Author: Lee M.

  • Wanted: A Countercultural Church

    Here’s a write-up from this Sunday’s Inquirer on Ron Sider’s new book the Scandal of the Evangelical Conscience. Sider calls for Christians to recommit to living as a “countercultural community” that resists the values of the surrounding society:

    The drift from biblical norms toward mass-culture values of individualism and entertainment is widespread, Sider says in the book, citing various surveys. For instance, 26 percent of traditional evangelicals and 46 percent of nontraditional ones do not think premarital sex is wrong. Twenty-five percent of born-again Christians have had live-in partners before marriage, not that far below the U.S. rate of 33 percent. The divorce rate for born-again Christians is 26 percent, topping the non-Christian rate of 22 percent.

    Despite recent church efforts to repent of racism, white conservative Protestants have been found to be more than twice as likely as other whites to blame lack of equality between the races on a lack of black motivation rather than discrimination.

    Though incomes have risen, giving to churches has not. Only 6 percent of born-again adults tithed in 2002, a drop from 12 percent in 2000. Giving has fallen from 3.1 percent of personal income – a third of a tithe – to 2.66 percent.

    Sider teaches at Eastern Baptist Theological Seminary just outside of Philly, and there was a conference there to discuss the ideas in the book:

    Randall Balmer, professor of American religious history at Columbia University, rued the current “blind allegiance to hard-right politics” as being a reversal of evangelicalism’s historic advocacy of progressive causes such as abolitionism, temperance, and women’s education and voting rights.

    As the movement joined forces with political conservatives about 25 years ago, Balmer said, its suspicions of “worldliness” also fell away: “In its quest for political influence, economic affluence and cultural respectability, evangelicalism ceased being a counterculture.”

    I’m hesistant to critique someone’s position based on just two quotes taken out of context, but doesn’t this at first blush seem inconsistent? Surely the progressive evangelicalism of the past sought “influcence … and cultural respectability.” Indeed, such evangelicals were an integral part of the turn-of-the-century Progressive movement, elements of which tended to view the American state as God’s chosen instrument to stamp out sin in all its forms. These selfsame progressives were instrumental foisting the disastrous and hated 18th Amendment on the country and stampeding the country into World War I (with the honorable exception of populist evangelical William Jennings Bryan who resigned as Wilson’s Secretary of State once he realized the administration was bent on entering the war, despite its official stance of neutrality).

    My point being that it’s one thing to criticize conservative evangelicals for being too “worldly” by entering into politics, and it’s quite another to criticize them for not being progressive enough.

    Other participants at the conference suggested that evangelicals drop out of the culture to a certain extent:

    A grab bag of cures to unbiblical living were proposed by speakers on the dais and from the floor: “Selective disengagement” from the culture (“Turn off the television, turn up the Bach,” quipped Wheaton College historian Mark Noll). Small “accountability groups,” in which believers confront sins. A return of church discipline in which members, particularly leaders, could be sanctioned. More use of sacramental confession and penance. More youth mentoring. Racial and urban-suburban dialogues. And the recovery of “biblical literacy.”

    Bible classes should explore which social conventions Jesus subverted and which injustices Moses redressed, Christianity Today editor David Neff said. “Not until we see the Bible’s radical challenges to ourselves and to the social evils we have been taught to tolerate are we biblically literate… . The gospel is about salvation, but we also know that the gospel never stops at salvation.”

    Sider suggests “We simply cannot follow Jesus in this crazy society unless we recover a deep sense of the church as a countercultural community,” and “We almost certainly would strengthen the church today if we made it harder to join.”

    Though I must say my Lutheran hackles are raised when I read things like this:

    “When Christians today reduce the gospel to forgiveness of sins, they are offering a one-sided, heretical message that is flatly unfaithful to the Jesus they worship as Lord and God.”

