Author: Lee M.

  • The Jeffersonian impulse

    Jeff Taylor, author of the interesting-sounding new book on the Democratic Party Where Did the Party Go?: William Jennings Bryan, Hubert Humphrey, and the Jeffersonian Legacy, has an essay adapted from the book on Imperialism and Isolationism: Contrasting Approaches to Foreign Policy.

    Taylor tries to dispel some myths about isolationism:

    To some, isolationism may imply ostrich-like, willful ignorance of the rest of the world, but this was never the case with its most famous practitioners. The isolation is not one of intellect, trade, or travel, but one of entangling alliances, military conflict, and imperial domination. For isolationists, national self-determination for colonies and national sovereignty for America are closely-related principles emanating from a common source: a commitment to democracy, freedom, and decentralization. Isolationism is the foreign policy of traditional liberals.

    We also get this great quote from Jefferson: “I know but one code of morality for men, whether acting singly or collectively. He who says I will be a rogue when I act in company with a hundred others, but an honest man when I act alone, will be believed in the former assertion but not in the latter.”

    The Jeffersonian-Hamilton divide that Taylor identifies is a perennial one in American politics that extends to both foreign and domestic questions and doesn’t track the left-right divide. In other words, it’s possible to be a right- or left-wing Jeffersonian or a right- or left-wing Hamiltonian. While Jeffersonian ideals of freedom and decentralization might seem to lead in a (right-wing) libertarian direction, they can also manifest themselves in a distrust of big business and moneyed interests, a suspicion of technological progress, and a devotion to the ideals of agrarianism and communitarianism (Wendell Berry could probably be described as a left-wing Jeffersonian, as could someone like Kirkpatrick Sale).

    Likewise, “national greatness” liberals and neoconservatives are both species of Hamiltonian (John McCain, subject of the previous post, would be an arch-Hamiltonian). They emphasize a untiy of national purpose which is to be concentrated and expressed through the federal government and have largely made peace with the “bigness” of modern society (big business, big government, etc.). They also want the US to take a very activist role in foreign affairs, whether to promote American commercial interests (which isn’t the same thing as laissez-faire) and/or to promote loftier ideals like democracy and human rights.

    Personally, I have strong sympathies with the Jeffersonian vision, but not without a sneaking suspicion that it would be impossible, and maybe undesirable, to put it into practice. A nation of small craftsmen and yeoman farmers has a certain romantic appeal, but I think this can easily be over-romanticized and the benefits of a society of “mass affluence” overlooked. As I mentioned in my review of Bill Kauffman’s Jeffersonian manifesto, the tight-knit small community is not necessarily or in any straightforward way a “solution” to the alleged problem of urban (or suburban) anomie. Rural, small-town, suburban and urban life all have their unique blessings and problems. And decentralization is not a magic bullet solution to political problems, however desirable it might be in some ways. For one thing, the nation-state is currently the only existing political unit capable of addressing some of the inequities generated by a global economy.

    Nevertheless, in our current situation it sure looks like we could use a little more of the Jeffersonian impulse if that means a certain level of government restraint, especially in foreign affairs. Not to mention that a renewal of federalism might help defuse some of our more hotly contested social issues. Like pacifism and other “radical” views, Jeffersonianism isn’t in any danger of sweeping the nation, but may provide a useful counterpoint to the existing consensus within the political class.

  • The problem with John McCain

    John McCain seems like an admirable person in many ways, but he’s never been someone I’d particularly want to see in the Oval Office. Here’s a good op-ed on why. For some reason, McCain’s actual views frequently get obscured in all the media fawning over his straight-talkin’ maverick persona. There is also the any-stick-to-beat-Bush-with phenomenon: whenever McCain departs from the White House he’s almost invariably referred to as a “moderate,” which in media-speak is invariably a term of praise. But on GWOT and general national security issues McCain is, if anything, to the “right” of Bush.

  • Moral diversity in the church

    I recently picked up a collection of essays from the library called Gays and the Future of Anglicanism, edited by Andrew Linzey and Richard Kirker. The essays cover a broad range of topics responding to the Church of England’s Windsor Report, which censured the American Episcopal Church and a diocese within the Canadian Anglican church for proceeding with the consecration of an openly gay bishop and the blessing of same-sex unions respectively.

