Author: Lee M.

  • Friday metal mayhem

    Read a review of the new Trivium album, Crusade in the Metro this morning. You can listen to it streaming on AOL here (don’t know how long that link will be good for). Sounds fantastic, especially if, like me, you’re a big fan of 80s thrash metal (early Metallica, Megadeth, Anthrax, etc.).

    And don’t tell me that cover art isn’t awesome.

  • Story of my life

    I’m going to flagrantly rip off Marvin and write my own “political autobiography” post, for my own benefit as much as anyone else’s.

    As Marvin points out in recounting a conversation with his right-of-center friend, location, if not everything, is something. I spent the late 90s and early 00s in two of the most left-wing environments imaginable: academia and Berkeley (though not at the same time). Naturally I became a conservative. 😉 I don’t know if it was the insufferable complacency of my lefty colleagues or a natural disposition to being contrarian, but I started reading National Review, the Weekly Standard, Commentary, and First Things (as a concession to liberalism I also subscribed to the New Republic). I started digging into conservative political thought: Kirk, Weaver, Hayek, von Mises, Nisbet, Sowell, Friedman and other stuff you don’t typically find on your grad school syllabus. (The one political theory class offered in my graduate program was pretty much all Marxism and John Rawls was about as far right as the spectrum of permissible political positions seemed to extend.)

    At this time I was a religious agnostic, but found myself gravitating toward a conservatism heavily tinged with libertarianism. In 2000 I voted for George W. Bush with some trepidation, but my concerns were mostly from the Right. In my view the Bush campaign represented at best an uneasy alliance between ideological conservatism of the National Review variety and the old-fashioned Rockefeller Republicanism of his father. I voted for him primarily on the grounds that he was, ostensibly, committed to free trade and a less interventionist foreign policy (oh how naive I was!) and seemed to be a moderate social conservative.

    Then came the move to Berkeley in early 2001. If conservative thought was not so much unwelcome as ignored in my grad school experience, in the Bay Area a registered Republican ranked somewhere just above a child molester in the scale of popularity. I also sat through some sermons at our very left-wing Lutheran church that set my teeth on edge, as you might imagine.

    But 9/11 changed, if not everything, at least some things. Though I supported the campaign in Afghanistan at the time, I was alarmed by what seemed to be the Bush administration’s cavalier attitude toward civil liberties and, eventually, its obvious desire to widen the theatre of war well beyond the pursuit of al-Qaeda and its confederates. By the time the run up to the Iraq war began I was firmly in “opposition” mode.

    Another important change in the way that I looked at the world was a embrace of Christianity after wrestling with the question off and on for the better part of a decade. I started to reevaluate certain positions I held, realizing that secular conservatism sometimes seems more interested in religion as a prop for the social order than in its truth claims. And whatever the correct policies were for addressing, say, poverty or the environment, it occurred to me that a Christian approach to them was not necessarily going to coincide with the ones favored by many political conservatives. At the very least I was willing to look at liberal positions with fresh eyes. (I also blame my wife for forcing me to take bleeding-heart liberal positions more seriously.)

    At this point I haven’t really re-thought a lot of my fundamental views on, say, economics or the scope of government so much as I’ve been continually dismayed by the way the GOP has behaved in power. I’ve become sharply attuned to the failures of “actually existing” conservatism you might say. I don’t think I need to rehash all that for anyone who’s read this blog over the last couple of years. Suffice it to say that I now find myself agreeing with the analysis coming out of liberal and Left organs much more frequently than those of the establishment Right, at least on the (to me) crucial issues of foreign policy, civil liberties, executive power, and the treatment of prisoners. So, I don’t know if that puts me on “the left” or just makes me a disgruntled conservative. For the forseeable future it may not make much difference.

  • Revolutionary pamphleteers as proto-bloggers

    I started reading Bernard Bailyn’s fascinating book The Ideological Origins of the American Revolution and was struck by his description of pamphleteering as the primary means by which revolutionary ideas were spread:

    It was in this form — as pamphlets — that much of the most important and characteristic writing of the American Revolution appeared. For the Revolutionary generation, as for its predecessors back to the early sixteenth century, the pamphlet had peculiar virtues as a medium of communication. Then, as now, it was seen that the pamphlet allowed one to do things that were not possible in any other form.

