Author: Lee M.

  • Who’s "innocent"?

    In Slate William Saletan argues that President Bush is being inconsistent in opposing embryonic stem cell research (or at least federal funding thereof) and supporting the death penalty. According to Saletan, if Bush thinks it’s wrong to “take a life in order to save a life” he ought to extend that logic to the death penalty.

    Matthew Yglesias mentions the obvious rejoinder, namely that the death penalty involves the taking of a guilty life (or at least it’s supposed to), whereas human embryos, if you agree they are fully human lives, are innocent and can’t be said to deserve death. However, Yglesias also points out that hardly anyone thinks that it’s always wrong to cause the deaths of innocents, since during war most people accept that it’s permissible to kill some number of innocent people, at least unintentionally. This, however, led to some confusion in the comments thread, with people wondering who is “really” innocent. Someone even mentioned that according to the doctrine of Original Sin, no one is really innocent.

    This misses the point, though. The distinction between guilty and innocent for the purposes of just war theory has very little to do with who, if anyone, deserves death. This is why the combatant/non-combatant distinction, while not perfect, is preferable.

    The point is that just war theory licenses lethal force only against those who are actively taking part in some act of aggression. This is why a conscripted soldier, who in terms of desert may be just as innocent as a civilian, is a legitimate target, but someone going to his job in a pencil factory isn’t. The goal is to stop the aggression, not to inflict punishment on those who most “deserve” it. The reason that it’s wrong to directly target the innocent (i.e. usually civilians, but also, e.g. the wounded) is that they aren’t a threat.

    Granted the line can become fuzzy. One might argue that a civilian working in a munitions factory is a legitimate target. But this doesn’t show that there are no clear-cut cases. A nursing home is not a legitimate target even if all the residents support their government’s war policies and are perhaps less “innocent” than the conscript soldier.

    This is different from the death penalty, though, since the offender is already in custody and presumably no longer engaged in the act which might require lethal force to stop. The death penalty is usually justified on the grounds of its deterrence effect and/or on the grounds that the offender deserves to be executed on retributive grounds. In the latter case moral guilt is obviously crucial, but that makes the case different from that of war.

  • The "New Fusionism" vs. the Seamless Garment

    Joseph “Jody” Bottum has an article in this month’s First Things on what he calls “the new fusionism” – the alliance between pro-lifers and neoconservative foreign policy hawks. The “old” fusionism, of course, was the alliance between libertarians and traditionalists that formed the core of the post-war conservative movement. National Review theoretician Frank S. Meyer was the most forceful exponent of “fusionism” – the idea that there were good philosophical, not just tactical or strategic, reasons for libertarians and traditionalists to form a political alliance.

    Bottum concedes that it’s possible to be a hawk on the war on terrorism and pro-choice (e.g. Rudy Giuliani, Joseph Lieberman) and, conversely, to be anti-abortion and opposed to the “maximalist” view of the war on terror (Pat Buchanan, John Paul II). Nevertheless, he thinks that there are good philosophical (not just political) reasons for opponents of abortion and proponents of a forceful foreign policy aimed at defeating Islamic terrorism and fostering a broader democratic revolution in the Middle East and beyond to be on the same side:

    [A]t the level of political theory, there’s a reasonable connection between what we do at home and what we do abroad—or, at least, between the attitudes that cause us to enact certain domestic agendas and the attitudes that drive our foreign policy. A nation that cannot summon the political will to ban even one particularly gruesome form of abortion is unlikely to persevere in the grueling work of building international democracy simply because it seems the moral thing to do. And a nation that cannot bring itself to believe its founding ideals are true for others will probably prove unable to hold those ideals for itself.

    The abolition of abortion and the active advance of democracy have more in common, I believe, than is usually thought. But even if they are utterly separate philosophically, this much is true: They both require reversing the failure of nerve that has lingered in America since at least the 1970s, and success in one may well feed success in the other.

    The goal in either case is to restore confidence in—well, what, exactly? Not our own infallible rightness, surely. But neither can we live any longer with the notion of our own infallible wrongness. We need to restore belief in the possibility of being right. There’s a reason the leftist Christian magazine Sojourners started life in the 1970s as something called the Post-American. Many religious activists in those days seemed to have reached a point where they couldn’t tell an admirable patriotism from the murderous ideologies of nationalism—and, besides, if you squinted hard enough, social defeatism looked like a secular version of the Christian doctrine of Original Sin. The result was hardly what they hoped for: a cynical policy of Realpolitik abroad and a culture of death at home.

