Author: Lee M.

  • Conservative Dissent on the Schiavo Case

    For what it’s worth.

    Here’s Jacob Hornberger (okay, he’s really more of a libertarian, but still):

    The issue in the Terri Schiavo case is not whether the Florida district court originally entered a correct judgment or not. The issue is whether this is a nation in which the American people are going to continue permitting their Washington politicians and bureaucrats to continue trampling on the Constitution and the rule of law, even while these people go abroad and hypocritically preach the importance of these principles to authoritarian regimes around the world.

    Come on now, Mr. Hornberger, tell us what you really think!

    He goes on:

    Thus, since the Schiavo case did not involve a federal or constitutional issue and did not involve citizens of different states, if one of the litigants had filed his suit in federal court rather than state court, the federal judge would have dismissed the case for lack of jurisdiction, no matter how much he felt that one side or the other deserved to prevail.

    This is an example of the “rule of law” – where a judge follows the law rather than deciding on his own to let the case proceed out of sympathy for one of the parties. In fact, it’s a commitment to the rule of law that motivated the U.S. district judge in the (new) Schiavo case to deny injunctive relief and the federal court of appeals to affirm that judgment, effectively rejecting Congress’s unconstitutional actions and despite any sympathies these federal judges might have for Terri Schiavo and her parents. As the majority opinion put it in the federal court of appeals case:

    There is no denying the absolute tragedy that has befallen Mrs. Schiavo. We all have our own family, our own loved ones, and our own children. However, we are called upon to make a collective, objective decision concerning a question of law. In the end, and no matter how much we wish Mrs. Schiavo had never suffered such a horrible accident, we are a nation of laws, and if we are to continue to be so, the pre-existing and well-established federal law governing injunctions as well as Pub. L. No. 109-3 must be applied to her case. While the position of our dissenting colleague has emotional appeal, we as judges must decide the case on the law.

    That’s how our system of government is supposed to work. When we pervert the process in an attempt to achieve a just result in a particular case, we inevitably end up with long-term bad results. That’s why it has been said that “hard cases make bad law.”

    He also questions the bona fides of the “pro-life” members of Congress who are intervening:

    This raw exercise of power is comparable to that being exercised by the Pentagon and the CIA, with their intentional and knowing denial of the principles and protections of the Constitution and the Bill of Rights to Americans and others who have been seized, tortured, sexually abused, and murdered, all with the silent and cowardly acquiescence of the so-called pro-life members of Congress. Or even the president’s waging of war against Iraq without the constitutionally required congressional declaration of war, again with the silent and cowardly acquiescence of Congress. Do you see now what happens when people meekly permit their government officials to begin violating the Constitution? The path toward the tyranny of omnipotent government quickly becomes a slippery slope.

    Is that what we’ve actually come to in this nation? A nation of meek lambs who permit these power-hungry wolves to once again scoff at and scorn the supreme law of the land – the law that our ancestors had the wisdom, foresight, and courage to impose on our government servants? A people who meekly permit such servants to trash our form of government under a purported “pro-life” mindset, a mindset that has sat silent and comatose during the entire time that an estimated 100,000 innocent Iraqi people have had their lives snuffed out by an unconstitutional war that lacked the constitutionally required congressional declaration of war?

    Meanwhile, paleo-conservative Thomas Fleming takes on the Christians:

    Hard cases make bad law. They also cause people to lose their moral bearings and their political principles. The case of Theresa Schiavo is no exception. Like many controversial issues, the Schiavo case pits states’-rights/limited-government Republicans against big-government Democrats who want to take power away from families and give it to federal judges. In this case, however, it is Barney Frank who is arguing for states’ rights and the entire Republican congressional caucus that is empowering judges. To take the irony one step further, President Bush—who, as President, has done next to nothing to protect innocent life—is now emerging as the spokesman for a “culture of life.” As governor of Texas, however, he signed a bill turning over the power to make decisions in apparently terminal cases to a medical-ethics board, which could authorize a hospital to end life support for a terminal patient even against the wishes of the next of kin. Under Texas “Advance Directives Act” of 1999, a children’s hospital, over the objection of the mother, removed a five-month-old boy from a ventilator. I should like to hear the President explain this away to the pro-life evangelicals he has betrayed at every turn.

    […]

    Liberal nonbelievers, who believe that “this is all there is,” may be pardoned for their hysterical attachment to physical life. This makes the non-Christian willingness to practice abortion and euthanasia all the more terrifying in its implications. For them, other people’s lives are mere commodities to be used when they are convenient, discarded when they are not.

    Christians know better. They know, not only that life is a precious gift, but also that it is not all there is. There was a time when believers gratefully accepted even martyrdom because it was a chance to live and die for their faith. Life can and ought to be beautiful, and we who believe that God looked at His creation and saw that it was good cannot contemn the joy and beauty of everyday life. But we also know that Christ’s kingdom is not of this world. We are sojourners here, like the Hebrews in the land of Egypt. Our home is elsewhere.