    Among the essays that I found most helpful were those addressing the question of what constitutes legitimate diversity in the church on moral issues, in particular, essays by Keith Ward, Rowan Greer, and Linzey himself.

    Ward argues that Anglicanism, unlike, say, Roman Catholicism, doesn’t have a mechanism for pronouncing definitively on contested moral questions. He then takes the Fourth Commandment (Sabbath observance) as an example of where the church has allowed widely divergent interpretations to exist side-by-side. What constitutes adherence to the Fourth Commandment is determined by context as well as reading the intention of “spirit” of the law. Hardly anyone would insist that Christians not “work, leave home, gather wood, or light a fire” on the Sabbath. Alternatively, one could follow Calvin and (arguably) St. Paul and say that for Christians there is no specially mandated day for observing it, since the law has been abrogated for them. However, Ward says, what you often end up with in practice is a kind of hodge-podge or halfway observance, where Christians are discouraged from working but not required to fulfill the other parts of the commandment. At the end of the day, he says, how we observe the Sabbath should be determined by the intent of the commandment, namely, to honor and remember God in all we do.

    Analogously, Ward contends that the apparent biblical prohibitions on sexual relations between members of the same sex likewise have to be judged both in their original context and in light of the fact that Christ is “the end of the law.” Appealing to the OT prohibitions, for instance, is undermined by the fact that Christians (and Jews) routinely mitigate or outright ignore parts of the law. Likewise, he argues, for some of St. Paul’s statements. To take them as legalistic commands is to misunderstand the teaching of the gospel. “If Paul teaches that the whole law has been set aside by Christ, then appeal to the law to back up a moral view has been rendered impossible. To appeal to the moral beliefs of Paul, who taught that we should not be bound by any written words, would hardly make sense” (p. 25).

    But lest this lead to relativism, Ward says that we have been given a way of testing our actions: “That criterion is love of neighbor, concern for their wellbeing. Such neighbor-love is to be modelled on the example of Jesus, which asks for self-giving, humble, unreserved and unlimited concern for the good of others” (p. 25). Ward concludes, then, that “when safeguarded by a stress on the need for loyalty and total commitment in relationships, and by an insistence that sexual practice should express and be subordinated to mutual personal love, a sexual relation between two people of the same sex who are by nature attracted to one another is acceptable and natural” (p. 26).

    Nevertheless, Ward allows that Christians can in good faith disagree about this. Interpreting and applying the Bible is a complex matter over which sincere and well-informed Christans can and will disagree. He proposes that a diverstiy of viewpoints existing in one church has been, and should continue to be, a hallmark of Anglicanism. He suggests that one way of embodying that diversity is the existence of inclusive churches “whose vision of human relationships as related in Christ includes those living in same-sex partnerships” (p. 29), and that there is no reason that pastors or bishops likewise situated shouldn’t minister to such churches.

    Rowan Greer looks at the diversity of viewpoints in light of traditional Anglican views on the authority of the Bible and church polity. He begins his essay by noting two opinions he holds with confidence:

    First, what could be called the traditional view [of sexuality] no longer compels widespread assent, not only with respect to homosexuality, but also in reference to issues such as the remarriage of divorced persons, heterosexual cohabitation outside marriage, and childless marriages of those capable of bearing children. It does not seem to me reasonable to treat the gay issue in isolation of other aspects of human sexuality. Second, granted that moral norms should not be severed from doctrinal considerations, I find it difficult to think of them as quite the same, and remain unconvinced that a particular view of human sexuality must be held necessary to salvation. (p. 101)

    Greer goes on to consider how the appeal to “scriptural authority” can be misleading because Anglicanism at least has never had a settled view of how scriptural authority functions. He canvasses the views of early Anglican divines like Richard Hooker, Joseph Hall, and William Chillingworth and notes that “even in early Anglicanism it is impossible any one clear understanding of biblical authority” (p. 105). Similarly with the other two legs of what he calls “that shibboleth of contemporary Anglicanism, ‘scripture, tradition, and reason” (p. 105).

