Author: Lee M.

  • War with Iran: A Bad Idea

    I realize I’m starting to sound like a Matthew Yglesias groupie, but this article on why war with Iran is a very, very bad idea is one of the best I’ve read. Even bracketing moral considerations, there just doesn’t seem to be a feasible military option that prevents Iran from getting nukes, rather than perhaps delaying it. Aerial bombing wouldn’t guarantee anything more than a setback, regime change-plus-occupation simply isn’t doable under current conditions, and a Mark Steyn-style “decapitation” (regime change without occupation) would just be plumb foolish.

    P.S. See also this piece by Israeli military historian Martin van Creveld.

  • Musings of a crunchy con symp

    Thanks to Pastor Chip Frontz, who graciously loaned me his copy of Rod Dreher’s Crunchy Cons, I can weigh in, if somewhat belatedly, on the whole phenomenon.

    As I see it, the crunchy con ethos can be understood as an attempt to bring to bear a traditionalist religious (or philosophical) sensibility to bear on the modern world and finding that it doesn’t match up with the kinds of positions usually labeled “conservative.” Dreher himself expresses surprise at the extent to which religious commitment informs the choices of the crunchy cons he interviewed.

    In one sense, this shouldn’t be surprising. Popular American conservative ideology as we know it, rather than being an organic and coherent worldview, was in many ways a reaction against Communism. During the Cold War we seemed to need an ideology to pose against that of the godless communism of the Soviets, and this ended up being something like “God + Patriotism + Democracy + Capitalism” (not necessarily in that order). But a commitment to “democratic capitalism,” or at least actually existing democratic capitalism, is not obviously congruent with the values found in the Western religious and philosophical tradition. Any reader of the Gospels (or Plato or Aristotle for that matter) will quickly discover that the pursuit of wealth, for instance, is eyed with considerable suspicion.

    So it makes sense to me that people who are strongly committed to a fairly traditional religious worldview would grow uneasy with consumer capitalism, disregard for the integrity of the environment, and vulgar or vacuous pop culture. For the crunchy con, the good life is defined by the pursuit of virtue and fidelity to tradition, even when this conflicts with the values that prevail in American society. The “con” part is the fidelity to tradition, and the “crunchy” part is the unorthodox (from a mainstream conservative perspective) stance with respect to capitalism, the environment, consumerism, etc.

    This sensibility is given more concrete shape through Dreher’s discussion of his own family’s experience as well as through interviews with other crunchies. The organizing principle he offers for the crunchy view of the world is “sacramentalism.” In short, this is the idea that holiness or spirit is mediated through the physical.

    The best explication of this that I’ve seen is in Fr. Alexander Schmemann’s For the Life of the World. Fr. Schmemann says that there are two basic ways of looking at the religious life. One sees religion as a “spiritual” realm removed and separate from ordinary life, a sanctuary to which we retreat from the mundane physical world. The flip side of this spiritualized religion is the “activist” type which embraces the secular, focusing everything on politics, social justice, etc. and basically ignoring the spiritual aspect of existence. We work to feed the hungry but forget to tell them about the Bread of Life.

    Only in the Bible, he says, is this dichotomy overcome:

    In the Bible the food that man eats, the world of which he must partake in order to live, is given to him by God, and it is given as communion with God. The world as man’s food is not something “material” and limited to material functions, thus different from, and opposed to, the specifically “spiritual” functions by which man is related to God. All that exists is God’s gift to man, and it all exists to make God known to man, to make man’s life communion with God. It is divine love made food, made life for man. God blesses everything He creates, and, in biblical language, this means that He makes all creation the sign and means of His presence and wisdom, love and revelation: “O taste and see that the Lord is good.” (p. 14)

    For crunchy cons, this sacramental view of the world can and should carry over into areas like how we spend our money, how we prepare and consume food, how we educate our children, and our attitude toward the environment and technology. In Dreher’s view mainstream American conservatism has largely abandoned this outlook in favor of a utilitarian devotion to the free market. This is combined with a view of the material world as a sheer resource to be consumed, rather than something to be received as a gift.

