A friend who’s a student at the Kennedy School of Government sends along a link to their brand new Africa Policy Journal. It aims to discuss Africa-related issues and policy from the perspective of Africans.
You can view the inagural issue here.
A friend who’s a student at the Kennedy School of Government sends along a link to their brand new Africa Policy Journal. It aims to discuss Africa-related issues and policy from the perspective of Africans.
You can view the inagural issue here.
The Christian Century reports on a recent speech by Congressman Henry Hyde of Illinois, a staunch conservative Republican, warning against overconfidence in our power to remake the world:
“It is a truism that power breeds arrogance. A far greater danger, however, stems from the self-delusion that is the more certain companion. For individuals and countries alike, power inevitably distorts perceptions of the world by insulating them in a soothing cocoon that is impervious to what scientists term ‘disconfirming evidence.’
[…]
“There is no evidence that we or anyone can guide from afar revolutions we have set in motion. We can more easily destabilize friends and others and give life to chaos and to avowed enemies than ensure outcomes in service of our interests and security. . . . In a world where the ratios of strength narrow, the consequences of miscalculation will become progressively more debilitating. The costs of golden theories will be paid for in the base coin of our interests.
[…]
“To allow our enormous power to delude us into seeing the world as a passive thing waiting for us to re-create it in an image of our choosing will hasten the day when we have little freedom to choose anything at all.”
Meanwhile, libertarian Jim Henley ruminates on the decline of limited government conservatism. The culprits? War, resentment of the left, and nationalism.
If you had asked me in, say, 2000 I would’ve said I was basically a small-government conservative: pro-free trade, pro-limited and accountable government, in favor of a “more humble” foreign policy as promised at the time by candidate Bush. I voted with little enthusiasm for Bush in 2000, sensing that he was far more comfortable in the pro-business, country club wing of the GOP (with a few sops for the Christian right) than anywhere else.
But what “actually existing” conservatism under a Bush White House and Republican-controlled Congress has turned out to depart from tradtional conservatism even more than I expected: massive increases in pork spending, giveaways to well-connected friends and donors, pro-corporate (as opposed to pro-free-market) economic policies, assertions of unchecked executive power, and a globe-straddling military presence.
I think I’ve probably drifted leftward in the last few years, but I’m not sure how much of that is genuine ideological evolution and how much is simply finding myself opposed to what the current administration is doing (particularly when it comes to things like war and peace, torture, civil liberties, etc.), and therefore ending up “on the left” sort of by default.
Addendum: I haven’t read it yet, but the Cato Institute recently released a report (PDF) on the Bush Administration’s record on that whole “defend and uphold the Constitution” thing.
Amnesty International has released a report stating that torture and inhumane treatment are “widespread” under U.S. custody. This goes against the “a few bad apples” line that Washington has pushed.
See also this reflection from theologian George Hunsinger.
Lots of well-intentioned folks are urging us to “do something” about the crisis in Darfur. And, heaven knows, there’s a lot of bad stuff going down. Just recently it was reported that the UN had to cut its rations to refugees there due to inadequate funding. That seems like something that could, and should, be remedied relatively easily by an influx of cash.
But there’s something a little troubling to me about some of the rhetoric, the talk of “saving” Darfur, as if all we, as enlightened westerners, have to do is go in there and straighten things out. Let’s recall that our history of going into troubled spots around the globe and successfully straightening things out is a mixed one, to put it mildly. Given our success at creating peace and brotherhood in Iraq (Kosovo, Somalia, etc.), maybe Sudan should be spared our ministrations.
And, almost inevitably it seems, we end up, in our zeal for separating every conflict into good guys and bad guys, siding with some pretty dubious characters (see, inter alia., our interventions in Central America and Afghanistan in the 80s and Kosovo in the 90s). Clearly the civilians being attacked are innocent, but if we intervene are we going to be forced to broker some sort of arrangement between the government and the various rebel groups, who no doubt come in various degrees of unsavoriness? Are we going to be picking winners and losers in the new Sudanese order? And what happens when the winners we pick start in with their human rights abuses? Not to mention the U.S.A. in particular should be wary of opening yet another front in the Muslim world; apparently Osama bin Laden is already calling on mujahedin to get ready to smite the “crusader plunderers” in Sudan.
I’m not saying that the U.S. should do nothing. For one thing, there do appear to be options short of military action. But if intervention is on the table, I would at least like to know straight up what exactly is being called for. A “peacekeeping” mission only makes sense if there’s peace to be kept. Otherwise let’s be honest and call it war. Are we willing to fight, if necessary, the government militias, and perhaps the Sudanese government itself? Are we talking regime change? Followed by occupation? How many troops do you suppose it would take to “pacify” all of Sudan, geographically the largest country in Africa (and more than twice the size of Iraq)?
