Author: Lee M.
-
All Saints
O Almighty God, who hast knit together thine elect in one communion and fellowship in the mystical body of thy Son Christ our Lord: Grant us grace so to follow thy blessed saints in all virtuous and godly living, that we may come to those ineffable joys which thou hast prepared for those who unfeignedly love thee; through the same Jesus Christ our Lord, who with thee and the Holy Spirit liveth and reigneth, one God, in glory everlasting. Amen. — BCP, traditional -
A paleocon Democrat in the Senate?
I admit that I haven’t followed the Virginia Senate race between George Allen and Jim Webb very closely. I knew Webb was a former Republican and Reagan Administration official who opposed the Iraq war, but I assumed that meant he was some kind of centrist Republican. Turns out, though, that he’s got a long history of what might best be described as right-wing populism: railing against leftist cultural elites, corrupt politicians, fat cat CEOs, and “chickenhawk” war planners who never wore a uniform.
Andrew Ferguson wonders how a blood-and-soil conservative who named his son after Robert E. Lee became the darling of Virginia’s Democratic party elite. Ross Douthat speculates that Webb could become the standard bearer of populism against the elite policy consensus of Hillary Clinton and John McCain in 2008.
-
Further Reformation Day reflections
LutherPunk and Without Authority both have worthwhile stuff to say on the issue of Protestant/Lutheran identity.
-
Whither Protestantism?
October 31st is traditionally observed, at least in Lutheran and some other Protestant churches, as “Reformation Day.” The idea is to commemorate Martin Luther’s posting of his 95 theses and the unofficial beginning of the Reformation.However, in these more ecumenical times, the triumphalism of Reformation Days past is significantly muted. The legacy of the Reformation seems to many Protestants to be an ambiguous one, and the shattering of the unity of the church something to be mourned rather than celebrated. Not to mention all the bloodshed that came in the wake of Christendom’s breakup.
Indeed, “catholic” has become a term that many Protestants have embraced with gusto in recent years. Everyone likes to think of themselves as catholic now, whereas the stock of being “protestant” seems to have declined. Some Lutherans, for example, prefer to be called “evangelical catholics.” The recently re-christened Episcopal Church (formerly ECUSA) dropped the “protestant” from their name (they used to be PECUSA) some time ago.
So what is the essence of Protestantism, and is there any point in still identifying ourselves as Protestants? Is it defined by adherence to the principle of sola scriptura or justification by faith alone? Both of these have been called into serious question by recent theology. A more positive view of tradition has undermined the biblicism implicit in some versions of the sola scriptura principle, and many theologians and biblical scholars have questioned whether justification was quite so central to Paul’s theology, and by implication, whether it should be so central to ours. This isn’t to say that there aren’t still able defenders of the traditional Protestant positions around, but the consensus that once existed has, I think it’s safe to say, been considerably weakened.
Some might identify the raison d’etre of Reformation theology with Paul Tillich’s “protestant principle,” the principle of criticism and the willingness to reexamine all absolutist claims and belief systems, be they papal, scriptural, or of any other ideological stripe. But this runs the risk of turning Protestantism into a purely formal exercise without substantive content. A debased version of Tillich’s principle finds expression in contemporary cliches about asking questions being more important than finding answers.
At the end of the day I imagine that many people are Protestants in large part because Catholicism or Orthodoxy don’t seem like live options for one reason or another. Either they don’t or can’t accept their claims to authority or their particular moral positions, or those churches just seem culturally alien. But these are largely negative judgments. What are the positive reasons, if any, for staying Protestant? What vision of Christianity does Protestantism have to offer to the larger church?
-
Putting the conserve back in conservatism
The Boston Globe ran an article yesterday on the attempt by some activists to reach out to evangelicals on environmental issues. A new documentary “The Great Warming” is aimed at least in part directly at mainstream conservative Christians and features appearances by Richard Cizik, an official at the National Association of Evangelicals.
It’s fairly easy to see why a Christian should oppose the despoilation of God’s creation. What’s less frequently mentioned is that environmental protection ought naturally to be a conservative position too. After all, you’d think conservatives would be all about conserving things. At one time this was widely acknowledged. Russell Kirk, the intellectual godfather of modern conservatism, was very much a lover of nature and opponent of paving over green places in the name of the free market. One of Kirk’s paragons of conservatism was staunch conservationist Teddy Roosevelt.
Another seminal early conservative thinker, Richard Weaver, once said that the difference between the radical and the conservative was that the former saw reality as infinitely plastic and amenable to the human will, whereas the latter respected the order of reality as a given and something that the human will should conform itself to. In these terms, respecting the integrity of the natural world would be the conservative position, while seeing it as so much raw material for human projects would be the radical view.
