Author: Lee M.

  • Spare me

    I was pretty sure I didn’t want to see Borat, but this clinches it for me. Low-brow humor I can take, but pretentious and self-righterous low-brow humor – no thanks.

    Anyway, America has got to be among the least anti-Semitic countries in the world by any standard I can think of.

    I did watch a few episodes of the Ali G show and thought they were pretty funny. But it’s way funnier to make fun of Newt Gingrich and Boutros-Boutros Ghali to their faces than some guys in a cowboy bar. I mean, the latter is not exactly daring, is it?

  • How to get out of Iraq?

    A proposal from Sen. Russ Feingold. (via ACBfP)

    Even though I was unsupportive of the original decision to go to war, I’ve only grudgingly been swayed toward the cut-and-run option. But more and more it seems to me that the longer we stay the more likely we’ll end up backing one side or the other of what will no doubt be a very dirty civil war.

    Also, instead on relying on the “Wise Men” of the Iraq Study Group to save us from our folly (for doubts about that see here and here), wouldn’t it be nice if our actual elected representatives were to take the lead on this?

  • More thoughts on Chadwick’s The Early Church

    John Henry Newman once said that “To be deep in history is to cease to be Protestant.” Now, I’m certainly not going to claim to be “deep” into early church history after having read Chadwick’s The Early Church (along with a few other books along the way), but I think I can see what Newman was getting at. At least a certain kind of Protestant – the kind that sees little difference between the early church and his contemporary “Bible church” – is going to find a lot that’s hard to swallow in the early church history. The roots of things like Roman primacy, the threefold office of ministry, and Marian devotion may not exactly go back to the New Testament itself, but they certainly appear early on. It’s simply not possible to see everything “catholic” as some kind of late-medieval distortion of the unvarnished pure gospel.

    However, I’m also inclined to turn Newman’s aphorism around at him. Reading Chadwick, hardly a radical deconstructionist historian, it’s hard to resist the impression that the “undivided early church” much beloved of C/catholic (including Anglo-Catholic and “evangelical catholic”) apologetics is at least in part an ideological construct. Rather than the serene consensus of orthodoxy, the early church looks more like a tradition in the way Alasdair MacIntyre defined it: “an argument extended through time.” And a fractious, intemperate, and at times violent one at that. Everything was hotly contensted by somebody at some point and there wasn’t any universally agreed upon court of final appeals, be it Bible, papacy, or church council. The boundaries between othrodoxy and heresy were in many cases quite fuzzy, and even “ecumencial” councils like Nicea and Chalcedon had their fair share of critics, not all of whom can easily be dismissed as out-and-out heretics. In some respects the early church ends up looking pretty “Protestant.”

  • Eyewitnesses to Jesus

    Great interview with British NT scholar and theologian Richard Bauckham at the blog Chrisendom discussing Bauckham’s new book Jesus and the Eyewitnesses.

    The book, in a nutshell:

    The historical argument (most of the book) is that the eyewitnesses of the events of the Gospel history remained, throughout their lives, the authoritative sources and guarantors of the traditions about Jesus, and that the texts of our Gospels are much closer to the way the eyewitnesses told their stories than has been generally thought since the rise of form criticism. I also argue that the Gospels have ways, largely unnoticed before now, of indicating their own eyewitness sources, and I present new evidence for believing Papias’ claim that Mark’s Gospel was based on Peter’s preaching. Although the book’s conclusions support rather traditional views of the Gospels, much of the argument is quite fresh. The book also breaks new ground in Gospel studies by engaging with modern psychological research on eyewitness memory.

    The theological argument is that the category of testimony offers a category for the Gospels that is both historiographically and theologically appropriate, and a way beyond the dichotomy of the Jesus of history and the Christ of faith. Jesus as presented by eyewitnesses participants in his history, for whom empirical fact and meaning were interrelated from the beginning, are the kind of access to Jesus that Christian faith requires.

    Sounds really interesting! Earlier this fall I read Bauckham’s God Crucified (review here), where he makes a somewhat similar argument that the earliest Christology was also the highest Christology. Rather than positing a long process of development from seeing Jesus as a Spirit-filled man or adopted Son of God to the full blown incarnational Christology of Nicea and Chalcedon, Bauckham argues that early Christians were able to combine a high Christology with rigorous Jewish monotheism. Bauckham uses the category of “divine identity” to show how a high Christology can exist without employing the metaphysical categories that have long bedeviled these discussions. He contends that this is what early Jewish Christians did by attributing to Jesus the very attributes which are unique to the divine identity.