    For another view, check out this essay by Lutheran theologian Gerhard Forde: “Is Forgiveness Enough? Reflections on an Odd Question.” Forde says:

    The first step we need to take in sorting out our problem is to pay some heed to the distinction between the ultimate and the penultimate in these matters. When the question is put, “Is forgiveness enough?” the first thing to ask is, “Enough for what?” The immediate answer, surely, is that it is enough for salvation. We are constantly reminded of that in our liturgy by the song of Zechariah when it is said that God’s people shall be given “knowledge of salvation by the forgiveness of their sins” (Luke 1:77). Such forgiveness is, as already indicated, the ultimate judgment, the last word spoken over and to us in this penultimate world. Indeed, it is the end (finis and telos) of our penultimate world and the beginning of the ultimate, the end of this old age and the beginning of the new. It brings the turn of the ages to faith. And so it is enough. Faith simply cannot ask, “Is that all?” It is all! To be faithful is to believe in the forgiveness of sins, and that it is enough.

    Of course we will want to say some other things when we turn to consider the penultimate and its concerns. Forgiveness of sins does not straightaway do for us in this age what we might desire. It does not heal the paralytic; it does not put food on the table; it does not bind up all our hurts and pains. If that is the sum and substance of what is hoped for, forgiveness will never be “enough.” But then, one might add, nothing will ever be enough. I expect that is the major impetus behind our question. In our culture of complaint and victimization we tend to lose sight of the ultimate and to focus rather on immediate injustices, wrongs, and abuses. So we cry, “Forgiveness is not enough!” We demand rather our rights; we demand justice, the righting of wrongs, the end of all abuses; we want fulfillment, self- esteem, happiness. No doubt these are matters of considerable importance. But they are, nevertheless, penultimate.

  • I wanna be…Anarchy!

    I’ve been reading a very interesting little book called Christian Anarchy: Jesus’ Primacy over the Powers by Vernard Eller (you can access the entire book online here). Eller is a theologian of the Church of the Brethren, a radical reformation church similar to the Mennonites.

    By “anarchy” Eller doesn’t mean political anarchy – i.e. striving to overthrow or abolish the state. Rather, he means the fundamental attitude Christians should take toward all the world’s “arkys” – those forces and structures that seek to govern human behavior. This includes governments obviously, but also “churches, schools, philosophies, social standards, peer pressures, fads and fashions, advertising, planning techniques, psychological and sociological theories.”

    An an-archist, then, is not someone opposed to all “arkys,” but someone who is, in a sense, indifferent to them. Just as an a-moralist is not necessarily immoral, but rather regards the whole area of morality with indifference.

    Eller argues that since Jesus is THE arky (arche – governing or first principle), a Christian cannot give to the arkys of the world the reverence or respect that they demand. Nor, however, do they need to oppose those arkys by entering into a power struggle. The perpetual temptation for us is to bless our “good” arkys, giving them a religious imprimatur, and going into battle against the “bad” arkys.

    As Eller puts it:

    “Anarchy” (“unarkyness”), it follows, is simply the state of being unimpressed with, disinterested in, skeptical of; nonchalant toward, and uninfluenced by the highfalutin claims of any and all arkys. And “Christian Anarchy”–the special topic of this book–is a Christianly motivated “unarkyness.” Precisely because Jesus is THE ARKY, the Prime of Creation, the Principal of All Good, the Prince of Peace and Everything Else, Christians dare never grant a human arky the primacy it claims for itself Precisely because God is the Lord of History we dare never grant that it is in the outcome of the human arky contest that the determination of history lies.

    Human arkys can be of the Establishment or the Revolution, conservative or progressive, etc. The point is that the Christian is enabled to stand “outside” the power struggle between the arkys:

    At this point of definition, then, we should note that the idea of “revolution” is not anarchical in any sense of the word. Revolutionists are very strongly opposed to certain arkys that they know to be “bad” and to be the work of “bad people.” However, they are just as strongly in favor of what they know to be “good” arkys that are the work of themselves and other good people like them. For instance, these revolutionists might seem to be superanarchical, finding nothing good to say about the establishment U.S. arky; but they turn out to be very proarchical, finding nothing but good to say about a revolutionary Sandinista arky. Indeed, the regular procedure of “revolution” is to form a (good) power-arky that can either overthrow and displace or else radically transform the (bad) arky currently in power. This selectivity amounts to a passionate faith in the power of arkys for human good and the farthest thing possible from a truly anarchical suspicion and mistrust of every human arky. Thus “anarchical” is a synonym for “nonpartisan”; and “anarchy” and “partisanship” are direct opposites.