    He then discusses what he considers to be a fairly persuasive view of biblical authority – that of an inspired witness or response to revelation – which he associates with figures like S.T. Coleridge, F.D. Maurice, Charles Gore, and William Temple. The upshot is that “the repudiation of infallibility is characteristic of Anglicanism and that this carries with it the conclusion that all human authority is fallible” (p. 109). Consequently, Greer argues that proposals to create a more centralized Anglican communion with quasi-legal mechanisms for enforcing unanimity on controversial issues is a mistake and constitutes taking the easy way out.

    Andrew Linzey’s essay “In Defense of Diversity” makes the point that it’s inconsistent to demand uniformity on one moral issue like homosexuality, while allowing for wide diversity on issues of at least as great, if not greater, moral import:

    Like many church reports, [the Windsor Report] likes to think that there is greater uniformity than acutally exists. It scolds ECUSA and the Diocese of New Westminster for failing to observe the “standard” of Anglican teaching, but omits to mention that it is, like all such “teaching,” based on Lambeth resolutions, wholly advisory at best. Nowhere is this clearer than on the issue of war and violence. Successive Lambeth Conferences of 1930, 1948, 1968, and 1978 declared that “war as a method of settling international disputes is incompatible with the teaching and example of Our Lord Jesus.” But this hasn’t stopped individual churches authorizing priests to serve in the armed forces as chaplains, even though they are required to wear military uniform and are subject to service discipline. And neither has it stopped individual Christians and ordained ministers making up their own minds about the rights and wrongs of particular wars, and participating in the ones they believe to be just. (pp. 176-7)

    Linzey’s point is not that any moral position is as good as any other, but rather that sincere Christians can legitimately reach different conclusions on particular issues in good faith. “We must give up as infantile the notion that all Christians have to morally agree on every issue. … Unity and communion would have been better served by a frank and honest recognition that disagreement is not in itself a sign of infidelity to Christ, or the demands of truth, or the fellowship that Anglicans can, at best, have within the church” (p. 178).

    Indeed, Linzey says, though some may dream of a “pure” church where everyone agrees on all moral issues of importance, such a church would in fact be a sect. And, whatever the value of sects, that isn’t historically what Anglican churches have tried to be. The “Elizabethan settlement” that gave rise to Anglicanism as we know it was in part a reaction against the sectarianism of the Puritans, who sought just such a “pure” church.

    I’m not sure how persuasive these arguments would be to someone who wasn’t already at least sympathetic to the “liberal” view on same-sex relationships in the church (though I think a case could be made that it’s also a deeply “conservative” view, but that’s a topic for another post…). However, it seems to me that a diversity of opinion on important issues isn’t going away and I’m convinced that it’s a mistake to make one’s position on this particular issue the litmus test for “genuine” Christianity.

    For better or worse, there is no unified Christian view on many of the perplexing issues of the day. One unfortunate tendency of Protestantism has been to splinter in the face of disagreement, whereas Catholicism has tended to try and enforce unity from the top down. But, as Keith Ward puts it, “If there is to be any hope of Christian unity in the world, Christians will have to learn to embrace diversity of interpretations, doctrines and ways of life, while always seeking to relate those diverse patterns to the disclosure of the divine nature in the biblical records of the person of Jesus, and in the creative power of the Holy Spirit” (p. 29).

    There are other essays in this volume worth discussing, which I may get to in future posts, but as a whole I think it’s a worthwhile read for Christians, not just Anglicans or pseudo-Anglicans like me, concerned with the splintering of our churches.

  • Hagel on exiting Iraq

    I said before that one of my hopes from the election was that some of the few GOP senators who haven’t entirely drunk the administration kool-aid might start to put pressure on the White House for a change of course in Iraq. Here’s Chuck Hagel in the Washington Post arguing for just that. What he’ll do in his capacity as US Senator to actually bring about a changed state of affairs remains to be seen.

  • C.S. Lewis, scholar and spiritual writer

    Unbeknownst to me until this morning, today the Episcopal Church calendar commemorates C.S. Lewis. As is traditional, we remember “saints” on the day of their death, or their birth into eternal life. (As it happens, Lewis died on November 22, 1963, the very same day as JFK and Aldous Huxley.)