    The connection, then, seems to be a desire for a renewed moral confidence, an ability to make judgments, to call evil by its name. And a shared opposition to the enervating moral relativism that (supposedly) infects the Left.

    Bottum concludes:

    The angry isolationist paleoconservatives are probably right—this isn’t conservatism, in several older senses of the word. But so what? Call it the new moralism, if you like. Call it a masked liberalism or a kind of radicalism that has bizarrely seized the American scene. Mutter darkly, if you want, about the shotgun marriage of ex-socialists and modern puritans, the cynical political joining of imperial adventurers with reactionary Catholics and backwoods Evangelicals. These facts still remain: The sense of national purpose regained by forceful response to the attacks of September 11 could help summon the will to halt the slaughter of a million unborn children a year. And the energy of the pro-life fight—the fundamental moral cause of our time—may revitalize belief in the great American experiment.

    There are any number of criticisms that could be offered of Mr. Bottum’s analysis. For starters, some conservatives might (and have) questioned whether a nation that permits the slaughter of millions of unborn children is fit to spread its way of life accross the globe.

    More fundamentally, though, Bottum seems to me to be arguing against a strawman. Most people who dissent from the neoconservative project of global democratic “revolution from above” (as ersatz neocon Christopher Hitchens has called it) do not think Islamic terrorism or extremism are good things. And most of them think the U.S. has the right and duty to prosecute a vigorous defense of its citizens against the threat of terrorism. Where they disagree is in thinking that purusing a vast scheme of regime change and nation building is either necessary or possible. Recall that it was the threat of weapons of mass destruction being passed to terrorists that generated the support for the Iraq war. All the talk of liberation and democracy was ancillary and largely after the fact.

    I also find it strange that Bottum, who I believe is a Catholic, seems so unconcerned that his own church fails to see the connection between an aggressive moralistic foreign policy and a culture of life:

    No one could accuse the Catholic Church, for instance, of being soft on the life issues, but the Vatican was strongly opposed to the United States’ intervention in Iraq—to the point of hosting a state visit in Rome and Assisi by Saddam Hussein’s vicious deputy, Tariq Aziz, in February 2003. Much of the Roman curia seems to have fallen into a functional pacifism that threatens a damaging loss of the traditional Catholic theory of just war. But, even with such confusions set aside, this much is obviously true: Every war, just or not, involves killing. Though the doctrine of what used to be called the “seamless garment of life” has worn threadbare over the years, there is surely a coherent position that insists on opposition to both the culture of death and American intervention in Iraq.

    The accusation of “functional pacifism” is a common one. It seems to mean that the Church’s teachings on just war are so stringent that they rule out virtually all modern wars. And this is supposed to count as a criticism of the theory rather than an indictment of modern war! Does Bottum think just war theory is legitimate only if it permits a certain number of wars? Or only if it blesses all American wars?

    I don’t deny that there was a good humanitarian case to be made for the removal of Saddam Hussein from power. The arguments from Iraq’s “sovereignty” seemed pretty disingenuous. But can Christians concerned about the sanctity of life brush aside the tens of thousands of casualities that the Iraq war has caused as a mere “side effect”? I think Bottum owes us a critique of just war theory, or at least an account of how the destruction wrought by the war comports with the requirements of proportionality and discrimination.

    It’s the refusal to take seriously the relationship between means and ends that I find most troubling about the neoconservative approach to foreign policy. It’s almost as though as long as the ends are exalted enough (democracy! freedom!), we can dispense with worrying about the means we use to acheive them and whether they are morally permissible. One of the reasons that so many Christians are staunchly opposed to abortion and other aspects of the “culture of death” is that they beleive, with St. Paul, that we can never “do evil that good may result.” Some acts, such as torture or the intentional killing of innocents, are always forbidden. They will be rightly skeptical of any foreign policy that asks us to be complicit in the commission of such evils.

  • George Lucas, Augustinian

    “So what did you do on your trip to Canada?” Why, saw Revenge of the Sith of course!

    I admit, I liked it. It had more of that old-time Star Wars feeling than either of the other two prequels.

    Some reviewers have commented that Anakin’s fear that Padme was going to die in childbirth was an unsatisfying explanation for his “fall.” But I thought it was rather Augustinian. For Augustine, sin is turning away from the infinite Good and toward an inordinate attachment to and disordered love for finite goods.

    For Anakin, rather than being content with finite goods like love and marriage as the finite (but real!) goods they are, he sought to extend them toward the infinite. In seeking to extend life unnaturally he demonstrates a disordered love. This leads him to disregard other moral constraints on his actions, creating a downward spiral.