    For instance, if the natural world is a gift from God with its own integrity, then practices like large-scale industrial farming and fast food suddenly come into question. This isn’t because it’s wrong for us to use nature for our own benefit, but because these practices tend to reduce to the natural world to a commodity to be exploited rather than a gift to be received in gratitude. Though Dreher doesn’t mention him, the insights of philosopher Albert Borgmann seem pertinent here. Borgmann is a critic of technology, but not a Luddite. His worry is that technological exploitation of nature threatens what he calls “focal things” and “focal practices.” At the risk of seeming pompous, I’ll quote what I wrote about Borgmann last year:

    A focal thing is something that calls forth our attention and engagement rather than being immediately available for our use. Focal things are real in their own right, rather than being commodities produced for our effortless consumption. And a focal practice is the activity whereby we engage with this reality. Paradigm instances of focal things for Borgmann are wilderness, musical instruments, the written word and the communal meal. The corresponding focal practices might be hiking, learning to play music, reading to each other and preparing the meal. These all require an active understanding and engagement with the underlying reality and the development of certain skills and virtues.

    Technology threatens focal practices because it attempts to make everything available and pliable at the push of a button or flip of a switch. It’s much easier to turn on the CD player and hear a flawless performance than to practice my own halting efforts at learning to play an instrument. But Borgmann thinks that focal practices are precisely what give life its meaning – a life reduced to an endless variety of consumption is unbearably banal.

    Crunchy cons worry that a world where everything is available as a commodity is one where we risk losing meaning and virtue for the sake of ease and convenience. Dreher writes about the family of evangelical Christians who started their own organic farm in order to raise food and animals in a way that more closely mirrors the way they believe God intended. To do this is to renounce the attitude that would turn the natural world into a commodity in favor of one that respects nature’s own integrity.

    To use Borgmann’s terminology, crunchy cons think that too many of our focal practices have been “outsourced” to corporations and the state. That’s why growing and/or preparing one’s own food, avoiding mass-produced culture, and homeschooling are central crunchy con endeavors.

    The political implications of all this are never made entirely clear. Dreher emphasizes that crunchy con-ism is more of a way of life than a political program. Though he does offer near the end of the book a tentative (and somewhat vague) crunchy con platform that includes reform of agricultural and health policies that make it easier for small farms to compete with agribusiness, zoning laws that favor historical preservation and high aesthetic standards, laws that make it easier to homeschool, and an energy policy aimed at reducing our dependence on foreign oil, along with more traditional social conservative concerns like restricting abortion and pornography, banning cloning, and tighter regulation of the biotech industry. He emphasizes, however, that not all crunchy cons would sign on to this; many, in fact, seem to have a strong libertarian streak and would be wary of using the government to instill “crunchy” virtues.

    I have to say that I’m generally sympathetic to many of the crunchies’ concerns, but there are some points of weakness. The most glaring, in my view, is that Dreher presents a lot of false dualisms. There are, on the one hand, virtuous crunchies, and on the other soulless, fast food munching, McMansion-dwelling mainstream conservatives. There are traditionalist religious believers who submit themselves to something greater than themselves, and “progressive” religious believers whose religion is little more than a projection of the needs or desires of the self. There is the wicked world of decadent American pop culture, suburban subdivisions, SUVs and consumerism versus the crunchy enclaves of quasi-monastic preservers of high culture (the last chapter is called “Waiting for Benedict”, a nod to Alasdair MacIntyre’s call for new forms of community that can uphold virtue in an increasingly barbarous world), Arts-and-Crafts urban bungalows, Volvos and bicycles, and self-sacrificing homeschoolers.

    Needless to say, there are a whole bunch of people who don’t fall into either of these stereotypes. And I can’t help but wonder if Dreher (unconsciously?) exaggerates how bad American culture is in order to validate the rebellious, “countercultural” (a word he uses with annoying frequency) self-image of the crunchy cons. Are most people in America really mindless consumerist drones driving their SUV’s to their bleak suburban subdivisions only to flop on the couch in front of the TV with their frozen pre-packaged dinners?

    After all, things like enthusiasm for organic food, environmentalism, “smart growth” and so on are hardly fringe movements anymore. Not to mention that many of the social problems that conservatives are worried about (teen pregnancy, abortion, school violence) have actually been getting better in recent years. And, personally, I think popular culture still has lots of bright spots (even TV!). Granted it’s tempting to think of oneself as part of a virtuous remnant in Babylon, but wouldn’t it make more sense for crunchy cons and their fellow travelers to encourage these positive trends by participating in and building up a common civic culture that can respond to crunchy concerns?

  • The Catholic Willow Creek?

    Interesting story in the Chicago Tribune about a Catholic parish outside of Chicago that has consciously, and by this account successfully, modeled itself after evangelical megachurches. In fact, it’s a mere three miles away from the (in)famous Willow Creek, and has managed to win parishoners back who were worshiping there.