    Though Christians may participate in the arkys when they see some good to be accomplished, they will not place their hopes in them as means to usher in God’s Kingdom, the “just society” or what have you. This is because they know that God will bring in the Kingdom in God’s own time, and that the means by which God has chosen to do this is through death and resurrection (rather than say, by revolution, top-down social engineering, or incrimental progress):

    Christian anarchists occasionally are willing to work through and even use worldly arkys when they see a chance to accomplish some immediate human good thereby. This is an admittedly risky business; the regular pattern is to make a quick entrance and just as quick an exit.

    For example, the civil arky of Christoph Blumhardt’s day was really putting it to the working classes, and anarchist Blumhardt saw the revolutionary arky of the Social Democrats as a vehicle for helping those people get their rights. He joined the party, spoke for it, ran for office, and won a six-year term in the Württemberg legislature. But it didn’t take a whole lot of arky red tape and politicking before he lost not only his interest but his cool: “I am proud stand before you as a man; and if politics cannot tolerate a human being, then let politics be damned.” That, my friends, is pure Essence of Anarchy: “Human beings, yes; politicians, never!” Blumhardt got out as soon as he graciously could.

    Eller is also concerned to point out that while Christians are irreverent to the claims of the arkys for respect, they are not revolutionists seeking to tear them down. This is the lesson he draws from Jesus’ refusal to be a political messiah, and Paul’s admonition to be subject to the ruling authorities. Eller advocates what he takes to be biblical non-resistance.

    There’s a lot packed into this little book, including discussion of Karl Barth, Bonhoeffer, Jacques Ellul and others. What I think is a valuable contribution of this book, though, is his insistence that no worldly cause, however important it may seem from our vantage point, can be identified with the Gospel. He is skeptical that there is any one “Christian morality,” much less a “Christian politics.” At a time when the “Christian Right” and the “Christian Left” seem increasingly at each others’ throats, it’s good, I think, to hear things like this:

    The fact is that any number of different moral systems can be and have been derived from the biblical gospel–with each having about as good arguments, documentation, and support as another. Nothing is to be gained (and a great deal of Christian charity is to be lost) by the church splitting up to battle over whose is “the truly Christian moral system.” I am quite confident, for example, that the liberal Left’s is not true Christian morality and the conservative Right’s is actually immorality (or vice versa). Doubtlessly the Left is reading its Bible correctly on some points and wrongly on others–and the Right likewise. I would be happy to have it said either that both represent Christian moralities or that neither does (good arguments either way). But what the evidence will not allow is any party’s claiming that what it represents is “Christian morality” while any party else represents “un-Christian immorality.”

  • No to Boltonism! No to Globaloney!

    Lots of predictable hand-wringing over President Bush’s appointment of John Bolton to the post of UN ambassador. Bolton has, after all, said things like this:

    “If the UN Secretariat building in New York lost ten stories, it wouldn’t make a bit of difference.”

    Well!

    In more temperate moods, Bolton has written things like this (via Justin Logan):

    We should…eliminate assessments altogether, moving toward a UN system that is funded entirely by purely voluntary contributions from the member governments. Such a system of voluntary contributions would allow each government to judge for itself whether it was getting its money’s worth from the UN and each of its component agencies.

