Author: Lee M.

  • Spider-Man, Dr. Strange, and Ayn Rand

    Salon has an interesting article on the great Steve Ditko, co-creator of Spider-Man. It notes the role Ditko’s exteme political individualism came to influence his art:

    Sixties hipsters thought that Ditko’s urban realism and trippy visions meant that he was one of them. They couldn’t have been much more wrong. Around the time that Ditko fell out with Marvel Comics in 1966, he became fascinated with Ayn Rand and objectivism, and his work started to take on a severe and increasingly strident right-wing tone. He spent a few years working for the small company Charlton Comics, where his most significant creation was the Question: a hero in a suit, hat and tie, with no face — just a blank pink blot — and a ruthless contempt for moral relativism. At a subsequent stint with DC Comics, he created the Hawk and the Dove (a pair of superhero brothers, whose personalities were exactly what you’d guess) and the Creeper (a yellow-skinned, green-haired, red-maned, screeching maniac).

    And then, by the end of the ’60s, Ditko retreated into the world of the small press — fanzines and self-published comics — where he could write and draw whatever he pleased. Comics like “Mr. A” and “Avenging World” became his venue to rant semi-intelligibly about objectivism, how there’s no middle ground or gray area in morality, and so on. He spent most of the next 30 years creating Rand-inspired comics that are beautifully designed and composed but almost unreadable; they’re explicitly didactic, but so heavy-handed that it’s impossible to imagine them swaying anyone’s opinions. (Ditko continued to draw hundreds of pages a year through the ’90s but hasn’t published any new work since 2000.)

    Of course, Spider-Man is arguably the least Randian superhero imaginable. He is constantly sacrificing his personal life to altruistically protect others.

  • Cinematic adventures of a (temporary) bachelor

    The wife is out of town for a few days, so I loaded up the Netflix queue with things I knew she wouldn’t want to watch.

    Last night’s offering was Shenandoah, a 1965 Jimmy Stewart vehicle in which Stewart plays Charlie Anderson, a farmer and widower living on his Viriginia farm with his seven children (and one daughter in law) during the last stages of the Civil War. Anderson steadfastly refuses to take sides in the war, and the dramatic tension comes from his efforts to protect his family caught between the two clashing armies from the chaos that war unleashes.

    The synopses of the movie almost invariably describe Anderson as a “pacifist” becuase of his refusal to take up arms on behalf of the Confederacy or the Union. But that doesn’t seem quite right, since Anderson and his boys aren’t afraid to mix it up when the situation calls for it, for instance in beating the tar out of some federal purchasing agents who’ve come to confiscate some of their horses for the Union cavalry.

    Rather, what Anderson seems to be is essentially an anarchist who refuses to fight on behalf of any government. We see this clearly in one exchange between Anderson and a Confederate officer who’s come to recruit Anderson’s six boys for the army.

    Officer: Virginia needs all her sons Mr. Anderson.

    Anderson: That might be so, Johnson, but these are my sons. They don’t belong to the state. When they were babies I never saw the state comin’ around here with a spare tit! We never asked anything of the state and never expected anything. We do our own living, and thanks to no man for the right.

    The anti-slavery Anderson isn’t about to send his boys to fight for a cause he doesn’t believe in. But he’s also not going to be bossed around by Yankees coming in to confiscate his property and kill his countrymen (and who end up taking his youngest son prisoner when the boy is mistaken for a “Johnny Reb”). For Anderson loyalty to his family trumps whatever loyalty he may have to the state, whether it be Virginia, the Confederacy, or the Union.

    Stewart is in fine form here, and, in fact, my one criticism of the film would be that most of the other actors (which include Katherine Ross from The Graduate in an early role as well as Glenn Corbett from Route 66) look positively mediocre in comparison.

    Definitely a melodramatic weepie, but overall a good flick with a stellar performance by the great Stewart.

  • War without cost?

    Andrew Bacevich, author of The New American Militarism, has an article in the American Conservative on Paul Wolfowitz. Bacevich sees Wolfowitz’s worldview as a response to the classic problem of “dirty hands.” Thinkers like Reinhold Niebuhr famously held that it was sometimes necessary to incur guilt while wielding power in service to the the good. America’s alliances with repulsive dictators like Stalin, or the use of weapons of mass destruction during World War II would be examples. This inevatibly implied limitations on the use of force, since it always involved moral costs.

    However, Wolfowitz, at least according to Bacevich, believes that advances in technology have made possible a kind of precision warfare that can, in principle, resolve the Niebuhrian dilemma. Thus also Wolfowitz’s thinking reconciled the urge to do good and the quest for American military supremacy. The US could be both the new Rome and the new Jerusalem. But if the use of force is now to be regarded as essentially morally costless, then it becomes pointless to regard war as a last resort.

