My wife and I live about a block and a half from Eastern Market, but the fire that gutted the building happended just before we moved here, about two years ago. Since then, the butchers, fish-monger, etc. have been housed in a makeshift building across the street, while the weekend produce vendors set their stalls up on the sidewalk outside. Great to see this historic building and center of community life being restored.
Author: Lee M.
-
One sentence movie review: Revolutionary Road
I can’t decide if it was a good movie that failed to acheive greatness due to a couple of glaring flaws, or just a really well-made, but fundamentally bad movie.
-
What GHG emissions?
Congress exempts factory farms from reporting their greenhouse gas emissions.
Related, here’s an analysis of Waxman-Markey from the National Wildlife Federation.
-
John Gray on Isaiah Berlin
Berlin is remembered by philosophers for defending ethical pluralism – the claim that human values make conflicting claims that cannot always be rationally reconciled – and arguing that this pluralism is the true basis of a liberal society. The argument is hardly demonstrative – if values can conflict in ways that have no rational solution, what reason can there be for favouring individual choice over other goods? But Berlin’s achievement was not to give liberalism a watertight foundation. It was to present liberalism as an attractive vision of life, and one that is not tied to a quasi-religious belief in progress. Though Berlin was solidly committed to the values of the liberal Enlightenment, he never shared the faith of Enlightenment thinkers that growing knowledge could resolve fundamental conflicts of value. For him such conflicts were part of what it means to be human, and any philosophy that offered to deliver us from them was both deluded and illiberal.
Read the rest here (via the American Conservative).
I don’t know how much Gray is over-reading Berlin here, but this certainly seems to aptly characterize Gray’s views. He’s been on a jihad against progressivist utopian delusions over the last few years, from taking on humanism in his provocative Straw Dogs (see my thoughts here) to critiquing apocalyptic religion and crusading neoconservatism in Black Mass.
Gray’s pluralistic, anti-progressivist liberalism definitely resonates with me. I’m deeply suspicious of narratives of historical progress and claims to basing society on a unified conception of the good. But I also have my reservations. Anti-progressivism can easily slide into complacency about rectifiable injustices. Sometimes we need the zeal of the radical.
-
More command and control please!
Interesting dissent on the Waxman-Markey climate change bill currently being stalled by farm-state Dems in Congress:
…President Barack Obama has publicly described the bill as his and the Democrats’ preferred alternative to regulation. Without the bill, he has threatened, the EPA will directly regulate greenhouse-gas emissions, a power it was given by the Supreme Court in 2007 and which it announced it would exercise in April 2009. Indeed, the bill specifically prohibits Obama’s EPA from regulating these emissions.
The bill’s carbon-cap-and-trade provisions are by all reports its heart and soul. They exemplify a Republican approach: Don’t tell polluters what to do, bribe them and hope they do what you want. Democrats have faked left and gone right.
[…]
Most environmental leaders and Democratic Party officials argue that we should support this bill no matter how imperfect because it represents an important, small step forward. Strip it of its cap-and-trade provisions and I would agree. Retain the cap-and-trade provisions and I see it as a giant step backward that may well hobble further progress in federal efforts to combat climate change for years to come.
For a qualified defense of the bill, see David Roberts at Grist. I don’t have the wonky chops to determine if the special interest giveaways overwhelm the positive aspects of the bill, though people I trust still seem to be behind it.
-
Charles Wesley gets his due
It appears that new scholarship is discovering some of the long-forgotten (or even suppressed) differences between Charles Wesley and his more famous brother. One interesting point that comes up in this piece is that C.W. leaned more heavily toward keeping Methodism as a movement within the Church of England.
I suppose it doesn’t mark me out as particularly interesting or original to note that I love Wesley’s hymns.
-
Burke v. Madison
Whether, like Burke, one believes that anarchy is the great threat to liberty and social peace, or, like Madison, that tyranny poses the greatest threat to liberty, goes a long way toward determining if one is a conservative or a liberal. –John McGowan, American Liberalism: An Interpretation for Our Time, p. 105
McGowan here is talking specifically about traditionalist conservatism, and this isn’t the whole story about the liberal/conservative divide, but this strikes me as insightful. Conservative worries about the fragility of the “moral ecology” of society rest on a view of liberty and peace as very precarious accomplishments. Meanwhile, liberals are apt to see any claims to power and authority as inherently suspect.
This divide reproduces itself, it seems to me, in church matters. Here I would place the divide between those for whom the greatest threat to the church is antinominanism, and those for whom it’s legalism.
The former tend to see any challenge to received understandings of the law as the first steps down the slippery slope to moral anarchy. What’s always needed is a robust re-assertion of “orthodoxy” or the “faith once delivered to the saints.”