    Now, as far as your humble scribe is concerned, the problem with Bolton is not that he’s anti-UN, but that he’s an ultra-hawk. As David Corn points out:

    Bolton is a hawk’s hawk in the Bush administration. He is the agent conservateur in Colin Powell’s State Department. He has led the administration’s effort against the International Criminal Court. Last year, he single-handedly tried to revise U.S. nuclear policy by asserting that Washington no longer felt bound to state that it would not use nuclear weapons against nations that do not possess nuclear weapons. (A State Department spokesman quickly claimed that Bolton had not said what he had indeed said.) Bolton also claimed that Cuba was developing biological weapons–a charge that was not substantiated by any evidence and that was challenged by experts. In July, he was about to allege in congressional testimony that Syria posed a weapons-of-mass-destruction threat before the CIA and other agencies, who considered his threat assessment to be exaggerated, objected to his statement. When England, France and Germany recently tried to develop a carrot-and-stick approach in negotiating an end to Iran’s suspected nuclear weapons program, Bolton huffed, “I don’t do carrots.”

    However, where Bolton and the UN-niks agree is in thinking that someone’s gotta run the world. They just differ on whether it should be done “unilaterally” (i.e. by the U.S.A.) or “multilaterally.” What’s never put on the table is unilateral mind-your-own-business-ism (=non-interventionism=”isolationism”=my preferred policy).

    As far as the UN – that continuing object of inexplicable devotion and reverence in some liberal circles – goes, I’m with lefty Alexander Cockburn who called it a “repellent harbinger of world guv’mint.”

  • Burkean Bloggers

    Now, how are we supposed to believe those conservatives when they tell us they are underrepresented in academia when we now have two conservative philosphy blogs? (In fairness, there does seem to be some considerable overlap in contributors – including friend of VI Bill Vallicella.)

    But seriously folks, the lineup at Right Reason looks good. It’s the brainchild of Max Goss, whose public split from Keith Burgess-Jackson’s Conservative Philosopher shocked the blog world! Posting is slated to start tomorrow.

  • More Lukacs

    Here’s a piece John Lukacs wrote last year on the increasing “militarization” of the image of the presidency. Catch anyone at the Heritage foundation writing something like this:

    Like the boy soldier salute, the sentimentalization of the military is juvenile. Television depictions of modern technological warfare, for example, make it seem as if a military campaign were but a superb game, an occasional Super Bowl that America is bound to win – and with almost no human losses. (“We’ll keep our fighting men and women out of harm’s way” – a senseless phrase that emerged duringthe Clinton years.) The exaggerated vesting of the president with his supreme role as commander in chief is a new element in our national history.

    When the Roman republic gave way to empire, the new supreme ruler, Augustus chose to name himself not “rex,” king, but “imperator,” from which our words emperor and empire derive, even though its original meaning was more like commander in chief. Thereafter Roman emperors came to depend increasingly on their military. Will our future presidents? Let us doubt it. And yet . . .

  • Liberty and/or Virtue?

    A debate in the American Conservative between Robert Locke and Daniel McCarthy.

    Locke:

    Libertarianism’s abstract and absolutist view of freedom leads to bizarre conclusions. Like slavery, libertarianism would have to allow one to sell oneself into it. (It has been possible at certain times in history to do just that by assuming debts one could not repay.) And libertarianism degenerates into outright idiocy when confronted with the problem of children, whom it treats like adults, supporting the abolition of compulsory education and all child-specific laws, like those against child labor and child sex. It likewise cannot handle the insane and the senile.

    McCarthy:

    Libertarianism is a political philosophy, not a complete system of ethics or metaphysics. Political philosophies address specifically the state and, more generally, justice in human society. The distinguishing characteristic of libertarianism is that it applies to the state the same ethical rules that apply to everyone else. Given that murder and theft are wrong—views not unique to libertarianism, of course—the libertarian contends that the state, which is to say those individuals who purport to act in the name of the common good, has no more right to seize the property of others, beat them, conscript them, or otherwise harm them than any other institution or individual has. Beyond this, libertarianism says only that a society without institutionalized violence can indeed exist and even thrive.

  • A Qualified Retraction

    Thanks to some comments from Marcus and a conversation with the wife, I’m now convinced that the argument in this post doesn’t show the impermissibility of “collateral damage.”

