| You are a Black Coffee |
![]() At your best, you are: low maintenance, friendly, and adaptable At your worst, you are: cheap and angsty You drink coffee when: you can get your hands on it Your caffeine addiction level: high |
(via Lutheran Chik)
| You are a Black Coffee |
![]() At your best, you are: low maintenance, friendly, and adaptable At your worst, you are: cheap and angsty You drink coffee when: you can get your hands on it Your caffeine addiction level: high |
(via Lutheran Chik)
Now I think Peter Singer is a philosophical and moral disaster. He has consistently applied utilitarian principles to argue, for instance, that infanticide is justifiable in some cases, and that human beings are not intrinsically more valuable than other animals. Indeed, I would regard that as a kind of reductio ad absurdum of utilitarianism.
Nevertheless, you don’t need to accept his more dubious principles to agree with the thrust of this op-ed. In fact, anyone minimally committed to opposing cruelty to animals and a posessing a certain consistency (e.g. why is it ok to treat a pig in ways you would never dream of treating a dog?) should look askance at many American farming practices.
One of the great things about a long weekend is the chance to catch up on my reading. I’m one who’ll go to library and check out an armfull of books, intending to get to them all…eventually. This weekend I finally got to John Wesley’s A Simple Account of Christian Perfection. It’s basically a collection of reflections, sermons, hymns, and essays on Wesley’s distinctive doctrine.
In a nutshell, Wesley’s claim is that it is possible for Christians to attain perfection in this life, in some cases many years prior to death. By perfection Wesley means, essentially, to be so completely full of love for God and one’s neighbor such that one no longer commits sin (in the sense of an intentional infraction of the moral law). Perfection, he is careful to point out, does not free us from ignorance or other weaknesses that belong to our status as finite embodied beings per se. Perfection also has a strong doxological and eucharistic aspect as we come to accept all things that happen to us with praise and thanksgiving, seeing them as God’s will.
For Wesley, justification means the remission of guilt on account of Christ’s atonement, whereas sanctification is the regeneration of the heart whereby we are “cleansed from all unrighteousness.” He thinks that it is very clear from the Bible that God promises to do this – not merely to save us from the consequences of sin, but to save us from sin itself.
It’s important to note that Wesley doesn’t think that perfection of total sanctification usually comes immediately after justification. There may be, and often is, a long period of growth toward perfection during which we still struggle with sin (though he doesn’t rule out that God may act on someone to bring them to perfection almost immediately). However, the final transition to perfection is an instantaneous movement even when it is preceded by a long period of growth. He also points out that, once attained, this state can be lost, but it needn’t be.
Wesley seems to have a synergistic account of sanctification – while justification is by faith alone, he thinks that the human will cooperates with God’s grace in attaining perfection. Though at times he suggests that it is entirely God working in us. So I’m not sure if he was unclear on this relation, or if he clarifies it elsewhere. He also thinks that we can know both that we have been justified and that we have attained total sanctification. This knowledge seems to come from self-examination, though others can corroborate it to a certain extent. Though he doesn’t claim to have attained this state himself, he does claim to know of people who have.
What to make of Wesley’s account? First of all, I think he’s right that the Bible (and tradition) holds that we are not just forgiven our sins on account of Christ, but God wants to actually deliver us from our sin. I think most Christians would agree that justification & the forgiveness of sins inagurates a new life in which we participate in Christ by the power of the Holy Spirit. And it has usually been taken that some progress in sanctification is possible in this life, that Christians are empowered to live according to God’s standards of rigteousness.
Does that mean, though, that it’s possible to attain perfection in this life? Here I think Wesley may overreach. First of all, I think his epistemology is a bit questionable. Is it really possible to determine by self-examination that we have been justified and/or attained perfection? This seems like a notoriously unreliable procedure. Once we make our own internal states the test of how we stand with God, we seem to be in danger of building our house on some pretty unstable sand.
This is where I think Luther’s emphasis on the “external word” can have a salutary effect. According to Luther we should not look inward to try and determine if we really have faith, but rather we should look outward – to Christ and to the promises God makes to us, which we receive through the preached word and the sacraments. These external means of grace have a solidity and objectivity that we can trust. Luther well knew the dangers of excessive self-examination.
Even if we could verify it by self-examination, I wonder if asserting that some do in fact attain perfection is to claim to know more than has been revealed to us. Exegetical considerations aside, it seems safer to say that one may attain perfection, and that it is something to be strived for, but we should be agnostic about whether this in fact occurs. We could draw a parallel with the question of universalism. Some want to positively assert that God will or must save everyone. But this seems to be more than we can know, and in fact an attempt to tie God’s hands by appeal to some abstract notion of justice. Better, I think, to say that we should hope and pray that God will save everyone, without asserting that we know this will in fact happen.