One might also point out (and I have) that the spirit that animates conservative positions on, say, abortion, euthanasia, and the exploitation of human embryos for research should naturally yield a hesitance to exploit the natural world through unrestrained economic development, genetic engineering, and unbridled technological “progress.” In other words, a worldview that takes the intrinsic value of life as a fundamental axiom might end up being both “pro-life” and “green.” Green icon E.F. Schumacher, for instance, was also a devout Catholic and articulated just such an affinity. However, in today’s political taxonomy these two groups are largely on opposite sides of the political spectrum (though phenomena like “Crunchy Cons” may indicate that change is afoot).
So, I think the intellectual connections between conservatism and “creation care” are already there, but we all know that ideas are not the only thing that drives politics (to say the least). TR-style conservationism doesn’t have much of a foothold in the current GOP. However, if a significant block of traditionally conservative voters such as evangelicals make environmental issues a high priority, we may see some change at the political level. What the Globe article and others I’ve read on the same topic don’t make clear is to what extent environmental issues have penetrated down to the grass-roots of evangelicalism, or if this is a phenomenon largely confined to the intelligensia.
-
Dinner with Bishop Wright
So, yesterday at about four o’clock I received a somewhat cryptic e-mail from the curate of our church asking if I had gotten the invitation to “dinner with Bishop Wright.” I hadn’t received any such thing and, intrigued, I gave him a call. And it turned out, yes, he meant that Bishop Wright, the Bishop of Durham, famed NT scholar and churchman. The good bish is in town giving a series of lectures at Harvard Memorial Church and had graciously agreed to have dinner with a group of folks from the Advent.
Naturally I was very excited at the opportunity and hopped on the T after work to meet up with everyone at the John Harvard Brew House in Harvard Square. Bishop Wright and his wife were there along with about twenty of us from the Church of the Advent. He entertained questions about everything from the state of the Episcopal Church and the broader Anglican communion, to pacifism and the idea of a global peacekeeping force, to the polarization of American politics. Obviously a really brilliant guy and also very engaging and humble.
I got the chance to ask him about how he thought Christians should put forth a political agenda in a pluralistic society, in light of some of the fears of “theocracy” that have been bandied about. He was very dismissive of such talk and basically said that you have to put all the cards on the table, including those relating to God. He also spoke of the need to de-couple what he called a “right-of-center theology” (by which I take it he meant robustly realistic and traditional views of the Resurrection, Atonement, person of Christ, etc.) from an automatic pairing with right-wing politics. In his view there are good elements in the agendas of both the Right and the Left and Christians shouldn’t automatically line up behind one or the other. He also spoke extremely well of Rowan Williams as someone in the UK who has been able to cross political lines in a way that enables him to speak to those in power from a truly independent standpoint.
Even though I can’t claim to be a great devotee of his work in that I’ve only read (I think) one of Bishop Wright’s books (though I’ve liked what I read), it was still a fantastic opportunity to meet him and a lot of fun to boot.
-
Taking Ahmadinejad seriously
Not what you might think. The always-interesting Paul Griffiths asks what would happen if American Christians took seriously the Iranian president’s advice to President Bush (whether sincerely intended or not) that he be guided above all else by his professed faith.
-
The immortality diet
This article about one writer’s attempt to practice the so-called Calorie Restriction Diet is very interesting. The CR diet, which essentially entails keeping one’s caloric intake to near-starvation levels has a fair bit of scientific evidence indicating that it may substantially increase one’s lifespan.
Indeed, some of the practicioners seem to think it could provide the gateway to immortality, in conjunction with “the Singularity” (aka the Rapture for nerds):
“Kurzweil thinks we will reach actuarial escape velocity pretty soon,” says Don. “What do you think, Michael?”
Michael pauses to collect his thoughts, and while he does, let’s fill in a blank or two. Ray Kurzweil is an occasionally best-selling futurist, given to flamboyant but well-researched predictions about the “transhumanist” century ahead of us, in which hyperbrainy artificial intelligence, fiendishly intricate nanorobotry, genome-twiddling Frankentech, and other incipient techno-marvels combine to reinvent humanity in the image of the machine. Swirling in the midst of it all is the key concept of “actuarial escape velocity,” a transhumanist term for that moment in the acceleration of biomedical progress when, for every year you live, technology adds another year or more to your maximum life span. It’s a tipping point that, theoretically at least, never stops tipping.
“I would like to hope 50 to 100 years,” says Michael, speaking carefully. He’s well aware what kind of weight that his day job, assisting the maverick life-extension theorist Aubrey de Grey, gives his words with people like Don. “Fifty to 100 years,” says Don, chewing thoughtfully on his lip. “That may be too late for me.”