    Wolfowitz was opposed in the run-up to the war by Army chief of staff General Eric Shinseki. Shinseki represented the old-school approach to war, directly opposed to Wolfowitz’s vision of war as a routine tool of policy. Shinseki was publicly rebuked and ended up going into early retirement, and, of course, we got our war. Despite his political victory, though, Bacevich sees Wolfowitz’s legacy as a mixed one at best:

    In its trial run, the doctrine of preventive war—Wolfowitz’s handiwork as much as the president’s—has produced liberation and occupation, a crisp demonstration of “shock and awe” and a protracted, debilitating insurgency, the dramatic toppling of a dictator and horrifying evidence implicating American soldiers in torture and other abuses.

    […]

    The forces that Paul Wolfowitz helped unleash—a dangerous combination of hubris and naïveté—are exacting an ever mounting cost. His considerable exertions notwithstanding, truth in matters of statecraft remains implacably gray. Even assuming honorable intentions on the part of those who conceived this war, wielding power in Iraq has left the United States up to its ankles, if not up to its knees, in guilt.

    Not to mention that the much-ballyhooed “precision” weapons we’ve been hearing about since at least the first Gulf War still go off target and still give us ample “collateral damage,” as we’ve seen in Iraq, Kosovo, and elsewhere. Plus, the deliberate targeting of infrastructure, however well-justified militarily, can’t help but affect civilian populations.

  • Feast of St. Justin Martyr

    What sober-minded man, then, will not acknowledge that we are not atheists, worshipping as we do the Maker of this universe, and declaring, as we have been taught, that He has no need of streams of blood and libations and incense; whom we praise to the utmost of our power by the exercise of prayer and thanksgiving for all things wherewith we are supplied, as we have been taught that the only honour that is worthy of Him is not to consume by fire what He has brought into being for our sustenance, but to use it for ourselves and those who need, and with gratitude to Him to offer thanks by invocations and hymns for our creation, and for all the means of health, and for the various qualities of the different kinds of things, and for the changes of the seasons; and to present before Him petitions for our existing again in incorruption through faith in Him. Our teacher of these things is Jesus Christ, who also was born for this purpose, and was crucified under Pontius Pilate, procurator of Judaea, in the times of Tiberius Caesar; and that we reasonably worship Him, having learned that He is the Son of the true God Himself, and holding Him in the second place, and the prophetic Spirit in the third, we will prove. For they proclaim our madness to consist in this, that we give to a crucified man a place second to the unchangeable and eternal God, the Creator of all; for they do not discern the mystery that is herein, to which, as we make it plain to you, we pray you to give heed. —from the First Apology

  • Thought for the day

    God gives what He commands. This testimony of non-violence is not an ‘ideal’ which will appear at the end of our ‘efforts.’ Here, as everywhere else, the life of obedience to which we are called is given to us by grace. This weakness, which I called a demand implied in the Gospel, is really a magnificent promise made to anyone who believes in Jesus Christ. If the branch remains attached to the vine, it too will bear the rare and delicate fruit (John 15). Besides, to live in Christ and keep His commandments is surely one and the same thing. In other words, the triumphant life of Christ crucified and resurrected springs forth of its own accord in the heart of anyone who joins himself to Christ by faith. We are not asked to practise non-violence and imitate Christ’s weakness, so much as to remain in His communion. But He has proclaimed to us that if we remain in it and keep His words, He gives us the grace to live by His example, because He comes Himself to live in our being and obey for us. Then our daily existence is genuinely a witness, because it tells of His love and sings of His power. —Jean Lasserre

  • "God’s servant for your good"

    Memorial Day has occasioned some provocative reflections on the nature of what allegiance, if any, the Christian should give to the secular political order. Pastor John Wright (via Eric) called this the “most dangerous weekend of the year” because it tempts Christians to buy into the mythos of the nation-state, something Pr. Wright deems a parody of the Gospel, complete with its saints, martyrs, and sacrificial economy.

    On a similar note, Dwight at Versus Populum discussed an essay by Michael Budde (from the collection The Church as Counterculture, edited by Budde and Robert W. Brimlow) that contends that Christians should withdraw their allegiance from the nation-state altogether, because it divides them by national loyalty and becuase, whatever good the nation-state does, the price it demands is a willingness to kill in its defense.

    I think these kinds of arguments often grow out of a “thick” eccleisiology as touted by thinkers like Stanley Hauerwas. On this understanding, the church is taken to be a new, alternative polity that in some sense replaces the polities of the world, at least as far as Christians are concerned (though it appears, as Dwight notes, that Budde would go further than Hauerwas in advocating a kind of Christian withdrawal from secular politics).