Another reason to be agnostic about the attainment of perfection is that making perfection the telos of our life may, ironically, lead us to an excessive self-concern. This is another point where the Lutheran tradition has a contribution to make. Rightly understood, justification by faith alone ought to inculcate in us a certain self-forgetfulness. Since my destiny is secure, because my life is “hidden with Christ in God,” I don’t have to worry about traversing some path of holiness or climing some spiritual ladder. Again, the Christians attention is turned outward toward the neighbor and his needs. Precisely because I don’t have to worry about myself I am free to serve the neighbor in love.
That said, I think Wesley has a word to say to us as well. Lutherans, perhaps becuase they have tended to focus so much on justification, have downplayed sanctification. This can result in a certain complacency about sin, whereas Wesley reminds us that it is always possible to press on further toward the goal, even if we don’t attain it in this life.
Another contribution that Wesley’s emphasis on holiness can make is that it can give shape to Christian love. In emphasizing the neighbor and his needs, a Lutheran ethos may fail to provide us with a way of distinguishing genuine from spurious needs. “Love and do what thou wilt” may be a sufficiently concrete ethic for saints, but I suspect that the rest of us need more guidance than that. Lutherans have often fallen back on the “orders of creation” as specifying in more detail the obligations we have to others. But this can blunt the radicalness of Christianity and sanctify the status quo. By contrast, the Wesleyan emphasis on the imitatio Christi can give a more particularly Christian shape to works of love directed toward the neighbor.
Open Court Press appears to have stumbled on to a publishing goldmine with their Popular Culture and Philosophy series – each title offers a collection of essays reflecting on some aspect of pop culture. Initially I was suspicious that anything good could come of this, but a friend bought me The Simpsons and Philosopy as a birthday present and it was surprisingly good.
So, when I found myself at Borders last night with a 30% off any item coupon in my hot little hands, I was pleasantly surprised to come across Mel Gibson’s Passion and Philosophy. The essays offer philosophical reflection on the film itself, but also on the broader topics it raises like the Atonement, artistic depictions of the Passion, Jesus and violence, and so on, all written by serious scholars. I’ve only read one essay so far, but it was a really excellent one by Loyola University of Chicago philosopher Paul K. Moser on “The Crisis of the Cross: God as Scandalous” (which you can also read online here).
Obviously the Passion of Our Lord has a rich history of providing fodder for deep thinking, so maybe the quality of this volume exceeds such titles as Buffy the Vampire Slayer and Philosophy or The Atkins Diet and Philosophy(!), but based on my limited sample I have to say that they’ve produced some quality material.
“Fr. Jape” has a long, rambling, at times snarky, critique of the new “chastity movement” among hip young evangelicals in the latest New Pantagruel. This, however, is a good point:
Much of the energy of the purity brigade is generated by the opposite notion—that it is the chaste, rather than the unchaste, who suffer. Thus, as opposed to their happy-go-lucky-rutting-round-the-clock counterparts, the chaste require “intentional communities,” as Winner makes it, for constant group therapy. Being consigned to a life cut off from human contact would entail suffering. But trying to avoid sin is hardship, not suffering. The idea that you are suffering is just your dirty “old man of sin” talking, as the Apostle names the bugger. You should want him to suffer and drop dead. His pain is your gain! But don’t try to make an epic tale out of it. In the history of the church, many people have truly suffered, but the struggle for chastity seems to rate as a particularly saintly, heroic enterprise only among the evangelicals and Jesus freaks—and only in recent decades. They need to grow up.
Now, at the risk of offering more information than readers care to have, I’m in no position to lecture others on the virtues of pre-marital chastity. But it does strike me that we’ve lowered our standards quite a bit when simply managing not to have sex is taken to be an exercise in heroic virtue!
All the ink spilled over Cindy Sheehan and Pat Robertson over the last few weeks seems pretty trivial now doesn’t it?
Just another quick post to highlight some hurricane relief efforts.
Here is a good list of organizations.
This site has some tips on giving wisely and effectively.
Some specific church groups providing relief:
ELCA Disaster Response
Catholic Charities
Methodist Relief
Presbyterian Disaster Assistance
Mennonite Central Committee
The New Pantagruel is trying to push the boundaries of what might constitute authentically “conservative” thought by posting brief summations of various “tendencies” (ideologies would be too strong) that have existed throughout American history, but mostly at the margins. The articles are excerpts from the recently published (scratch that: forthcoming) American Conservatism: An Encyclopedia. These alternatives bear slight resemblence to what passes for mainstream conservative thought nowadays, with its lionization of the economics of Wal-Mart and the valorization of the warfare state.