    Here’s the collect (via fellow Boston-area blogger Until Translucent):

    O God of searing truth and surpassing beauty, we give you thanks for Clive Staples Lewis whose sanctified imagination lights fires of faith in young and old alike; Surprise us also with your joy and draw us into that new and abundant life which is ours in Christ Jesus, who lives and reigns with you and the Holy Spirit, one God, now and for ever. Amen.

    Here’s Lewis himself from his marvelous sermon “The Weight of Glory” [PDF]:

    Meanwhile the cross comes before the crown and tomorrow is a Monday morning. A cleft has opened in the pitiless walls of the world, and we are invited to follow our great Captain inside. The following Him is, of course, the essential point. That being so, it may be asked what practical use there is in the speculations which I have been indulging. I can think of at least one such use. It may be possible for each to think too much of his own potential glory hereafter; it is hardly possible for him to think too often or too deeply about that of his neighbour. The load, or weight, or burden of my neighbour’s glory should be laid daily on my back, a load so heavy that only humility can carry it, and the backs of the proud will be broken. It is a serious thing to live in a society of possible gods and goddesses, to remember that the dullest and most uninteresting person you talk to may one day be a creature which, if you saw it now, you would be strongly tempted to worship, or else a horror and a corruption such as you now meet, if at all, only in a nightmare. All day long we are, in some degree, helping each other to one or other of these destinations. It is in the light of these overwhelming possibilities, it is with the awe and the circumspection proper to them, that we should conduct all our dealings with one another, all friendships, all loves, all play, all politics. There are no ordinary people. You have never talked to a mere mortal. Nations, cultures, arts, civilization—these are mortal, and their life is to ours as the life of a gnat. But it is immortals whom we joke with, work with, marry, snub, and exploit—immortal horrors or everlasting splendours. This does not mean that we are to be perpetually solemn. We must play. But our merriment must be of that kind (and it is, in fact, the merriest kind) which exists between people who have, from the outset, taken each other seriously—no flippancy, no superiority, no presumption. And our charity must be a real and costly love, with deep feeling for the sins in spite of which we love the sinner—no mere tolerance or indulgence which parodies love as flippancy parodies merriment. Next to the Blessed Sacrament itself, your neighbour is the holiest object presented to your senses. If he is your Christian neighbour he is holy in almost the same way, for in him also Christ vere latitat—the glorifier and the glorified, Glory Himself, is truly hidden.

  • Death, where is thy sting?

    Thomas at Without Authority writes on death and whether we should consider it natural and/or evil in itself. I think he’s on the right track there (and I’m not just saying that because he had nice things to say about a few of my posts).

    I’m intrigued by his last paragraph where he says:

    So, in my estimation, the evolutionary biologists are right when they say that death is a necessary part of nature. But are they also correct in concluding that the world is not good, as the book of Genesis would have us believe? I think the answer depends on how one interprets the biblical statements concering the goodness of creation. Are these meant to imply that the world is intrinsically good, that is, good in-and-of-itself? Or do they mean that creation is only good when it’s in communion with its Creator? I think the latter answer is correct, which means that only a redeemed creation is truly “good”. We should never draw too sharp a distinction between God’s roles as Creator and Redeemer, as if He first made a supposedly good creation and then had to save it when all hell broke loose. Creation always involves redemption, and redemption always involves a new creation. Thus, it’s not surprising that a purely atheistic worldview like neo-Darwinism is incapable of seeing the inherent goodness of creation, since it cuts itself off from the salvation that redeems and restores this fractured world.

    I take this to mean that creation is always in “process” toward the final consummation. This seems at odds with the traditional notion that creation “at the beginning” was finished and perfect as it was, and only later fell into sin and disharmony. Maybe this is more consonant with the somewhat popular “Irenaean” (after Irenaeus, bishop of Lyons and scourge of gnostics) account of the fall that sees creation and humanity as progressing from a state of relative immaturity to one of perfect communion with God. On this view, the fall was more like a detour from this intended path than a cataclysmic rupture from a state of perfect bliss.