    Apart from that, there was plenty of bad acting and cheesy dialogue. And I think Lucas overdoes the CGI backgrounds. (Hoth and Tatooine seemed so much more real than virtually any of the settings in the prequels!) Still, a partial redemption of the series.

  • Playlist

    I notice sometimes the cool blog kids will post a list of the hep tracks they have in their iPod or computer or some other newfangled contraption. As a variation on this theme, I thought I would list the twelve CDs I currently have in my little portable CD case thingie just for kicks:

  • This seems like a pretty big deal, doesn’t it?

    The New York Review of Books is going to become the first major American media outlet to (finally!) publish the “smoking gun” memo of Tony Blair’s government. The memo indicates that the decision by the Bush administration to go to war with Iraq had been made as early as July 2002, and that the justifications (WMD, ties to terrorism) came afterwards.

    From the memo:

    C [a British intelligence agent] reported on his recent talks in Washington. There was a perceptible shift in attitude. Military action was now seen as inevitable. Bush wanted to remove Saddam, through military action, justified by the conjunction of terrorism and WMD. But the intelligence and facts were being fixed around the policy. The NSC had no patience with the UN route, and no enthusiasm for publishing material on the Iraqi regime’s record. There was little discussion in Washington of the aftermath after military action.

    The accompanying story suggest that the confrontation with the UN was engineered largely in order to provide a legal pretext for the war, not to avoid it:

    Thus, the idea of UN inspectors was introduced not as a means to avoid war, as President Bush repeatedly assured Americans, but as a means to make war possible. War had been decided on; the problem under discussion here was how to make, in the prime minister’s words, “the political context …right.” The “political strategy” — at the center of which, as with the Americans, was weapons of mass destruction, for “it was the regime that was producing the WMD” — must be strong enough to give “the military plan the space to work.” Which is to say, once the allies were victorious the war would justify itself. The demand that Iraq accept UN inspectors, especially if refused, could form the political bridge by which the allies could reach their goal: “regime change” through “military action.”

    Tom Dispatch has been permitted to make the NYRB story available early here.

  • Consistency and a "culture of life"

    Julian Sanchez and Matthew Yglesias both ponder the oft-made argument that it’s inconsistent or hypocritical to be against legal abortion but in favor of the death penalty. Sanchez says that there’s nothing logically inconsistent about opposing abortion while favoring capital punishment while Yglesias argues that it’s fair game to ask anti-abortion death penalty proponents to live up to their “culture of life” rhetoric.

    On the one hand, Sanchez is right that it’s possible to draw a morally significant distinction between killing an unborn child and executing, say, a convicted serial killer. (Interesting that almost no one makes the argument that the truly consistent position is to favor both legal abortion and the death penalty!)

    Still, I think Yglesias is onto something when he points out that if you embrace the notion of a “culture of life” then you should at least be uncomfortable with the death penalty.

    I would argue that the connecting thread is a strong presumption against the taking of human life. As Methodist Bishop Timothy Whitaker has said:

    When John Wesley gave the General Rules to the people called Methodists the first thing he told them was to do no harm. In order to show evidence that we are a people who are being saved by God we should do no harm.

    The rule to do no harm directs those of us who are Christians to practice non-violence. A Christian is someone who is horrified by violence, refrains from violence in her or his own life, and seeks to restrain violence in the world insofar as possible.

    The practice of non-violence is advocated in many religious traditions and philosophical teachings down through history. More than that, it expresses the will of God who is revealed in the story of the Bible.

    This horror of violence would make a people formed by a “culture of life” very hesitant to take the life of a fellow human being. This is sometimes combined with the idea that ready acceptance of killing in one sphere of life will spill over into others. There are differences of opinion among those who adhere to a “consistent life” ethic as to whether there are ever circumstances which permit the taking of life. The Catholic tradtion, as expressed in the catechism, allows that in some cases war and capital punishment may be legitimate responses to aggression, but only when other means of defense are unavailable.

    But both groups can agree, I think, that to “seek to restrain violence in the world insofar as possible” would require that we seek alternatives to abortion, capital punishment, war, and euthanasia, even if perhaps under some circumstances they might be necessary. It does seem that conservatives can be too comfortable with war and capital punishment, while liberals too easily accept abortion and euthanasia. A “culture of life,” on the other hand, would not accept the prevalent rationalizations for the alleged necessity of these forms of violence.