    Bailyn offers this quote from Orwell:

    The pamphlet is a one-man show. One has complete freedom to be scurrilous, abusive, and seditious; or, on the other hand, to be more detailed, serious and “high-brow” than is ever possible in a newspaper or in most kinds of periodicals. At the same time, since the pamphlet is always short and unbound, it can be produced much more quickly than a book, and in principle, at any rate, can reach a bigger public. Above all, the pamphlet does not have to follow any prescribed pattern. It can be in prose or verse, it can consist largely of maps or statistics or quotations, it can take the form of a story, a fable, a letter, an essay, a dialogue, or a piece of “reportage.” All that is required of it is that it shall be topical, polemical, and short.

    Bailyn continues:

    The pamphlet’s greatest asset was perhaps its flexibility in size, for while it could contain only a very few pages and hence be used for publishing short squibs and sharp, quick rebuttals, it could also accomodate much longer, more serious and permanent writing as well. Some pamphlets of the Revolutionary period contain sixty or even eighty pages, on which are printed technical, magisterial treatises. Between the extremes of the squib and the book-length treatise, however, there lay the most commonly used, the ideally convenient length: from 5,000 to 25,000 words, printed on anywhere from ten to fifty pages, quarto or octavo in size.

    The pamphlet of this middle length was perfectly suited to the needs of the Revolutionary writers. It was spacious enough to allow for the full development of an argument — to investigate premises, explore logic, and consider conclusions; it could accomodate the elaborate involutions of eighteenth-century literay forms; it gave range for the publication of fully-wrought, leisurely-paced sermons; it could conveniently carry state papers, collections of newspaper columns, and strings of correspondence. It was in this form, consequently, that “the best thought of the day expressed itself”; it was in this form that “the solid framework of constitutional thought” was developed; it was in this form that “the basic elements of American political thought of the Revolutionary period appeared first.” And yet pamphlets of this length were seldom ponderous; whatever the gravity of their themes or the spaciousness of their contents, they were always essentially polemical, and aimed at immediate and rapidly shifting targets: at suddenly developing problems, unanticipated arguments, and swiftly rising, controversial figures. The best of the writing that appeared in this form, consquently, had a rare combination of spontaneity and solidity, of dash and detail, of casualness and care. (pp. 2-4)

    Bailyn goes on to identify three main types of pamphlet: the direct response to a current event, the “chain-reacting polemic” – a series of back-and-forth debates “which characteristically proceeded with increasing shrillness until it ended in bitter personal vituperation,” (my emphasis) and ritualistic commemorative orations.

    At any rate, I think it’s clear that if the Revolutionary generation had lived today they would’ve been ardent bloggers. 😉

  • The theologian as amateur economist

    Usually any book review symposium will have a mix of negative and positive reviews, but the one on Kathryn Tanner’s Economy of Grace in the most recent Journal of Lutheran Ethics – not exactly a right-wing rag – has four pretty scathing reviews.

    In fairness, I haven’t read Prof. Tanner’s book, but if these reviews are at all accurate it sounds like she may be guilty of what seems to be a common failing among theologians who write about economics – being long on moral prescription and short on actually coming to grips with the findings of the discipline.

    I’m not saying that economists are infallible – far from it. But we can’t simply wish away things like scarcity and trade offs because they don’t gel with the way we think the world should be. If economics provides an accurate – if partial – understanding of the way the world works, then Christians should use that knowledge to help craft policies that make people better off.

    For a good introduction to a variety of Christian perspectives on these issues I’d recommend the book Wealth, Poverty, and Human Destiny, edited by Doug Bandow and David Schindler.

  • Blood Mountain

    Naturally one is a bit suspicious of any metal album that receives accolades from indie/hipster types, but I have to say that Mastodon’s new album Blood Mountain is pretty darn incredible.

    The critical hype about them being the second coming of Metallica (circa 1986) may be a bit overstated, but their dizzying mix of thrash, power, death, and prog elements is impressive (actually, the drumming along might be worth the price of the CD).

    Plus, the album’s about, well, a blood mountain. I mean, c’mon!

  • McPherson’s Grace at this Time

    Last week I read C.W. McPherson’s short book Grace at this Time, which is an explanation and commendation of the Daily Office as a form of daily prayer for Christians. The practice of the daily office – a structured form of daily prayer consisting of a prescribed order of psalms and readings with responses and prayers – can be traced back to early Christian practice and even arguably has roots in Judaism. McPherson gives a brief historical overview of the development of the office, tracing the evolution of “cathedral” and “monastic” forms of the office culminating with Thomas Cranmer’s reform of the monastic offices into the simplified morning and evening prayer services found in the Book of Common Prayer.