  • Conservatism – wha’ happened?

    Former National Review board member and trustee Austin Bramwell writes about what he sees as the dead end of conservatism. No one is spared – neither neocons nor paleocons – but Bramwell reserves his harshest criticisms for NR, the flagship journal of American conservatism, for becoming, in his view, unserious about, well, pretty much everything.

    What’s not clear is what, if anything, Bramwell would put in place of what he takes to be the wreckage of modern conservatism.

  • Orthodoxy/Orthopraxis

    Graham at Leaving Muenster has a characteristically challenging post on where Christianity falls short if it’s taken to be simply a set of beliefs and not a way of life:

    I remember hearing Brian Mclaren talk a few years ago about an interview he’d given at a conference. I believe it was with Dallas Willard and they were discussing why a trip to your average bookshop would reveal a great upsurge of interest in Buddhism and New Age, but a sharp disinterest with Christianity.

    Willard’s response was simple and – it seems to me – spot on: “Christianity is a set of doctrines, whilst Buddhism offers a way of life.”

    At the time, I would have called myself a Christian and I was gutted. I couldn’t deny the truth in McLaren’s words. I knew the riches of Christian spirituality and the writings of Catholic mystics and Orthodox theologians, but these didn’t function as the mainstream of Christianity and seemed to be presented as something of an exceptional and optional extra.

    (Note: I don’t intend what follows to be an argument with Graham as such; I’m not sure how much of this he would disagree with. This is more a riff on the idea that there is some fundamental dichotomy between doctrine and practice.)

    There seems to be a common sentiment abroad that Christianity has focused too much on orthodoxy and not enough on orthopraxis. A lot of wrangling over dogma and theological formulations, and not enough following Jesus.

    In fact, some would go so far as to say that we should focus on following the way of life taught and exemplified by Jesus in the Gospels and not worry about things like creeds and systematic theologies.

    For my part, here as elsewhere, I want to say “both/and” rather than “either/or.” I find myself doing that a lot – maybe this accounts for my attraction to the via media of Anglicanism. I don’t think that it’s possible to separate beliefs from pracitce.

    The reason for this is fairly straightforward: our beliefs are already embedded in our practice. We do certain things because, at least in part, we believe the world to be a certain way.

    Those who would have us just follow the simple way of loving Jesus seem to overlook the fact that Jesus’ teachings are rooted in his proclamation of the mercies of his Father and his Father’s Kingdom. Because God has a certain character, we are called and empowered to live in a particular way.

    Beyond this, we know precious little of any “Jesus movement” prior to or apart from the proclamation of Jesus as Risen Lord. It’s a commonplace of New Testament scholarship that all the NT books were written from the perspective of faith in the Risen Christ. In fact, you hardly need to be a scholar to recognize that. And apart from that faith, is there really enough material to base a way of life on the teachings one finds in the Gospels?

    Moreover, why would we want to? If the teachings of Jesus are to be separated from the teachings about Jesus, it’s not clear why that particular way of life should be taken to be universally binding. As J.H. Yoder wrote, he is normative as a human being becuase he’s divine. If the church’s Christological claims are of (at best) secondary importance, it’s not at all clear why some other historical person wouldn’t provide us with as good a role model if not better (St. Francis? Mother Teresa? Buddha? Gandhi?). If nothing else, we have better information about many of them.

    It’s because Jesus reveals the character and identity of God, or is the agent of God’s kingdom, or is the incarnation of the universal logos, or however we want to elucidate it theologically, that he provides the foundation for a way of life. Certainly there’ve been many nominal Christians (no doubt there are nominal Buddhists too), but I would argue that those who most faithfully followed Jesus also took with utmost seriousness the church’s claims about who he is.

  • The politics of biotech

    William Saletan has a good article on how biotech issues are threatening to upset existing political categories. He gives an admirably evenhanded account of the stakes as each side sees them, but then points out that these debates are making for strange bedfellows:

    On the left, the instinct is to treat ESC research like health care. “[Missouri’s] Amendment 2 is about finding cures and saving lives—nothing more, and nothing less,” said an ad for the ballot measure. But in the stem-cell fight, the teams are all messed up. You’ve never seen conservatives so exercised about protecting women from “Big Biotech,” or liberals so in love with drug companies. From California to Michigan to Massachusetts, the most common argument for stem-cell subsidies, next to saving lives, is that they’ll attract high-tech business.