  • NRCAT statement of conscience

    If you’re concerned about reports of the use of torture in the war on terror then you might consider endorsing the National Religious Coaltion Against Torture‘s “Statement of Conscience.” I’ve mentioned this before, but recently received an e-mail saying that they’re aiming to have 50,000 signatures by mid-January.

    You can view and endorse the statement here. I know I would make a lousy political activist because I’m always at least a little bit skeptical that these sorts of things will have any effect, but, hey, couldn’t hurt, right?

  • What does TEC teach about salvation?

    Yesterday’s Boston Globe carried an article about Episcopal parishes in the Diocese of Massachusetts disassociating themselves from the national church body on account of the latter’s “teachings on gay clergy, homosexuality, and salvation.”

    Leaving aside for the moment the controversy over V. Gene Robinson and the larger issue of homosexuality in the church, what’s this business about the Episcopal Church’s teaching on salvation?

    A bit further on we read:

    After the ordination of V. Gene Robinson , a gay man, as bishop in New Hampshire in 2003, disaffected congregations asked that the national convention of the church return to a literal reading of the Bible that unequivocally forbids homosexuality. They also asked Episcopal leaders to affirm that the only route to salvation was through Jesus.

    The 2006 convention did neither of these things, leading congregations such as All Saints of Attleboro to leave the denomination and others to request that they be overseen by traditionally oriented bishops rather than those who support the new teachings, such as M. Thomas Shaw, the bishop of the Diocese of Massachusetts.

    And:

    Parishioners concluded that the majority in the Episcopal Church of the United States, which backs full acceptance of gays and lesbians and does not hold that belief in Jesus is the only route to salvation, “are at odds with the vast majority of Anglicans, with the Christian community of North America, and with Christians throughout the world,” [All Saints parishoner Ron] Wheelock said.

    Now, there are two possibly distinct things being claimed here. One is that the Episcopal Church denies that “the only route to salvation [is] through Jesus” and the other is that “belief in Jesus is the only route to salvation.” These aren’t necessarily the same thing. It’s possible that salvation only comes through Jesus but that explicit belief in Jesus (at least in this life) isn’t a necessary condition for that salvation. In other words, Jesus can save us even if we don’t know that it’s Jesus saving us.

    So, it’s possible to affirm that Christ’s work is what opens the door to salvation without claiming that one must explicitly acknowledge that work in order to receive its benefits. I take it, for instance, that the Catholic church teaches something like this when it says that

    Those who, through no fault of their own, do not know the Gospel of Christ or his Church, but who nevertheless seek God with a sincere heart, and, moved by grace, try in their actions to do his will as they know it through the dictates of their conscience – those too may achieve eternal salvation. (Catechism of the Catholic Church, Part I, Section Two, Chapter 3, Article 9, Paragraph 3)

    Apparently part of the controversy has been fueled by some remarks made by new Presiding Bishop Katharine Jefferts Schori about the relationship between Christianity and other religions. For instance, in a recent Time Magazine interview, Bp. Schori said in response to the question “Is belief in Jesus the only way to get to heaven?”:

    We who practice the Christian tradition understand him as our vehicle to the divine. But for us to assume that God could not act in other ways is, I think, to put God in an awfully small box.

    Now, that’s not as precise an answer as one might’ve liked, and I think Bp. Schori may be conflating Christ’s work and our belief in that work (just as the Globe article above seemed to be doing). But if what she means to affirm is that God can act to bring people to salvation who have never heard of Jesus, then I don’t see anything particularly problematic about that.

    What would be problematic would be if Jesus was reduced to simply one manifestation of a kind of ineffable transcendence that is no more (or less) binding or normative than those claimed by other religions. In such a view, there are a plurality of “vehicles to the divine,” none necessarily better or worse than any other. This is not a tenable view in my opinion, and it’s certainly outside the historic Christian mainstream. If the Episcopal Church were in fact found to be teaching such a view, then there would be serious cause for concern.

    Of course, it’s not entirely clear what it means for the Episcopal Church to teach x since there is no teaching magisterium to pronounce definitively on what the church teaches. I’m not sure what kind of force the pronouncements of the General Convention have, but failing to affirm a particular version of the claim that the only route to salvation is through Jesus is not the same as denying it.