    Mrs. Schiavo’s parents have the right and duty to do what they can for their daughter, but the rest of us—and, by the rest of us, I include Bill Frist, Tom Delay, George Bush, and the Vatican spokesmen who so cavalierly intrude themselves into legal and constitutional matters they do not understand—have no business. Playing politics with a dying woman, even if it advances the pro-life cause or expands the electoral base of the Republican Party, is contemptible.

  • Seamless Garment Watch

    Another item from today’s Inquirer: Santorum shifting on a key issue:

    Sen. Rick Santorum (R., Pa), a longtime supporter of the death penalty, says he is reexamining his stance but not to the point of saying it is wrong in all cases.

    “I still support the death penalty, but what I’m suggesting is, number one, we have to be more cautious,” he said Tuesday, saying capital punishment should be limited to the “most horrific and heinous of crimes.”

    Santorum, who is running for a third term, said he was “not saying that I fundamentally believe the death penalty is wrong.”

    In an interview published in Tuesday’s Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, Santorum, a Roman Catholic, said he agreed with the Pope that the use of the death penalty should be limited.

    Some thoughts:

    • The Catholic bishops have recently stepped up their advocacy for ending the death penalty. Is Santorum worried about getting the Kerry treatment in ’06?
    • Bob Casey, Jr. is both anti-abortion and anti-death penalty. Does Santorum thinks that this consistent ethic of life approach will play well with voters?
    • What does it really matter if a U.S. Senator is against the death penalty anyway? Federal death penalty cases are rare, and the Supreme Court has ruled that the states can deploy it pretty much at their discretion (with certain exceptions like juveniles).
  • And we wonder why the mainline churches are shrinking…

    The Inquirer has an article this morning discussing various religious groups’ responses to the Schiavo case. As you might expect, Philadelphia’s Cardinal Justin Rigali condemns the removal of Ms. Schiavo’s feeding tube as an unequivocally “evil” act. Reform Rabbi and medical ethicist Mark Washofsky said “A person need not be at the doorway of death to decide medical therapy is not justifiable and… doesn’t belong.” On the other hand, Msgr. Kevin McMahon, professor of moral theology at St. Charles Borromeo Seminary in Wynnewood, pointed out that “you are discontinuing nutrition and hydration to someone who is not dying. You are introducing the cause of death. You are killing somebody, and killing is evil.”

    Then we get this from Eileen Lindner, identified as “an official at the National Council of Churches”:

    “The church might give guidelines,” Lindner said, “but in the end, my conscience must be guided by my own notions of God. That’s what the Protestant Reformation was about.”

    (That scraping sound you hear is Martin Luther and John Calvin rolling over in their graves, by the way.)

    Really? “My own notions of God”? And where might I get those notions? Not from any mainline Protestant church since the Reformation was all about individualism and freedom of conscience apparently. It was not, contrary to what some might be tempted to think, about reforming the church to bring it back in line with the catholic faith from which the Reformers believed the Medieval church had departed.

    If Ms. Lindner’s understanding of the Reformation reigns at the NCC, we’re in worse shape than I thought.

  • Party of limited government? Ha!

    Speaking of the Schiavo case, in today’s Inquirer analyst Dick Polman writes that it’s emblematic of the GOP’s shift from the party of limited government to the party of using the federal government to enforce a particular morality:

    Barry Goldwater said in 1964, “I fear Washington and centralized government more than I do Moscow.” Ronald Reagan said in 1975, “The basis of conservatism is a desire for less governmental interference, or less centralized authority.” And Newt Gingrich vowed in 1994 that a Republican Congress would hasten “the end of government that is too big, too intrusive.”

    But today, as evidenced by the Republican Congress’ intervention in the Terri Schiavo case, it’s clear that the traditional conservative credo no longer guides the GOP. The core mission has radically changed during the Bush era. “Small government” and “state’s rights” are out; wielding federal power to advance moral issues at the local level is in.

    Now, there’s an entire of genre of analysis, going back, say, ten years or so, in which liberals, who would never be caught dead voting Republican, attempt to rescue the lovable old GOP from horrible Christian Rightists and steer it back to the noble legacy of Goldwater and Reagan. Never mind that Goldwater and Reagan were denounced as fascists and extremists in their day!

    But more to the point, has the GOP ever been the party of limited government? From its very inception it was dedicated to “wielding federal power to advance moral issues at the local level” (we call that Civil War and Reconstruction!). The rhetoric of Reagan was largely just that (as even most conservatives now concede). The priorities of the GOP when in power have usually been tax cuts, huge increases in military spending, pork and corporate welfare, and modest cuts in programs for the poor. Combine this with a lot of mostly empty rhetoric on family values and you’ve got a recipe for electoral success! But little principled devotion to limited government or genuine federalism and localism.