    The secret to the 22-year-old church’s success has been replicating what growing churches are doing, but in a Catholic way. The result is an innovative congregation that bills itself as “an evangelical church in the Roman Catholic tradition.”

    “I think what happened to the Catholic Church is we became a little comfortable with ourselves and forgot some of what made us Catholic. We forgot what made us passionate,” said Holy Family’s pastor, Rev. Pat Brennan. “So I’ve just taken the best that I’ve seen of Catholic parishes and evangelical churches and put them together to make Holy Family. In doing that, I think we’ve rediscovered the heart of Catholicism.”

    Like several other parishioners, Mary Whiteside said she was on the verge of abandoning her Catholic faith when she found Holy Family. On her first visit, Whiteside said she was hooked by the music and the pastor’s riveting homilies. Her husband, Phil, who was raised a Baptist, was so moved that he converted to Catholicism.”

    Great things are happening in this church. We’re just very alive,” said Whiteside, who is on the parish leadership council. “We’re sharing some elements of the evangelical church, but I don’t think we’re trading any part of our Catholic identity.”

    Holy Family was started two decades ago when Cardinal Joseph Bernardin [coiner of the “consistent ethic of life” – Lee] became concerned about the large numbers of Catholics in the northern suburbs leaving their churches to become members of Willow Creek Community Church. In 1984, the former archbishop purchased 16 acres of farmland in Inverness and founded a new parish community, Holy Family.

    You can read the rest of the story here (link via Wesley Blog).

    Though there has been some controversy:

    But tensions have risen with the current archbishop, Cardinal Francis George, who supports a more orthodox view of the liturgy than his predecessor. Parishioners say the most recent example of that tension is the dispute over kneelers.

    In the church’s original design, Holy Family never had kneelers, partly to replicate evangelical churches but also to provide more room between pews. But when the church presented renovation plans to the archdiocese last year, parishioners learned the plans would not be approved unless the church installed kneelers.

    “I’m disappointed,” said Rosemary Geisler. “That was a decision that should have been left up to the people, and instead it was forced on us.”

    The minor dispute has led some parishioners to worry about the type of priest who will be selected as pastor of Holy Name after Brennan’s term ends in two years. Dolores Siok, who has been at Holy Family for 17 years, worries about what will happen if the new priest wants to take the church back to Catholic orthodoxy.

    Now, I’m guessing most of the members of Holy Family wouldn’t say they’ve departed from Catholic orthodoxy!

    Clearly, though, it’s not just Protestants who deal with the tension between being faithful to our tradition and attracting new people (or retaining already existing members).

  • Curses!

    I may have mentioned previously that we are relocating to the Boston area this summer. By all accounts Boston is a great town, and I’m really looking forward to the move.

    However, I am disgruntled to discover that Yuengling doesn’t distribute to Massachusetts! For those not in the know, Yuengling (‘ying-ling’), the self-proclaimed oldest brewery in America (located in Pottsville, Pa.), is the maker of the most widely-drunk beer in the Philadelphia area, Yuengling Lager. Unlike most of your mass-marketed American lagers, Yuengling makes a smooth-drinkin’ lager that actually tastes good and is comparatively cheap. Walk into any bar in Philly and simply order “lager” and Yuengling is what you’ll get. Not to mention they make a good porter and Black and Tan as well.


    Though, by all accounts, Boston is no slouch when it comes to beer, so I’ll no doubt be able to cope.

  • The catholicity of pietism

    In his essay “Lutheran Pietism and Catholic Piety,” found in the collection The Catholicity of the Reformation, church historian Robert Louis Wilken argues that Lutheran pietism was in part an attempt to recover some of the features of medieval piety that had been swept aside by the Reformation. Johann Arndt, the grandfather of Lutheran pietism, was steeped in medieval spirituality and even published editions of the German mystic Johann Tauler’s Theologica Germania (which influenced Luther himself) as well as Thomas a Kempis’s Imitation of Christ. Arndt’s own magnum opus, True Christianity was extremely influential on later pietists like Philip Jakob Spener and Wilken says that Lutheran immigrants were likely to have True Christianity along with a Bible, a hymnal, and a copy of Luther’s Small Catechism with them upon arriving in America.