Just asking.
Swedish Lutheran theologian Anders Nygren is best known for his book Agape and Eros, which argued for agape as the essence of divine love in Christianity. But his little book The Essence of Christianity: Two Essays is worth reading too. For my purposes I want to focus on the second essay, “The Atonement as a Work of God.”
Nygren begins by distinguishing between pre- or non-Christian and Christian ideas of atonement. The fundamental religious problem, he says, is fellowship with God. We recognize that we aren’t worthy to stand in the presence of God, that there is a barrier to fellowship caused by our unworthiness. This gives rise to various attempts at making atonement. At the most “primitive” level we have the literal offering of sacrifices. Then we move to an ethical or moral approach where people attempt to have fellowship with God on the basis of their good works. Finally, sensing the failure of these other methods, there is an attempt to base fellowship on an offering of humility and contrition.
What all of these attempts have in common, he says, is that atonement and fellowship with God are understood to have their basis in something we do:
All these different kinds of sacrifice have something about them which disqualifies them as means of reconciliation. Every attempt on man’s part to put himself right with God and make himself acceptable to God, conceals ultimately a piece of human presumption. There is an inner contradiction in all human attempts to make atonement and effect reconciliation. For by the very fact that he seeks reconciliation, man acknowledges God’s right to make demands on him, acknowledges Him to be God. Yet at the same time he denies the divinity of God, when he imagines that by means of something of his own–his gifts, his righteousness, or his humility–he can put himself right with God. (p. 90)
By contrast, the Christian idea of atonement is that reconciliation is rooted in God’s love and is, from beginning to end, God’s work. Agape, in Nygren’s account, consists of four elements: it is spontaneous, it is not motivated by any value intrinsic to its object, it is creative, and it establishes fellowship with God. From this Nygren can say that, far from having its basis in our holiness, our fellowship with God has its basis in sin! To our natural way of thinking it seems fitting that we should become holy or pure before entering into fellowship with God. But the Christian scandal is that God wills to have fellowship with us as sinners.
Nygren draws a distinction (perhaps too starkly) between Catholic and Evangelical (i.e. Protestant) understandings of how fellowship with God is acheived. In his telling, Catholicism founds our fellowship with God on the righteousness in us. We aren’t fit for communion with God until we are actually made holy. This isn’t Pelagianism since our holiness is wrought by grace, but it differs from the Evangelical approach because it makes our holiness the basis of fellowship. The Evangelical perspective, on the other hand, is that God “stoops down to sinful man and seeks fellowship with him” (p. 108). We don’t rise up to God, even if by grace, God comes down to us. Fellowship is established by God and is fellowship with sinners, preceding any holiness of our own.
The signature feature of agape is that it loves without respect to any qualities of the beloved. The good news is that, while we were yet sinners, Christ died for us. In fact, Nygren says, agape and atonement are essentially the same thing. Atonement just is God’s love coming among us to establish fellowship with us sinners. “God’s love is in its essential nature Agape-love; it is downward-moving love, a love which seeks the lost and wills to have fellowship with sinners, a love which is spontaneous and creative of fellowship” (p. 113).
But this raises the question, Why then talk of Atonement at all? If God’s love is unconditional love that forgives by its very nature, why the sacrifice of Jesus? Why the Cross? Why, as is often asked, can’t God simply up and forgive our sins without requiring the death of his Son?
Nygren responds that this question misunderstands both the nature of God’s love and the nature of sin. First, God’s love is not an indulgent, sentimental love; it is by its very nature opposed to sin. But to see why, we have to get clear on what sin is. Sin isn’t simply a series of discrete misdeeds which God could just overlook. Sin, as Luther and others saw, is a fundamental disposition or orientation of the self. The self that is “curved in on itself.” A self in such a condition simply can’t love God; it doesn’t want to, except perhaps when it sees God as a means to some end (such as happiness, wealth, self-improvement, etc.). This is what Luther meant by the “bondage of the will” – not that we can’t will, but that what we will is, inescapably, to be our own. If God is love and sin is selfishness, there can be nothing but contradiction between them.