  • The more things change… or Lessons from the early church

    I’ve been reading Henry Chadwick’s history of the early church (thanks, Josh!) and been struck by the relevance of that history for some of the issues facing the church today.

    Consider, for example, the so-called new atheists (Dawkins, Sam Harris, et al.) who specialize in arguing against a certain construal of Christianity as though it were the sole legitimate version. I call this the “heads I win/tails you lose” argument since the whole point is to brand one’s opponent as either a raving fundamentalist or a weak-kneed temporizer. Either you accept the most implausible literalistic version of Christian belief, or you’re a wishy-washy liberal sellout and therefore not a “real” Christian.

    But as Chadwick demonstrates, the early church was well aware of the difficulties of some of the more literlaisitc versions of key beliefs, as well as the moral issues raised by certain troubling Old Testament passages for the Christian view of God, and resolutely grappled with them. Irenaeus offered a nuanced account of creation and the existence of evil, Clement of Alexandria questioned the idea of a “materialist” resurrection and earthly millenium, and Origen pressed the case for allegorical and metaphorical interpretations of Scripture (too far, some would say).

    The point isn’t that we need to accept the answers provided by these early theologians (and, it’s worth recalling that they were writing during a time when church teaching was still in a great deal of flux and some of their ideas would later be deemed unorthodox), but that this style of theologizing and exegesis has as long a pedigree in the church as any, and modern fundamentalism (which itself even gets unfairly distorted by some of its critics) is a relative newcomer.

    Another thing that I’ve been thinking about is just how radical a decision the early church made in deciding that the Mosaic Law was no longer binding upon Christians. We talk nowadays about “revisionists,” but, to take our most heated contemporary example, the argument for blessing monogomous same-sex unions looks positively conservative compared to chucking the Law. [Edited to add: Not that the Law was regarded as a bad thing. Rather, it was seen as a temporary expedient, or a “tutor” to lead people to knowledge of righteousness. But what’s striking to me is that Christians would feel free to set aside what were regarded as divine commands.] Of course, this by itself doesn’t settle that particular issue, but it does put into perspective some of the more dire pronouncements about overthrowing thousands of years of unbroken tradition, since that’s precisely what the church did!

    Also noteworthy is how some of these early theologians resisted the imposition of a “new law” in the sense of hard and fast rules for Christian conduct. Consider Chadwick’s account of Clement’s discussion of Jesus’ advice to the rich young ruler:

    Clement wrote a special discourse to help Christians puzzled about the right use of their money and troubled especially by the absolute command of the Lord to the rich young ruler, ‘If you would be perfect, sell all you have…’ On a rapid reading it might seem as if Clement were merely a compromiser trying to wriggle out of the plain meaning of a commandment. But a fairer reading of his tract shows that he did not see the gospel ethic as imposing legalistic obligations but rather as a statement of God’s highest purpose for those who follow him to the utmost. What really matters is the use rather than the accident of possession. Accordingly Clement laid down a guide for the wealthy converts of the Alexandrian church, which imposed a most strenuous standard of frugality and self-discipline. Clement passionately opposed any luxury or ostentation, and much that he protested to be lawful he regarded as highly inexpedient.

    The exposition of the saying to the rich young ruler and several passages in the Paedogogus and Stromateis show Clement acting as a spritual director. It lay in the nature of his view of the Christian life as a progress towards the likeness of God in Christ that he saw it both as a dynamic advance in the comprehension of the nature of Christian doctrine and also as a process of education in which the aspirant would make mistakes calling for penitence. The church he describes as a ‘school’, with many grades and differing abilities among its pupils, where all the elect were equal, but some were ‘more elect’ than others. Accordingly Clement could take a view of the church which allowed room for the resotration of the lapsed and at the same time held the highest demands before all Christians. (p. 98)

    Of course, alongside this fairly humane and tolerant ethic we also have the rigor of, say, Tertullian (though it should be noted that Tertullian ended his days outside the church). But the idea of Christian ethics as a way of life leading to a gradual increase in Christ-likeness, while recognizing the persistent reality of human sin and failure, strikes me as a deeply appealing one. And it appears to have significant precedent in the church’s history.