    For if C (the innocent bystander) doesn’t have a duty to sacrifice himself to save A, it doesn’t seem like we can say that A has an obligation to sacrifice himself to save C. In other words, what we get is a kind of “lifeboat” situation where two people’s rights come into irreconcilable conflict and one person has to be sacrificed.

    However, this would only seem to be the case in instances where the use of lethal force is the only way for A to save himself. If A can defend himself in some other way, he has the obligation to take that route (even perhaps at considerable risk to himself).

  • Pro-Lifers’ cups may runneth over in PA

    Looks like pro-life Democrat Bob Casey Jr. will be running for US Senate next year. There has been a minor controversy because the Party bigwigs have been pushing for Casey and trying to get other possible candidates not to run, clearing the field for him. (Casey doesn’t want a draining and expensive primary before going up against Santorum.)

    However, two possible challengers to Casey, former state treasurer Barbara Hafer and Rep. Joe Hoeffel (who ran unsuccessfully against Arlen Specter last year) have balked at bowing out of a primary. Hafer is a former Republican who left the GOP over the abortion issue (Hoeffel is also pro-choice).

    Though I would definitely be pulling for Casey in the primary and the general election, I think the Democrats would be doing the voters a disservice by trying to squash a primary contest. Some of us are still ticked at the PA Dems for going to such great lengths to kick Ralph Nader off the ballot last fall.

    UPDATE: The Inquirer reports today that Hafer and Hoeffel will step aside to clear the way for Casey.

  • Eugene Peterson’s Down to Earth Spirituality

    An interview at CT. I read and liked his Answering God. This makes me want to read more of his stuff.

    This bit is good:

    Many people assume that spirituality is about becoming emotionally intimate with God.

    That’s a naïve view of spirituality. What we’re talking about is the Christian life. It’s following Jesus. Spirituality is no different from what we’ve been doing for two thousand years just by going to church and receiving the sacraments, being baptized, learning to pray, and reading Scriptures rightly. It’s just ordinary stuff.

    This promise of intimacy is both right and wrong. There is an intimacy with God, but it’s like any other intimacy; it’s part of the fabric of your life. In marriage you don’t feel intimate most of the time. Nor with a friend. Intimacy isn’t primarily a mystical emotion. It’s a way of life, a life of openness, honesty, a certain transparency.

    Doesn’t the mystical tradition suggest otherwise?

    One of my favorite stories is of Teresa of Avila. She’s sitting in the kitchen with a roasted chicken. And she’s got it with both hands, and she’s gnawing on it, just devouring this chicken. One of the nuns comes in shocked that she’s doing this, behaving this way. She said, “When I eat chicken, I eat chicken; when I pray, I pray.”

    If you read the saints, they’re pretty ordinary people. There are moments of rapture and ecstasy, but once every 10 years. And even then it’s a surprise to them. They didn’t do anything. We’ve got to disabuse people of these illusions of what the Christian life is. It’s a wonderful life, but it’s not wonderful in the way a lot of people want it to be.

    Yet evangelicals rightly tell people they can have a “personal relationship with God.”

    That suggests a certain type of spiritual intimacy.All these words get so screwed up in our society. If intimacy means being open and honest and authentic, so I don’t have veils, or I don’t have to be defensive or in denial of who I am, that’s wonderful. But in our culture, intimacy usually has sexual connotations, with some kind of completion. So I want intimacy because I want more out of life. Very seldom does it have the sense of sacrifice or giving or being vulnerable. Those are two different ways of being intimate. And in our American vocabulary intimacy usually has to do with getting something from the other. That just screws the whole thing up.

    It’s very dangerous to use the language of the culture to interpret the gospel. Our vocabulary has to be chastened and tested by revelation, by the Scriptures. We’ve got a pretty good vocabulary and syntax, and we’d better start paying attention to it because the way we grab words here and there to appeal to unbelievers is not very good.