enemy of the family and traditional virtues is the State first and foremost. This was the assumption that held the “fusionist” movement of libertarians and conservatives together during most of the Cold War.
But, as I suggested the other day, it may be that some conservatives have elevated an empirical generalization, viz. that government can corrode traditional bonds and undermine virute, into an unquestionable universal truth: government is always the problem.
As a universal truth this seems eminently questionable, and it ignores the importance of what we might call the “moral ecology” of a society. It might be here – in resisting the encroachments of an ever-present commercialized culture on family and private life – that cultural conservatives could find common cause with certain liberals. Ralph Nader, for one, has long been a foe of “the commericalization of childhood” – of aiming advertising at children at ever-younger ages. He has also decried the fact that many parents are unable to tend to family and community obligations because they are working more hours than ever to make ends meet (Nader has also opposed euthanasia on the grounds that profiteering HMOs will use it as an excuse to cut off care).
If there’s one thing conservatives should stand for, it should be healthy families and communities, and these ends may sometimes require protection from the market, not just the government.
-
Against Responsible Drinking
I’m not going to say that I agree with everything in this article, but surely there’s something to be said for a little carefree hedonism:
What we do have is a society in which sometimes, and for a variety of reasons, people like to drink to get drunk. Not because they think that wine goes better with dinner than Ribena; not because they want to relax a little after a hard day’s white-collar work; not because they believe the studies about a glass of red being good for their hearts (but two pints of lager being very bad indeed); but because they want to get off the plane of existence that is normal, humdrum, everyday life, and into that parallel universe of inebriation. What’s wrong with doing that once in a while? Nothing. Indeed, there is a good deal that is very right about it. …
It is not the consequences of drunkenness that make it a modern bogeyman, but its simple out-of-controlness. For a political class hell-bent on micro-management of all aspects of everyday life, in thrall to etiquette, suspicious of spontaneity, and living by the code of ‘everything in moderation’, the image of the carefree drunk is one that it cannot comprehend, still less empathise with. For the rest of us, for whom the odd bender is not a political statement but a welcome fact of life, we should resist the temptation to buy into the cult of ‘responsible drinking’ and remember what we are doing in the pub in the first place.
-
Move along, folks. Nothing here to see…
But you might want to check out Camassia on Eros and idolatry, or Disputations on free will (start here), or Keith Burgess-Jackson on “demi”-vegetarianism (hey, I’m one of those!).
-
True but Incomplete
I Am a Christian Too on science and religion. (See also Bill Keezer on Intelligent Design and the Anthropic Principle.)
I’m in basic agreement with IACT’s position – science gives us a true picture of the world, but a partial one. The kind of epistemological imperialism practiced by Dawkins, et al. is wholly unjustifiable. Huston Smith once compared it to thinking that a very detailed map of the greater Chicago area could substitute for a map of the United States.
There are more things in heaven and earth, Horatio…
-
The Future of the GOP: Populist or Royalist?
Reihan Salam thinks they would do well to address the economic concerns of those middle- and working-class socially conservative voters who are putting them in office. “Get the government off our backs” doesn’t resonate with these voters as much as it might have in the 80s.
Alternatively, a moderately socially conservative Democrat Party could pick off many of these voters if, e.g. the costs of healthcare and child-rearing become too onerous. The GOP has benefitted from the Dems’ scorched earth commitment to abortion rights and other elements of an anti-traditionalist cultural agenda, but the D’s may be wising up.
My diagnosis is that conservatives have turned shrinking government from being a means (to revitalizing communities and private initiative) to an end in itself. But no sane conservative thinks we can do without government entirely. And libertarian zeal for smashing the state appeals to few people beyond a small group of ideologues and think-tankers.