    Indeed, the proposed resolution that was defeated at the General Convention seems a bit ambiguous itself on what is being claimed:

    Resolved, the House of _____ concurring, That the 75th General Convention of the Episcopal Church declares its unchanging commitment to Jesus Christ as the Son of God, the only name by which any person may be saved (Article XVIII); and be it further Resolved, That we acknowledge the solemn responsibility placed upon us to share Christ with all persons when we hear His words, “I am the Way, the Truth, and the Life. No-one comes to the Father except through me” (John 14:6); and be it further Resolved, That we affirm that in Christ there is both the substitutionary essence of the Cross and the manifestation of God’s unlimited and unending love for all persons; and be it further Resolved, That we renew our dedication to be faithful witnesses to all persons of the saving love of God perfectly and uniquely revealed in Jesus and upheld by the full testimony of Holy Scripture.

    One could interpret this in a polemcial way – that is, affirming that one must explicitly call on the name of Jesus in order to be saved, and affirming a particular understanding of Christ’s work (“the substitutionary essence of the Cross”), in which case it’s understandable that the delegates would have problems with it. I myself would be wary about setting conditions on what people have to do in order to be saved, or requiring that everyone adhere to a particular Atonement theory (something the larger church never saw fit to require in any of its creeds or councils). Or, one could read it as mushy boilerplate that essentially says “Yay, Jesus!” which, while not being a bad thing for the church to say, doesn’t seem to require being affirmed by a church whose entire raison d’etre is the good news of Jesus.

    More to the point, I think one would be better off looking at the daily practice of the church to determine what it believes about Jesus. The Prayer Book liturgy, the preaching, the sacraments all presuppose and proclaim that Jesus saves. In my admittedly limited experience, that seems to be the primary way in which the Episcopal Church teaches what it believes. If that’s the case, why the need to reaffirm the basic foundation of the church’s mission in a General Convention resolution?

    It could be that the controversy over soteriology is a stalking horse for the issue of homosexuality. Otherwise, it’s sort of hard to account for the outrage over a position which, on a charitable reading, isn’t really any different from the position of the Catholic Church, who almost no one has accused of selling out the exclusive claims of Christ.

    On the other hand, it’s possible to imagine a case where a church does fall outside the bounds of orthodoxy. If the Episcopal Church were to promulgate a statement explicitly denying the unique mediatorial work of Christ, then I think you whould have such a case. But as far as I can tell it hasn’t done that, and its life and practice presuppose the opposite.

  • Jars of Clay – LIVE!

    At the risk of incurring the mockery of Derek or others, just wanted to mention that the good wife and I attended a Jars of Clay concert last Friday at Gordon College on the north shore (billed as “the only nondenominational Christian college in New England”). Apart from being dragged to a Petra concert by my older sister when I was about 15, this was my only exposure to live popular Christian music. But, as I’ve mentioned before, I really dig Jars of Clay; they seem to me to be several cuts above most “CCM.”

    And they didn’t disappoint. The material on their newest album is much more rock-inflected than their last few, and, while I won’t say that they rocked harder than seeing, say, the Ramones when I was 18 or Pantera and Anthrax when I was 22, they certainly rocked that particular house (which was, interestingly, the campus chapel!). I wish the same could be said of the audience, who actually sat down during slow songs! And not only was there no dancing to speak of, there was precious little bopping or bobbing. Kids these days! I wasn’t expecting crowd surfing or moshing or anything, but a little more spontaneity would’ve made it feel a little more like, y’know, a rock concert. But then my exposure to evangelical subculture is petty limited, so maybe that’s normal behavior.

    But not only did JoC put on a really good show, they took some time to promote their project blood: water mission, which is dedicated to providing access to clean drinking water in Africa by raising funds for wells and other clean water projects in villages throughout the continent. That strikes me as a pretty worthwhile undertaking.

    So, kudos to Jars of Clay for a good show, even if I might’ve preferred to see them in a dimly lit club with a beer in my hand instead of sitting in a padded pew next to 13 year old girls. 😉