Here are the pieces:
“Community” by Caleb Stegall
“Agrarianism” by Jeremy Beer
“Anarchism” by Bill Kauffman
“Localism” by Allan Carlson
I was particularly happy to see the essay by Bill Kauffman, one of my favorite political writers.
Kauffman writes:
Perhaps no political term is quite so misunderstood as “anarchy.” In the popular press, it is a synonym for disorder and chaos, not to mention looting and pillage: countries like Haiti are always being “plunged into anarchy.” The anarchist, meanwhile, is frozen into a late-nineteenth-century caricature: he is furtive, hirsute, beady-eyed, given to gesticulation, gibberish, and, most of all, pointless acts of violence. Yet anarchy, according to most of its proponents through the years, is peaceable, wholly voluntary, and perhaps a bit utopian. The word means “without a ruler”; anarchy is defined as the absence of a state and its attendant coercive powers. It implies nothing about social arrangements, family and sexual life, or religion; and in fact the most persuasive anarchists, from Russian novelist Leo Tolstoy to Catholic Worker founder Dorothy Day, have been Christians. [Kauffman, incidentally, penned an article a few years back called The Way of Love: Dorothy Day and the American Right, which connects Day’s “Catholic anarchism” to the decentralist, anti-imperialist Old Right.]
…echoes of native anarchism may be heard throughout American history: in the warnings of the Anti-Federalists about the centralizing thrust of the new Constitution; in the Garrisonian abolitionists who reviled any government that countenanced slavery; in the Populists of the 1890s, with their attacks on chartered corporations and paper wealth; in the Old Right of the 1930s, which saw the New Deal as potentially totalitarian; in the New Left of the 1960s, which denounced the military, the university, and the corporation as dehumanizing; and among contemporary libertarians, especially those influenced by the economist and anti-imperialist Murray N. Rothbard. But except for the anarchist-tinged Industrial Workers of the World, the radical labor union that reached its zenith in the early twentieth century, anarchists have never been adept organizers. For the most part anarchy in the United States has been a literary-political tendency. A very partial list of American men and women of letters who have described themselves as anarchists includes Henry Adams (a “conservative Christian anarchist”), Paul Goodman, Norman Mailer, Robinson Jeffers, e.e. cummings, Lawrence Ferlinghetti, Ursula Le Guin, William Saroyan, Dwight Macdonald, and Edward Abbey. Abbey’s novels, especially The Brave Cowboy (1956), The Monkeywrench Gang (1975), and The Fool’s Progress (1988), feature merry anarchist heroes who live by Abbey’s anarchist creed: “Be loyal to your family, your clan, your friends, and your community. Let the nation-state go hang itself.”
I myself have always had a soft spot for such “literary anarchists” – folk who despise the impersonalizing largeness of the nation-state, the corporation, and other institutions that make it difficult to live life on a “human scale.” Whether their anarchist vision is realizable or sustainable is debatable, but I think it offers a valuable corrective to the worship of power and the resort to coercion and domination (the libido dominandi as Augustine called it) that humans are entirely too prone to.
Andrew J. Bacevich is a Vietnam vet and West Point grad who now teaches International Relations at Boston University. He’s contributed articles to such conservative periodicals as National Review, The Weekly Standard, and First Things.
Now Bacevich has written one of the better political books to come out this year. Rather than a shrill anti-Bush screed, The New American Militarism tries, in a largely non-polemical fashion, to understand how we got to where we are and what we might do about it.
By “the new American militarism” Bacevich means a mindset or worldview that manifests itself in “a romanticized view of soldiers, a tendency to see military power as the truest measure of national greatness, and outsized expectations regarding the efficacy of force” (p. 2). He characterizes this view as “Wilsonianism under arms,” which seeks “a world remade in America’s image and therefore permanently at peace” (p. 10).
Our own day has seen the revival of Wilsonina ambitions and Wilsonian certainty, this time, however, combined with a pronounced affinity for the sword. With the end of the Cold War, the constraints that once held American ideologues in check fell away. Meanwhile, in more than a few quarters, America’s unprecedented military ascendancy, a by-product of victory in the Cold War, raised the alluring prospect that here at last was the instrument that would enable the United States to fulfill its providential mission. (p. 11)
Rather than the concoction of a sinister cabal of oilmen or neoconservatives who hoodwinked the American public after 9/11, Bacevich thinks that the roots of this “military metaphysic” go much deeper. It is the result of a confluence of forces that sought, largely with honorable motives, to rebuild American honor and prestige after the disaster of Vietnam. These include the military itself, certain public intellectuals, a certain mythology about America deployed by politicians – preeminently Ronald Reagan, and politically conservative evangelical Christians.