By contrast, the latter group bristles at any assertion of authority, tending to see all such claims as oppressive. Even those requiring, say, a priest or bishop to uphold the creeds or a communicant to have been baptized are illegitimate intrusions upon personal liberty.
It’s not that I think the truth lies simply in striking a happy medium between liberal and conservative positions, but both are certainly prone to unhelpful excesses. This fundamental difference in outlooks may also help explain why the two sides–in both the political and ecclessiastical spheres–so often talk past each other.
-
The health care “debate”
I don’t have a strong specific policy preference as far as health care reform goes, but I was out eating with some friends this weekend and was provided, courtesy of the CNN playing on the TV at the restaurant, with a telling example of how the health care debate is being carried on. (Usually I avoid cable news like the plague.) It was a special on health care reform (hosted by Wolf Blitzer, I think) and they kept talking about the dread “slippery slope” toward Canadian- or UK-style “socialized medicine.” There are several problems with this including 1) it presumes that “socialized medicine” is an inherently undesirable end point (slipperly slopes are not generally considered to carry us toward good things); 2) it conflates a Canadian single-payer system with a more genuinely “socialist” system where the state actually provides health care services, like in the UK; and 3) it implies that Canda and the UK are (or viewers will assume that they are) backward hellholes that no normal person would ever want to take as providing models or ideas for policy in the U.S.
-
Problems of omnipotence, omniscience, and temporality
In his book Pascal’s Fire, Keith Ward writes:
…ultimate mind is the actual basis of all possible states. It is the only being that must be actual, if anything at all is possible. It is thus uniquely self-existent, not deriving its existence from any other being. Its nature is necessarily what it is–there are no possible alternatives to it, since it is the basis of every possibility. It can be spoken of as omniscient, in the sense that it conceives or generates all possible states, knows what they are and knows that there are no more than it conceives. It can be spoken of as omnipotent, in the sense that it brings whatever is actual into existence from the realm of possibility, or it generates actual beings with a derivative power to make some possible states actual. Nothing that comes into being can have more power than ultimate mind has, since the latter is the source of all actuality.
It might well be as well to note that these definitions of omniscience and omnipotence are not exactly the same as the ones classical philosophers have often given. Many philosophers define omniscience as knowledge of absolutely everything, possible, actual, past, present and future. They define omnipotence as the power to do absolutely anything that is not self-contradictory. The definitions I have given are more restricted than that. They do not entail that God knows what will be actual in the future. Perhaps God leaves the future open for radical freedom. And they do not entail that God can do absolutely anything. Perhaps God leaves, or even must leave, finite reality to follow its own inherent laws of development.
Yet we can still say that God knows everything that is possible and actual (the future may not be actual yet) and that God is the most powerful being there could possibly be and the ultimate source of all things that come into being. This leaves open the question of exactly which possible states can be made actual adn whether there are restrictions on what possible states can be actual. Though such an ultimate mind can sensibly be called omniscient and omnipotent, this may not be enough to satisfy some religious believers. It is enough, however, to satisfy the requirements of being an ultimate explanation of the universe. (pp. 132-3)
Elsewhere Ward speaks of God’s “temporality,” as the divine experience of a succession of states. God is still trans-temporal in the sense of transcending the multiple processes of temporal succession posited by relativity theory. But Ward argues, contra the classical view, that it is a perfection, not an imperfection, for God to experience the flow of new experiences and new possibilities for creativity, in response to real relationships with creatures.
God can enter into many different times, acting and responding in them, while also existing in a trans-temporal way. We cannot imagine this trans-temporality of God, but it should not be conceived as a totally immutable and static existence. It might be better conceived as a transcendent agency that acts incessantly in many temporal streams, manifesting its changeless perfection in continual creative activity, sensitive awareness, and overflowing goodness. (p. 216)
Obviously a lot of argument would be required to establish this position with any confidence, but I think there are two root insights that motivate it. The first is that, if God does not experience temporality in some sense, then God’s knowledge is, paradoxically, limited. That is, there’s a mode of experience that God has no knowledge of. The second is that God, according to the Bible and much religious experience, exists in responsive relationship with God’s creatures. For this to be a genuine relationship and not an illusory one, God must be able to actually enter into the flow of time and, potentially, be affected by it. Classical Christian thought limited this to the Incarnation, but Ward goes further than that here.
So, if there is a temporal aspect to God’s existence, then we can begin to see why omniscience might still allow that God doesn’t know certain things. If there are genuinely undetermined events (and there may be quite few for all we know), then even God would only have probably knowledge of how they are going to turn out. As Ward says, God knows all possible states and all actual states, but non-actual future states would not necessarily be part of God’s knowledge.
I always feel a bit impious even speculating about this stuff.