  • Obligatory Terri Schiavo Post

    I have nothing of substance to add to the debate (there’s plenty of that elsewhere). I did think this article today at Slate was pretty good. It’s by Harriet McBryde Johnson who is a disability-rights lawyer in South Carolina.

    One thing in particular she says is worth highlighting:

    Despite the unseemly Palm Sunday pontificating in Congress, the legislation enabling Ms. Schiavo’s parents to sue did not take sides in the so-called culture wars. It did not dictate that Ms. Schiavo be fed. It simply created a procedure whereby the federal courts could decide whether Ms. Schiavo’s federally protected rights have been violated.

    In the Senate, a key supporter of a federal remedy was Iowa Sen. Tom Harkin, a progressive Democrat and longtime friend of labor and civil rights, including disability rights. Harkin told reporters, “There are a lot of people in the shadows, all over this country, who are incapacitated because of a disability, and many times there is no one to speak for them, and it is hard to determine what their wishes really are or were. So I think there ought to be a broader type of a proceeding that would apply to people in similar circumstances who are incapacitated.”

    I hope against hope that I will never be one of those people in the shadows, that I will always, one way or another, be able to make my wishes known. I hope that I will not outlive my usefulness or my capacity (at least occasionally) to amuse the people around me. But if it happens otherwise, I hope whoever is appointed to speak for me will be subject to legal constraints. Even if my guardian thinks I’d be better off dead—even if I think so myself—I hope to live and die in a world that recognizes that killing, even of people with the most severe disabilities, is a matter of more than private concern.

    Clearly, Congress’s Palm Sunday legislation was not the “broader type of proceeding” Harkin and I want. It does not define when and how federal court review will be available to all of those in the shadows, but rather provides a procedure for one case only. To create a general system of review, applicable whenever life-and-death decisions intersect with disability rights, will require a reasoned, informed debate unlike what we’ve had until now. It will take time. But in the Schiavo case, time is running out.

  • Mister, we could use a man like Herbert Hoover again!

    I’ve been reading Ronald Radosh’s Prophets on the Right: Profiles of Conservative Critics of American Globalism in which Radosh discusses the views of the “isolationist” conservatives of the World War I & II eras. The book, a sympathetic portrayal of its subjects, was written during Radosh’s “New Left” phase, before he went neocon and started writing for David Horowitz’s Front Page Mag. Radosh even collaborated for a while with libertarian isolationist Murray Rothbard on the short-lived journal Left and Right. The book jacket actually has a postivie blurb from Horowitz (still in his New Left phase at the time) and Horowitz’s bête noire Noam Chomsky!

    Anyway, in the chapter on historian Charles Beard, Radosh writes:

    Beard supported Herbert Hoover’s definition of national defense: the armed forces existed only to prevent an invasion of the mainland. The armed forces had to protect the nation’s continental heritage, not move to defend the American dollar wherever it happened to be threatened. (p. 21)

    That Herbert Hoover! What was he, some kind of America-hating peacenik?

  • Left & Right Find Common Ground on the Environment

    Interesting article detailing how left-right coalitions have passed several local environmentally friendly measures.

    Environmental issues, especially at the state and local levels, are bringing together conservatives and liberals who agree on little else, providing common ground in an increasingly polarized nation.

    One of the benefits of federalism and localism is that local politics seem to be less driven by these grand ideological divides and more amenable to compromise. It’s a lot harder to demonize people who are your neigbors or the parents of your kids’ friends.

    Conservatives such as pro-gun hunters and antiabortion evangelicals are making common cause with pro-abortion-rights, gun-control liberals on land conservation, pollution, and endangered-species protection.

    “We’ve heard a lot about the death of environmentalism, but I think what we’re seeing is the rebirth of environmentalism. We’re going back to where we were in the 1970s,” said Deb Callahan, president of the League of Conservation Voters. “We’re building a populist movement.”

    […]

    “You have a new politics overlaid on the old that talks about the environment,” said Robert J. Brulle, associate professor of sociology and environmental policy at Drexel University. “About 70 percent of the issues still break down along the old lines, but for 30 or 40 percent of them, the traditional left-right dichotomy doesn’t work anymore.

    “The strangest bedfellows I’ve ever seen are Earth Firsters and evangelical Christians.”

    The piece highlights how “red state” voters and evangelical Christians in particular are taking a much more active interest in environmental issues:

    In “red” Montana, voters rejected a proposal to repeal a 1998 ban on cyanide leaching, a gold-mining method. The debate pitted concerns about water pollution against proffered economic gains from mining.