The prestige of the military was at an all-time low after Vietnam, and officers like Creighton Abrams undertook a very deliberate program of rebuilding that consisted of refurbishing the image of the American soldier as virtuous, efficient, and dedicated to the common good and building up the physical capacity of the military to guarantee that it would win any future conventional wars handily. In other words, to avoid another Vietnam at all costs.
In the realm of ideas, certain public intellectuals (people like Norman Podhoretz and Irving Kristol) has become increasingly appaled by what they saw as the hippie irrationality and nihilism of the New Left. In addition to corroding cherished American values, the New Left threatened to enervate America’s ability to stand up to international communism abroad. In the aftermath of Vietnam, with its calls for America to “come home” (as embodied in the McGovern campaign), the Left, in the eyes of these “neoconservatives” (as socialist Michael Harrington dubbed them), was recapitulating the days of Weimar Germany, when a flaccid liberalism was unable to withstand the onset of fascism. For the necons it is always 1939 and the greatest danger is always “appeasement” of fascism, communism, or Islamic radicalism. The neocons saw it as their appointed task to restore America’s confidence in its values so that it could sustain a free and decent society at home, and lead the battle against the Soviet Union on the world stage.
Thus these intellectuals, most of them Democrats in the Truman-Humphrey mold, found themselves supporting the candidacy of Ronald Reagan in 1980. Reagan’s effectiveness as a politician, Bacevich thinks, had a lot to do with his ability to deploy a mythology of America as a land of unlimited possibilities. Jimmy Carter, in his famous “malaise” speech, had suggested that Americans needed to learn to live with lowered expectations, by, for instance, reducing our dependence on foreign oil. Reagan countered that it was morning in America and that all we needed was to unleash the creative potential of the American by removing the shackles of big government. There was no need for Americans to limit their consumption or their freedom. America was a force for good in the world, not the evil empire of “Amerikkka” that radicals on the Left deplored.
For better or for worse, it was Reagan’s vision of America that prevailed, and the 1980s saw a dramatic revision in the public perception of the military. Reagan went out of his way to praise the armed forces, to appear in public with soldiers, and to emphasize the inherent goodness of the military calling. Whereas post-Vietnam Hollywood had focused on the horrors of war and what it did to the men serving, the 80s gave us the sanitized, heroic version of military life in movies like Top Gun.
Another group that saw the revitalization of the military as a key part of an American moral renewal were politically conservative evangelical Protestants. Leaders like Jerry Fallwell combined a loathing of godless communism with a belief in the virtue of soldiers as a key to a greater moral renewal in America. Indeed, one of the interesting stories Bacevich tells is how evangelical leaders made major inroads into the military chaplaincy, with cooperation from the military who, as we saw above, had their own reasons for wanting virtuous, disciplined recruits. Bacevich also notes that conservative evangelicals tended to see the U.S. (and Israel) as exempt from the normal restraints of just war fighting due to their exalted status in God’s plan.
The final piece in the puzzle that rebuilt the confidence in a strategy of “global power projection” was the innovative thinking of an elite group of war strategists, associated with think tanks like the RAND corporation. Thinkers like Albert Wohlstetter and Andrew Mashall were proponents of what came to be known as the Revolution in Military Affairs (RMA). The basic idea is that technological advances have reduced the costs and increased the effectiveness of military intervention, making possible relatively painless military actions rather than the massive clashes of armies that characterized the two World Wars.
All of these efforts came to fruition in operation Desert Storm. The U.S. rallied the nations of the world to punish the aggression of a rogue state. An incredibly efficient, technologically advanced military routed the Iraqis out of Kuwait with lightning speed and with casualties (at least on our side) kept to a minimum. Soldiers were not seen as dropouts or psychopaths as they sometimes had been in the Vietnam era, but well-trained and virtuous professionals. We had finally, it seemed, put the “Vietnam syndrome” behind us.
Next I’ll discuss Bacevich’s views on what went wrong, why we got involved in the Middle East in the first place, and his vision for a genuine “common defense” of the U.S.
The good news just keeps rolling in on the health front. First it was that booze is good for the old ticker, then we found out that dark chocolate helps lower blood pressure, now it turns out coffee may help prevent cancer!
Some truffles, an espresso, and a glass of bourbon – now that’s my idea of a heart healthy meal!
Reason has an interesting article on the history of coffee’s negative image.