    Pietism was concerned to correct what it saw as the one-sidedness of Lutheran orthodoxy with its emphasis on doctrinal correctness and a strongly forensic view of justification. While the early pietists like Arndt and Spener strongly believed in justification by faith, they believed just as strongly that it should call forth a new life in the believer, marked by an alteration in the affections. The believer comes to actually love God:

    In Arndt, as in all spiritual writers, the movement of God toward human beings is complemented by a movement of the believer toward God, a raising up, an ascent, which is propelled by love and longing for God. Love is the basis for fellowship and union with God. “The end of all theology and Christianity is union with God . . . marriage with the heavenly bridegroom Jesus Christ.” (p. 83)

    Wilken says that the passions and affections have long had a positive role in Christian piety, in contrast with Stoicism which urged its followers to eliminate their passions and subordinate them to reason. For theologians like Gregory of Nyssa and Maximus the Confessor, eros, or desire, while prone to distortion, can lead us to God. This idea is more Platonic than Stoic; for Plato eros should prompt us to move beyond the material realm to contemplation of the Good and the Beautiful. For Gregory, meanwhile, desire and yearning lead us to cling to God and learn the “habit of loving the beautiful.” Maximus the Confessor says that desire can bring about a “yearning for divine things” and that the passions are necessary to motivate us to fix our minds on God.

    The pietism of Arndt, Spener, and Johann Gerhard, Wilken contends, was in continuity with these ancient strands of Christian spirituality. For Gerhard, God’s love toward us isn’t simply a declaration of forgiveness, but also kindles the flame of love in our hearts for God in return. “Love is the chief thing that unites us to God because the one who loves and that which is loved become one” (quoted by Wilken, p. 89).

    Whatever one wishes to call these strands of Lutheran spirituality, there can be no question that their piety grew out of a genuinely biblical and hence authentically Catholic impulse. In giving priority to the love of God in the Christian life, they set forth a vision of the Christian life, as did St. Paul and St. John, in which the Christ for us was perfected by the Christ in us, and not least, they inspired the faithful to pursue a life of holiness as does the Bible.

    […]

    The spiritual world they presented to Lutheran readers was not the product of deformed late medieval piety (if there ever was such a thing); it was the fruit of centuries of Christian thought and experience based on the Scriptures and informed by the central articles of faith–namely, the two natures of Christ and the doctrine of the Holy Trinity–and by the sacraments. Indeed, one might press the point to argue that it was because they drew on the spiritual traditions of the medieval world, which were, of course, nurtured by the spiritual writers of the early church, that these early pietists were so biblical. (pp. 90-1)

    Unfortunately, later pietism seems to have gotten detached from the firm commitment to Word and Sacrament that characterized men like Arndt and Spener and become more interested in spiritual introspection, looking for evidence of sanctification in the self, rather than looking to Christ for assurance. Some of the later pietist writings are filled with a morbid introspection and obsession with cleansing the self of any trace of sin. The genius of the Lutheran reformation, it seems to me, was that it boldly proposed that all of our righteousness rests in Christ, not in ourselves and comes as a sheer gift. Ideally this leads to a certain self-forgetfulness that expresses itself in gratitude toward God and love for neighbor.

    Wilken says that Lutheran pietism was bound to peter out once it was no longer being nourished by catholic piety (a judgment that is not too surprising considering that Wilken has since gone over to Rome). He deems the Reformation a brilliant, but one-sided movement that needed Catholic substance and Protestant principle to maintain a sustainable piety.

    He concludes:

    The early Lutheran spiritual writers, Johan Arndt and John Gerhard, remind us that the first commandment is: “You shall love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your might.” From this they draw the obvious conclusion: loving God is the beginning and the end of the Christian life, and Christian life is about the ordering of one’s loves. “Where your treasure is, there will your heart be also.” Christian faith is as much a matter of what one loves as it is of what one believes or what one does. For the gift that God desires is the gift of ourselves, and there is no giving of the self that is not a giving of the heart. St. Augustine wrote: “We offer to him, on the altar of the heart, the sacrifice of humility and praise, and the flame on the altar is the burning fire of love. To see him as he can be seen and to cleave to him, we purify ourselves from every stain of sin and evil desire and we consecrate ourselves in his name. For he himself is the source of our bliss, he himself is the goal of all our striving. . . . For we direct our course towards him with love so that in reaching him we may find our rest, and attain our happiness because we have achieved our fulfillment in him.” (pp. 91-2)

    Obviously I’d like to be less pessimistic than Wilken about magisterial Protestantism’s ability to sustain the kind of piety that does result in the proper ordering of our loves (or at least a movement in that direction). Much of what passes for “spirituality” in bookstores and on TV, even supposedly Christian spirituality, is more about coping with stress or getting a better career than it is about learning to love God. And many of our churches seem wary of anything that doesn’t promise an immediate ethical or social payoff. The idea of loving God for his own sake, rather than as a means to some human project, seems to have fallen on hard times.