“It may be too late for me,” says Michael. But the truth is, once you accept that actuarial escape velocity is out there waiting for you, a single point in time that marks the gates of immortality, it’s never too late to hope your life will intersect with it—and there isn’t much you wouldn’t do to minimize your chances of missing it by so much as a day. With stakes like that in play, even a lifetime of hunger seems a small price to pay.
By the end of the article the author has given up on the CR diet, in no small part due to his increasing awareness of the cult-like qualities of its adherent. He then offers some reflections on why someone like him would be attracted to such an apparently extreme lifestyle:
I know: What was I thinking? But do you really need to ask? The workings of a heart and mind like mine are no mystery. I’m your average midlife secular professional—reasonably well adjusted, as the profile goes—a little tightly wound, but aren’t we all? Like the tail-end baby- boomer I also am, I grow more intimate each day with the fears of mortality already gripping the rest of my generation, and lacking spiritual faith, I am perhaps inordinately susceptible to scientific promises of longer, healthier life. I’m of the generation that made marathon running a popular pastime, for God’s sake, so fleshly discomfort in the name of self-involved achievement is a surprisingly easy sell. Throw in a promise that any undue pain and suffering will be masked or compensated by a psychic well-being possibly chemical in origin, and the deal is just about clinched.
I won’t belabor the point: Just take a good look around your neighborhood, your place of work, your therapist’s waiting room. Take a good look in the mirror maybe, too. That ought to be enough to tell you CR’s growth from cult to subculture to fact of mainstream cultural life is not so unimaginable. Yes, CR flies in the face of common sense, but it’s got the preponderance of scientific evidence on its side. Yes, it’s a little crazy, but the crazinesses it requires are only those already endemic to our age and area code. And yes, by any objective standard, the food is lousy, but believe me: Starve yourself long enough and even a tofu-coffee-macadamia-nut-and-flaxseed smoothie becomes ambrosia.
So if you’ve read this far and still think you could never, ever, do what my five dinner guests do to themselves every day, don’t kid yourself. I’ve seen the future, and it’s hungry.
The obvious angle here is the secular loss of faith in anything beyond death leading to a frantic grasping at scientific promises of immortality. But there’s also a class angle. Working-class people, in my experience, are much more fatalistic about the body’s limits and its eventual breakdown. Middle and upper-class professionals, by contrast, see these as problems to be overcome by means of some technocratic fix. As Christopher Lasch wrote in his book The True and Only Heaven, working class culture is more attuned to the idea that life has certain inherent limits. Not everything in the human condition is a problem to be overcome; some aspects of it are there to be suffered.
But there is a tension here that isn’t easily resolvable in one direction or the other. No one thinks that we should simply accept disease, suffering, physical and mental breakdown, etc. as facts of life and do nothing to alleviate their effects. Awareness of life’s limits can become fatalism. On the other hand, quests for a kind of techno-immortality can lead people both to employ immoral means in its pursuit and to confuse quantity of life with quality (to take a trivial example: would you want to live forever if it meant you had to eat the kind of food prescribed by the CR diet?).
Christianity has generally held these two impulses in tension, without fully giving in to one or the other. Alleviating suffering has always been regarded as a good, as Jesus’s healings and the church’s commitment to works of mercy demonstrate. But this life is not an end in itself, or something to be prolonged at all costs. Christians have been taught to sit loosely to this life, being willing to suffer and even die as witnesses to their faith, with the confidence that there is something greater in store beyond the limits of the present world.
Maybe these tendencies can be held together because confidence in the resurrection allows Christians not to be anxious about their own survival, thus freeing them to attend to the needs of others. Christianity has never been primarily about extending one’s own life – that’s God’s business. Becuase our lives are hidden with Christ, we’re free to be “little Christs” to our neighbors, as Luther put it. By contrast, secular schemes for immortality like the CR diet end up being incredibly self-centered. How do you have time for your neighbor when you’re so busy obsessing about your caloric intake?
-
Diocese of Mass: Just say no to marriage?
Some priests in the Episcopal diocese of Massachusetts are sponsoring a resolution to be considered at the upcoming diocesan convention that would get the church out of the business of marrying people. Instead, couples would have to get married by a justice of the peace and could then come to the church for a blessing if they wanted.
Depending on who you talk to, this is either a blow for equality or an act of devotion to the principle of the separation of church and state. Either way, Unitarian Universalist blogger Philocrites isn’t impressed.
-
Living in the Berkeley of the East Coast
Someone told me the other day that in something like 80% of the congressional races in Massachusetts there is no Republican even running. However, in my district, the incumbent Democrat, Michael Capuano, is not running unopposed. It just so happens that his opponent is running on the Socialist Workers Party ticket.
We also have three local non-binding resolutions on the ballot (these are in addition to the statewide ballot questions). One is a call to withdraw from Iraq and the other two have to do with divestment from Israel. Who would’ve thought our local precincts would have their own foreign policy?