    On this view the primary (only?) allegiance of a Christian must be to God and his church, not to any earthly community. For Budde it is especially urgent that Christians not participate in or in any way bless the state’s wielding of lethal force. He thinks this is too high of a price to pay for even the supposedly good things that states do such as providing relief to the poor:

    If you want to use Caesar’s tools, you must commit to doing more than praying for Caesar’s health–you must be willing to kill (or hire killers) on Caesar’s behalf. Lobbying, voting, legislating, and the like all stand as endorsements, legitimations, and blessings of state-based power. Christians might have an easier time seeing the stakes if the tradeoffs were put more starkly: for instance, how many foreign deaths are acceptable for the defense of Social Security? How many of other people’s children may be sacrificed to protect aid to indigent children in this country? The tradeoffs are never so obvious or so simplistic, but states do offer a roundabout version of the choice to Christians and others: if you want the “good” state (or clan or imperial) programs, you must commit yourself to protecting the state from challenges to its health …. In the world of states, empires, power-wielding clans, and the like, the “good” programs are options, add-ons, luxuries; the essential elements are those of coercion, control, and power that preserve the state itself. Whatever the regime type, in a crisis welfare programs will be abolished long before the police, army, and the prisons. (p. 223)

    Budde makes a powerful case, but I wonder if he goes to the opposite extreme from those who would deify the state and demand unconditional allegiance. All Christians agree that there are limits to the obedience we can give to the political authorities, but most would disagree that this demands total abstention from politics.

    One such was Jean Lasserre, the French Calvinist and pacifist who greatly influenced Dietrich Bonhoeffer. Lasserre believed that Christians should never kill, but this didn’t mean that they owed no allegiance to the political authorities. In his book War and the Gospel, Lasserre sets out the limits of the Christian’s obedience to the state. Depending on the circumstances, the Christian attitude toward the political authorities can take one of three forms:

    1. When the State in its activities and its orders does not violate God’s order, the Church will take an attitude of benevolent submission towards it, implying scrupulous obedience of the State’s orders by Christians.

    2. But when the State violates God’s order on one point or another, the Church would be unfaithful to its own ministry and its responsibility towards the State, if it did not clearly protest, reminding the State that it is the servant of God for men’s good, not to aggravate their discontent or their disorder. This protest can be embodied in definite and significant acts. However, Christians must patiently endure without rebellion the injustices of which they may themselves be the victims at the hands of the State.

    3. When the State, not content with violating God’s order, tries to make Christians take a personal part in such violation, the Church and Christians must respectfully but openly disobey that demand by the State. This is the price of their fidelity to Jesus Christ.

    For Lasserre, the Ten Commandments provide the standard by which Christians are to judge whether the state is violating God’s order. There aren’t “two moralities,” one for the State and one for the church; rather, the Ten Commandments provide a kind of “floor” beneath which the conduct of the state should not fall:

    Gospel morality is above all positive, proceeding from more or less unlimited declarations: ‘And as ye would that men should do unto you, do ye also to them likewise’; political morality is more negative, proceeding from prohibitions: ‘Thou shall not kill, thou shall not steal,’ etc; but they do not contradict each other. It may not always be easy to bring out in practice the agreement between the demands of these two spheres of Christian morality; but in principle there is still harmony between them. The Decalogue is an indispensable control standard for both political and private morality.

    Of course this does not at once resolve all problems; there will always be border‑line cases where making a decision is terribly delicate and difficult. But there is one thing which can be said: if my thesis is sound, it at last makes possible the Church’s prophetic ministry: in the name of the Decalogue the Church can appreciate just when the State, servant of God for man’s good, starts betraying its mission, becomes a demonic factor of disorder, and at once forfeits the right to Christians’ obedience. The Church can protest against the State’s abuses by reference not to an abstract conception of man, but to the Ten Commandments‑which are concrete enough to be comprehensible to any State. Thanks to them the Church can make the indispensable critical judgment on the State’s laws and demands‑while leaving it a no less indispensable margin for liberty of action. By fighting‑with spiritual arms, of course, including respectful disobedience‑to make the State itself respect the Decalogue, the Church is rendering it the immense service of recalling to it what are the limits of the political order it is charged by God to establish and preserve.

    The political authorities have an indispensable role to play – namely, establishing and preserving political order. In that sense, the church doesn’t replace the state; the political authorities have their own legitimate function. However, the Decalogue provides the parameters that the state may not transgress in carrying out its God-appointed task. He recognizes that states often will transgress these boudaries, and when they do the Christian’s obligation of obedience finds its limit.