  • Feingold’s out

    Looks like Russ Feingold has ruled out an 08 presidential run to focus on influencing the Democratic agenda in the Senate. This is too bad in my view, not because I expected him to actually get the nomination (much less win the general election), but that I think it would be useful to have an out-and-out dove in the primaries of at least one party. As things are shaping up now, we may end up with the debate carried on entirely between pro-interventionist Dems.

    Currently it looks like John Edwards is the most leftward candidate likely to run, but I don’t recall him being particularly dovish on war and peace issues. I’m also not sure what the foreign policy views of the much-hyped Barack Obama are. But I would like to see a candidate who challenged the basic assumptions of our interventionist foreign policy.

  • Black helicopter watch

    I read the NT Wright lecture I linked to yesterday and I tend to agree with Jonathan that Wright is too optimistic about a global army (or “police force” as he calls it) as a viable alternative to our present situation.

    Wright says:

    First, we must work from every angle either to enable the United Nations and the International Courts of Justice to function as they should, or to replace them with something else that can do the same job better. The only way we could have done something wise in Iraq would have been for a force, with the energy of the whole international community behind it, composed equally of Norwegians and Nigerians, of Australians and Pakistanis, of Chileans and Japanese and, yes, British and Americans. To continue to resist the making real of such an internationally credible police force, as many on the right in America have done, is more and more obviously a way of saying that now that we’re in power we will use that power utterly for our own advantage, and rule out the possibility that anyone might call us in turn to account. Of course, when China or India becomes the next superpower, we can expect the present superpower to go running for help to any international court that might then exist. But the point is this: it is time to make the transition globally that we in this country made in the 1830s when we moved from local militias to a credible national police force. Of course with any such move there are all the same dangers of the abuse of power. But we already have abuse of power; it is part of the task of the church, in calling present abuse to account, to work for a better structure which could actually deal, with visible credibility, with all kinds of problems around the world. I wish I thought that such a refreshed United Nations was likely to emerge soon. But we must work and pray for something like this to happen. In such work, and in such prayer, God is present to call both the War on Terror, and the Terror itself, to account.

    I think there are a few problems with this. One is the implication that abuse of power won’t be more pronounced at a global level than at a national level. While it’s certainly dangerous for any nation to act as judge in its own case, any kind of world government or army would have the added danger of being the only game in town. A world government, for instance, would presumably have no “right of exit” acting as a check on its pretensions. There is the added problem that the more removed any governing body is from the people it governs, the more problems there are with accountability.

    In addition to problems of monopoly and accountability, I think the empirical claim that a multinational invasion of Iraq would have had significantly more credibility and that that credibility would’ve made a significant difference to the success of the mission is dubious. The thing is that most people in the world would resent outsiders coming into their country and bossing them around. Maybe the invasion of Iraq would’ve engendered less resentment if it was the kind of multinational force Wright envisions, but the attendant bomb-dropping that would’ve still been necessary (and which Wright rightly deplores) would no doubt have created the same kind of enmity toward any invading force. I don’t think the dynamic of occupation changes just because it has a UN (or whatever) imprimatur on it.

    It’s interesting to me that Wright uses the analogy of England moving from local militias to a national police force, because an American would read that totally differently. If any politician in Washington proposed replacing all local law enforcement with a federal police force, people of every political persuasion would roundly denounce it. Suspicion of centralized power is part of our political DNA.

    Not to say that better international institutions aren’t desirable, but I can’t help but think that any kind of global UN army would be a standing invitation to more meddling and intervention by the powerful nations of the world (who would almost certainly dominate it like they do the UN in its present form) or it would result in a deadlock when powerful nations’ interests clashed (just as the US and the USSR essentially prevented the UN from functioning as intended during the Cold War).

    If anything, my inclination is to go in the opposite direction and make political institutions more participatory by devolving important functions to regional and local levels, with less centralization, more federalism, more local autonomy, and with decisions made among the people who are most affected by them. That may sound utopian, but no less so, I’d argue, than what Bishop Wright is proposing.

    All that said, there are a number of good and important points made in the lecture, and I think Wright’s account of how Jesus inagurates God’s kingdom and Christians participate in it is very good.