    McPherson provides a walk-through of morning prayer (which is, in his view, the paradigmatic office) as well as a brief theology and spirituality of the office. Though the office is designed as a form of corporate prayer, McPherson emphasizes its usefulness as a form of personal devotion. The office, he argues, provides a certain stability in our prayer life as well as keeping us from getting bogged down in subjectivity. It does this be mandating a disciplined encounter with the Bible (through the praying of the Psalms and the lectionary readings) and by connecting us to the rich theological and liturgical tradition of the church.

    One interesting point McPherson makes is that the office is compatible with a variety of spiritualities. For instance, he says, the psalms and lessons can be approached in the spirit of the monasitc practice of lectio divina. And he recommends introducing periods of silence for meditation and free prayer, especially when praying alone.

    If the publishing industry is any indication, lots of people from various traditons have found a new interest in praying some form of the office. There has been a proliferation of books about this form of prayer as well as various specialty versions (Celtic versions, versions for times of grieving, etc.). McPherson’s book is helpful in laying bare the structure that unites various forms of the office and why it takes the form that it does. In essence, it’s a conversation with God wherin we alternate between hearing God’s word and responding (often using the words of the Bible to do so, as in the canticles).

    The form of the office that McPherson recommends is that found in the current version of the US Book of Common Prayer, but most of what he says would apply to other versions just as well, at least as far as I can tell. I for one still find the BCP office a bit daunting in its rubrics and page-flipping, much less some of the more elaborate versions like the Roman Catholic Liturgy of the Hours, or the Anglican Breviary. However, it’s hard to take exception to the prescription of a daily dose of psalmody and scripture readings framed by some of the classic prayers of the Christian church.

    There are a variety of simplified office books available, though most of them don’t seem to provide the range of scripture that one would get in using the BCP version. If one wanted to do a stripped-down version of the office one could simply follow the lectionary readings with appointed psalms and supplement them with the Lukan canticles, Lord’s Prayer, and perhaps the creed, though that wouldn’t get you the variety that the full version provides.

  • A few links with notes

    In comments to this post, *Christopher commended the work of Catholic theologian James Alison. A quick Google search reveals that many of his writings are available online here. I’m somewhat wary of people who rely too much on Rene Girard’s work, only because they often give off a vibe of “Girard has figured out everything!”, but Alison seems like he’s up to some interesting stuff. I’ve printed out this article on the Atonement and hope to read it over the weekend.

    Derek the beer-snob has a link to an interesting piece from the rector of St. Mary the Virgin church in NYC on traditional and revisionist language about God.

    I think I basically come down in the middle here. I’m for traditional language to name the Trinity, especially in the context of worship, but am open to exploring feminine imagery in our language about God and can see the merit of avoiding gender-specific terms when it doesn’t distort theological truth. The key, it seems to me, is that our language should be a response to God’s self-revelation, not something we make up to feel better about ourselves.

    At Faith and Theology Kim Fabricius has ten provocative propositions on peace and war. I might quibble with the notion that the church simply became hopelessly compromised when it sold out to “Constantinianism”; I think this division of church history into pristine “pre-Constantinian” and corrupt “post-Constantinian” eras often fails to take seriously church tradition (not to mention one wonders what it says about our doctrine of Providence). Just war theory, after all, has as long a pedigree in the church as many other post-biblical developments that few would want to throw out.

  • Ward on Original Sin and Atonement

    Previously we saw Keith Ward offer an account of original sin that he thinks consistent with a broad evolutionary picture. As a result of a primal choice for evil and turning away from God, the human race finds itself estranged from God and unable to repair the breach.

    Ward distinguishes between what he calls “forensic” and “soterial” accounts of sin. Forensic accounts are chiefly concerned with guilt and punishment, while soterial accounts focus on the way in which the self’s dispositions and inclinations are warped and in need of healing. A purely forensic understanding of sin sees spiritual death as punishment which we have incurred on account of our first parents’ sin. A soterial view, on the other hand, sees our alienation from God and the distortion of our desires as the inevitable consequence of sin rather than a punishment imposed according to a retributive understanding of justice.