    Lasserre takes this to include the sixth commandment in its full rigor: the state is not permitted to kill even acting in its legitimate capacity as protector of its citizens. And Christians do not owe the state the obedience of killing on its behalf:

    According to the Scriptures, a political order conforming to the will of God is one where, among other things, human life is respected and protected. … Murder is always a major disorder, because it is a violation of God’s Law. We know today, as Calvin did not, that the burning of Servet was a disorder; what would Calvinists give that this fire had never been lit! When the State kills, it is contributing to disorder, even if apparently, according to human wisdom, it is limiting disorder. By killing, it adds an extra disorder to those it claims to be putting down. The sixth commandment has another relevance to politics which will lead us to the same conclusion. We have seen that if constraint is indispensable to the State for carrying out its function, the degree of violence or cruelty implied in the use of this constraint is by no means a matter of indifference. There is a certain limit beyond which that constraint ceases to contribute to order in society. When the State is too brutal, it becomes itself a factor of disorder. The spectacle of what goes on in totalitarian countries is an obvious demonstration of this. Our government perhaps has the right to order that a factory occupied by strikers be forcibly cleared, but when people are killed in this police operation, everyone feels that the State has failed and that the disorder is aggravated, not diminished. For in the sight of God a human life has more value than a factory or a juridical principle. It is the same with the State’s constraint as with certain toxic drugs, which are useful in small doses but lethal in strong doses. But where do you find this fine the State must not pass? Without going into the problem of torture, I believe the line is given us by the sixth commandment, which properly signifies this: when the State reaches the point of killing, it has already passed the degree of violence allowed it for maintaining order in the society it has charge over. By killing, it increases disorder and injustice, whatever its declared or secret intention. Whether it lets itself be maddened by fear, or is clever enough to adopt Caiaphas’ aphorism (e.g. when making war), the State betrays its true mission by shedding blood. It abuses its power, imagines that it is protecting, but is really destroying.

    Lasserre doesn’t even deny the state the right to make use of some force, but lethal force he sees as a violation of the sixth commandment. He also commends forms of non-violent resistance as possible alternatives to defending a nation from invasion with lethal force that should be explored.

    I think Lasserre’s perspective provides a helpful corrective to the view of someone like Budde (even if one doesn’t go all the way in embracing pacifism). The advent of the new age through Christ’s death and resurrection certainly “de-sacralizes” the claims of all earthly authorities and relativizes the allegiance owed by Christians to those authorities. The loyalty owed to any political community is, at best, penultimate. But Christians can still support the state in its legitimate functions of creating and preserving a political order and earthly peace. This stance seems to avoid both “sectarianism” and making the Gospel irrelevant to the conduct of politics by invoking a kind of “two-tiered” morality.

  • ESCR, abortion, and consistency

    Speaking of abortion (and I’m not usually that interested in discussing it on the ol’ blog, but we’ll make an exception today), one thing that puzzles me is these congressmen who claim to be “pro-life” but favor embryonic stem cell research:

    Rep. Randy “Duke” Cunningham (R., Calif.), a conservative who described himself as “100 percent pro-life,” choked back tears as he recalled meeting a seriously ill 6-year-old girl at a congressional hearing on medical research.

    “I don’t want another 6-year-old to die,” he said haltingly. “I want to save life.”

    Rep. Lane Evans (D., Ill.) endorsed the bill in a voice distorted by Parkinson’s disease. Rep. James R. Langevin (D., R.I.), another self-described “pro-life” lawmaker, spoke from his wheelchair about the promise of stem-cell research.

    “Stem-cell research gives us hope and a reason to believe,” he said. “I believe one day a child with diabetes will no longer face a lifetime of painful shots and tests. I believe one day families will no longer watch in agony as a loved one with Parkinson’s or Alzheimer’s declines. And I believe one day I will walk again.”

    I’m not saying you couldn’t make that into a coherent position, but it’s pretty much the opposite of my intuitions. As far as I’m concerned, not funding the industrial-scale creation, destruction, and harvesting of nascent human life is pretty obviously wrong, not to mention creepy.

    Abortion, however, I find to be much more of a gut-wrenching issue. Mainly because one important aspect of it involves a person’s control over her own body.

    But if these “pro-life” law makers think that it’s wrong to destroy/kill an embryo in a woman’s womb, how can it possibly be ok to do it in a petri dish? What’s the relevant difference? Since stopping (or even just failing to fund!) ESCR doesn’t involve the kind of coercion that would be required in outlawing abortion, it seems, to me at any rate, much more clear cut.

    (Though props for consistency to, inter alia., Reps. DeLay, Burgess, Akin, Hyde, and Oberstar.)

  • Did abortions increase under Bush?

    That was the claim made by Christian ethicist Glen Stassen. Stassen and others inferred that an increase in “economic injustice” because of Bush’s policies was the culprit.

    But according to this (via Amy Welborn) that claim is, well, false:

    Politicians from Hillary Clinton and John Kerry to Howard Dean have recently contended that abortions have increased since George W. Bush took office in 2001.

    This claim is false. It’s based on an an opinion piece that used data from only 16 states. A study by the Alan Guttmacher Institute of 43 states found that abortions have actually decreased.

    (Needless to say, the Alan Guttmacher Institute is hardly a bastion of anti-abortion propaganda!)