  • Greatness inflation

    The Discovery Channel is doing a new series to determine who the “greatest” American is. The list of 100 nominees will be whittled down by voting over the course of the series.

    The list of nominees is pretty presposterous. Apart from the obvious inclusions, there are a lot of people that seem to be on there for no other reason than that they’re alive or celebrities of various sorts.

    Here’s the list; I’ve bolded the people that seem to uncontroversially belong there (i.e. they would be on anyone’s short list), and italicized those who seem completely ridiculous as candidates (plain text means I can see reasons for inclusion, but they’re not an obvious choice):

    Abraham Lincoln
    Albert Einstein
    Alexander Graham Bell
    Alexander Hamilton
    Amelia Earhart
    Andrew Carnegie
    Arnold Schwarzenegger
    Audie Murphy
    Babe Ruth
    Barack Obama
    Barbara Bush
    Benjamin Franklin
    Bill Clinton
    Bill Cosby (William Henry Cosby, Jr.)
    Bill Gates
    Billy Graham
    Bob Hope
    Brett Favre
    Carl Sagan
    Cesar Chavez
    Charles Lindbergh
    Christopher Reeve
    Chuck Yeager
    Clint Eastwood
    Colin Powell
    Condoleezza Rice
    Donald Trump
    Dwight D. Eisenhower
    Eleanor Roosevelt (Anna Eleanor Roosevelt)
    Ellen DeGeneres
    Elvis Presley
    Frank Sinatra
    Franklin D. Roosevelt
    Frederick Douglass
    George H. W. Bush
    George W. Bush
    George Lucas
    George Patton
    George Washington
    George Washington Carver
    Harriet Ross Tubman
    Harry Truman
    Helen Keller
    Henry Ford
    Hillary Rodham Clinton
    Howard Hughes
    Hugh Hefner
    Jackie Robinson (Jack Roosevelt Robinson)
    Jacqueline Kennedy Onassis
    Jesse Owens
    Jimmy Carter
    Jimmy Stewart
    John Edwards
    John Glenn
    John F. Kennedy
    John Wayne
    Johnny Carson (John William Carson)
    Jonas Edward Salk
    Joseph Smith Jr.
    Katharine Hepburn
    Lance Armstrong
    Laura Bush
    Lucille Ball
    Lyndon B. Johnson
    Madonna (Madonna Louise Veronica Ciccone)
    Malcolm X (Malcolm Little)
    Marilyn Monroe
    Mark Twain (Samuel Langhorne Clemens)
    Martha Stewart
    Martin Luther King Jr.
    Maya Angelou
    Mel Gibson
    Michael Jackson
    Michael Jordan
    Michael Moore
    Muhammad Ali (Cassius Marcellus Clay, Jr.)
    Neil Alden Armstrong
    Nikola Tesla
    Oprah Winfrey
    Pat Tillman
    Dr. Phil McGraw
    Ray Charles
    Richard Nixon
    Robert Kennedy
    Ronald Reagan
    Rosa Parks
    Rudolph W. Giuliani
    Rush Limbaugh
    Sam Walton
    Steve Jobs
    Steven Spielberg
    Susan B. Anthony
    Theodore Roosevelt
    Thomas Edison
    Thomas Jefferson
    Tiger Woods
    Tom Cruise
    Tom Hanks
    Walt Disney
    Wright Brothers (Orville & Wilbur Wright)

    As a general rule I would exclude any current Hollywood stars as well as politicians who have as yet to really accomplish anything substantial (John Edwards??). Personally sports stars leave me cold, but I can recognize that certain ones have acheived iconic status (Muhammed Ali, Babe Ruth). Ditto for singers (Elvis, Sinatra).

    (link and idea via Professor Bainbridge)

  • Thought for the day

    There is nothing conservative about war. For at least the last century war has been the herald and handmaid of socialism and state control. It is the excuse for censorship, organised lying, regulation and taxation. It is paradise for the busybody and the nark. It damages family life and wounds the Church. It is, in short, the ally of everything summed up by the ugly word “progress.” — Peter Hitchens

  • Nonviolent resistance, semi-autonomous zones, and people power

    Reason‘s Jesse Walker surveys some of the recent nonviolent protests in Latin America and elsewhere, pointing out that those which are seen as not aligned with U.S. interests tend to receive much less favorable coverage in the mainstream press.

    He also discusses some of the more interesting and creative ways that people have been taking power back from oppressive and exploitative governments, not by guerilla war and insurrection, but through strikes, protest, nonviolent resistance, and even setting up alternative social structures.