    The Christian tradition has both forensic and soterial elements, but certain strands emphasize one or the other more heavily. Ward sides with the Christian East (as I understand it) in rejecting the idea of original guilt (as distinct from original sin) and sees the problem for humans more in terms of repairing or healing the self and its relation to God. Original sin is “more like a disease or an incapacity than a crime” (p. 176). And he’s on solid Reformational ground, it seems to me, in holding sin to be not so much a series of discrete acts, but a fundamental orientation of the self – “curved inward” as Luther might put it. This self-centeredness is a result of the evil choices made by our ancestors and the fact that each of us is born into a world where it’s difficult to resist out selfish desires and in which our relationship with God has been shattered.

    Consequently, Ward’s account of the Atonement avoids penal or debt-payment metaphors and emphasizes images of participation and healing. As the Incarnate Word of God, Jesus mediates God’s saving grace and forgiveness, making a new relationship possible. Jesus is both the perfect human response to God and a revelation of God’s compassion. Jesus’ life of perfect obedience, which culminates on the cross, results in his Resurrection and the outpouring of the Spirit. This makes possible our participation in new life with God. Salvation must involve a change in the subject and not just a remittance of punishment. The purpose of God’s act of Atonement, in Ward’s telling, is to restore humans to a proper relationship with God and to heal their disordered desires.

    In Jesus, according to Christian belief, God acts in a uniquely clear, unhampered way, to evoke repentance by revealing the divine nature as suffering, redemptive, unitive love. God acts to show the life that is required of us, to establish a community in which such a life can be begun, to show that the human goal of divine-human fellowship is possible, and to draw people into such fellowship. Thus there will be particular, historical acts that establish this community, founded on a primal revelatory event in which divine-human fellowship is archetypally established. The Spirit is the power which made that event possible, as the icon, and formative pattern of the Spirit’s continued co-operative action throughout the world.

    On this view, atonement, the liberation of human lives by God from selfish desire and their uniting in fellowship with the life of God, is necessary if human nature is to attain its intended fulfillment. Such atonement must involve the disclosure of God’s patient bearing of the sufferings of the world (a sacrifice or giving-up of unmixed bliss for the sake of the possible goods of human life). It must involve God’s revealing the pattern of perfected human life in God (a life of healing and forgiveness). It must also involve God’s effective transformation of humans from self-regard to the love of supreme beauty, in accordance with that pattern (the gift of the Spirit). This revelation must come in a particular history and context that is able to manifest God’s particular actions in the world, actions which begin and define the particular process of forgiveness and fulfillment that constitutes the Christian life. (p. 223)

    This, in a nutshell, appears to be Ward’s answer to Anselm’s question “why did God become man?” He eschews penal or satisfaction motifs and appeals to what in some ways seems a more patristic understanding: God became human so that humans might become divine. The problem – that from which we need to be saved – is our estrangement from God. In Jesus God restores the possibility of fellowship. But, unlike certain patristic accounts which seem to rely on a reified Platonic notion of human nature, Ward’s appeal to the Spirit as the means by which we are healed and united with God and conformed to the image of Christ may be a more biblical way to think about it.

    To connect it back to evolution, we can say that God created a world intended to give rise, through a long process of historical evolution, to finite personal beings capable of enjoying fellowship with God. However, due to a pre-historic choice of self over God, humanity’s progress toward that goal was derailed and we became alienated from God. But God comes to us in the person of Jesus to re-establish that relationship and get the human project back on track and to guide it toward its goal.

    Clearly some aspects of Ward’s account deviate from the tradition. The rejection of hereditary guilt may bother those who understand sin and atonement in primarily forensic terms. However, it’s worth pointing out that, evolution aside, there’s never really been a compelling account of how someone can be guilty (and even deserving of damnation) because of a choice their distant ancestors made. Ward’s view manages to retain the insight that we are suffering the consequences of our ancestor’s choices and in need of deliverance from them, without embracing the notion of original guilt. His view also resonates with the Christus Victor motif in seeing humanity in need of rescue from “powers” that hold us in thrall and prevent us from establishing fellowship with God.

  • The road to hell, etc.

    With Iraq as Exhibit A, U of Chicago law prof Eric Posner (son of Richard, I think) argues for a presumption against “humanitarian” war in the Washington Post.

    Many well-meaning people – often, but not exclusively liberals – who otherwise tend to be “anti-war” find themselves with an itchy trigger finger when it comes to humanitarian disasters. But here, as elsewhere, policies have to be judged not by their proponents’ good intentions, but by those policies’ likely consequences.

    Link via Matthew Yglesias.