    Colorado voters, who put their state in the “red” column for Bush, also approved a measure requiring electric utilities to obtain 10 percent of their energy from renewable resources by 2015. And they elected a Democratic U.S. senator, Ken Salazar, whose slogan was “our land, our water, our people.”

    In conservative Gwinnett County, Ga., where 66 percent of voters picked Bush, voters by the same margin approved a one-cent sales-tax increase to pay for $85 million to protect open space. In Indian River County, Fla., voters went overwhelmingly (61 percent) for Bush, and even more overwhelmingly (67 percent) for spending $50 million to preserve open space. Nationwide, 162 of a record 217 land-preservation ballot measures were approved, according to the Trust for Public Land, a land conservation organization.

    Denver-area voters approved a $4.7 billion mass-transit plan to vastly expand the region’s commuter-rail system and pay for it with a 0.4-cent sales-tax increase. Around the country, 23 of 31 transit-ballot measures passed.

    […]

    And most evangelical Christians, a pivotal conservative group for Bush in the last election, say they favor strict rules to protect the environment even if they cost jobs or result in higher prices, according to the 2004 National Survey of Religion and Politics.

    “Evangelicals are more sympathetic to the environmental movement than people think,” said Rich Cizik, vice president for governmental affairs for the National Association of Evangelicals. “The stereotype of evangelicals is that we’re all sitting at home reading Left Behind or out pillaging and plundering the environment. That’s just not the case.”

    […]

    Conservative voters who typically oppose increased government spending or tax increases often support spending for land preservation because it “delivers tangible results, close to home,” said Ernest Cook, senior vice president and director of conservation finance for the Trust for Public Land.

    He noted that 97 of the nation’s 100 fastest-growing counties voted for Bush last November but that many of those same counties recognize “a great need to set aside land for conservation purposes.”

    Seems to me that conservation should be a bedrock value of conservatives, since they are in favor of preserving the patrimony that has been handed down to us. And just as Christians should want to honor and protect God’s creation, a patriot should want to preserve the beauty of the American land.

  • Is Suffering Redemptive?

    Speaking of the Passion, the sermon preached by our associate pastor yesterday made what I thought were some very good points, and some that I was less sure about. She started off by noting that we in the advanced industrialized West aren’t all that good at dealing with suffering. She attributed this to the fact that our prosperity and technology enable us to go through at least large swaths of life relatively insulated from the kind of suffering that folks elsewhere in the world are all too familiar with. The idea that we can somehow totally abolish suffering from human life is a pernicious illusion that blinds us to important features of reality.

    This strikes me as right, and importantly so. Not only do I think our obsession with insulating ourselves from suffering is ultimately doomed to failure, it also tends to be used to justify a great deal of evil inflicted upon others. War, abortion, economic exploitation, euthanasia, etc. have all been justified as part of the grand plan to eliminate suffering.

    Our pastor then went on to talk about how Jesus’ Passion teaches us about the true nature of suffering. It’s here, though, that things started to get a little murky, I thought. She said that Christianity teaches that “suffering is redemptive.” Now, I certainly agree that the life, passion, death, and resurrection of Jesus Christ are redemptive, but is suffering per se, or even generally, redemptive? On the contrary, it seems to me that suffering, considered in and of itself, is intrinsically bad. After all, isn’t the promise of the Gospel that God will “wipe away every tear from their eyes; and death shall be no more; neither shall there be mourning, nor crying, nor pain, any more: the first things are passed away”? (Rev. 21:4) The fact that God can bring good out of evil does not make evil good, I would think.

    The attitude of the NT seems to be that suffering is something Christians endure for the sake of following Jesus, but not necessarily that it’s something redemptive in itself. Followers of Jesus should certainly expect suffering, but not seek it out. And Paul says that “our present sufferings are not worth comparing with the glory that will be revealed in us,” (Rom. 8:18) which seems to indicate that they are relatively unimportant.

    I think part of the issue at hand is that we moderns tend to take human suffering to be a much bigger theological problem than the ancients did. Entire theologies have been written to show that the whole point of the Gospel is that God “identifies with us in our sufferings.” I don’t want to deny that this is a part of the story of redemption, but focusing on it tends to obscure the elements that cast us in a less than flattering light. If God’s purpose is to identify with us in our sufferings, it means that we’re the victims and the onus is somehow on God to do something about the situation. But in the traditional understanding of the Passion, God is the victim (literally!) and we are the victimizers. In fact, to say that “suffering is redemptive” may in a way tend to exculpate us from complicity in Jesus’ death. Rather than a crime visited on the Son of God, it becomes an illustration of a general truth offered for our edification.

    (In fairness to my pastor I may be reading way too much into what she said. Regardless, I think the idea that “suffering is redemptive” has enough general currency that it’s worth thinking about.)