Into this world that is closed against Him, indifferent to Him, God wills to bring His love. Here above all it becomes clear that it is precisely God’s love that makes it impossible for forgiveness to be the superficial, easy-going and self-evident thing commonly called by that name, and that forgiveness can only exist in inseparable connection with a real atonement. The sin that has to be forgiven is not simply a matter of a few moral misdemeanours standing in the way of God’s loving purposes; therefore forgiveness cannot simply mean that God magnanimously overlooks these faults and pursues His purpose of love without regard to them. The sin consists precisely in the fact that man selfishly shuts himself up against God’s love, showing no interest in it, and in so far as he seeks God at all, he seeks Him for selfish ends, so that–as Luther puts it–‘even in God he seeks only his own.’ (pp. 121-2)
If it were possible for us to simply give up our selfishness and love God, we would have atonement and fellowship based on our acheivement. But selfishness isn’t prepared to do that – how could it? Selfishness can’t sacrifice itself! So love sacrifices itself instead:
God, the divine love, takes the sacrifice upon Himself instead. ‘God was in Christ reconciling the world to Himself.’ Here in the most literal sense it is possible to speak of vicarious sacrifice and vicarious suffering. When selfish human life refuses to conform to the divine love, God’s love does not refuse to submit to the conditions of selfish human life. The question may be raised whether such a procedure is worthy of the divine love, and from an ordinary human point of view the answer must be that it is not. But such is divine love, such is God’s Agape, that it does not allow even human selfishness to set a limit to its giving and self-giving. It comes down into the world of sin and does not hesitate to give itself away to selfishness. It becomes a sacrifice in a new and deeper sense than that in which the lover always sacrifices himself for his beloved. It suffers itself to become lost love, a love spurned and trampled underfoot by selfishness. That is the way of divine atonement. (pp. 124-5)
God’s sacrifice is that he expends his love on this selfish world, even though it may end up as “lost love.” “But God’s love does not come to an end, God does not cease loving, because his love is spurned and trampled on by human selfishness, so that it becomes quite literally outcast and lost” (p. 126). Jesus’ entire life is this sacrifice, this spilling of God’s love upon often ungrateful sinners, and it culminates at the cross:
But where does divine love meet us as lost love more truly than in the Cross of Christ? Yet the love which does not cease to be love even when it is lost, is for that very reason the victory over all that stands against it. Here, and only here, is there any room for talk of the omnipotence of love. The way between God and a world fast bound in selfishness has been opened. Therefore the Christian faith sees in the atoning work of Christ the unshakable foundation of our fellowship with God. (p. 126, emphasis added)
I think the strength of Nygren’s position is that it roots the atonement squarely in God’s love. Some crude versions of atonement theory have seemed to imply that God was changed from wrathful to loving by what happened on the cross. Nygren makes it clear that it is entriely a work of God’s love. He repeatedly quotes Paul that “God was in Christ reconciling the world to himself.” It’s God who initiates reconciliation.
Questions for Nygren’s account: Does it overlook the penal element in atonemnt? (Is there a penal element in atonement?) Also, he doesn’t talk about the Resurrection; can an account of atonement stand independently from the Resurrection? Does the Resurrection simply ratify or validate what happened on the cross? And what about the cosmic aspect of reconciliation? Nygren seems to focus almost exclusively on human fellowship with God, but doesn’t the work of Christ have implications for all of creation?
Some good reading out there this week. I particularly liked “Dembski and the Cause of Evil” at Siris, “The Case for Abolishing Nuclear Weapons” at Mode for Caleb, and the discussion of The Gospel of Judas at Even the Devils Believe.
We just started watching the short-lived late 90s series Freaks and Geeks on DVD. Very funny and sweet. Especially if you were – ahem – not the most popular kid in high school. In the episode we watched last night, Lindsay, a smart girl who’s testing the waters of rebellion by hanging out with the “Freak” crowd (roughly, stoners), decides to throw a keg party while her parents are out of town to impress her new friends. But her “geeky” younger brother Sam and his friends switch the keg out for one filled with non-alcoholic beer in an attempt to forestall trouble. Problem is, the guests manage to convince themselves that they’re getting drunk anyway.
Unlike most TV shows about high school, the actors actually look like they are in high school, they talk like high schoolers, and they go through the same kinds of painfully awkward experiences that many people go through in high school. And the characters are sweet, funny, and likable. Naturally it was cancelled.

On the musical front I’ve been enjoying the 1998 album Something Wicked This Way Comes by the power/thrash metal band Iced Earth. These guys combine some of the epic and melodic sound (and fantasy-tinged themes) of bands like Iron Maiden with elements of thrash. Good stuff.

There’s been a fair bit of discussion recently about presumed presidential aspirant (and current Massachusetts governor) Mitt Romney’s Mormonism and how that might play with voters.
Romney faces two distinct, but not unrelated problems. Evangelical Protestants who make up an influential portion of the GOP base tend to see Mormons, despite their their social conservatism, as a dangerous cult. Meanwhile, moderate Republicans, independents, and swing voters, whom any candidate would need to woo to win the general election, tend to see Mormonism as, er, well, a dangerous (or at least bizarre) cult (and are less warm to Mormons’ social conservatism).
Some of the writers linked above think that voter uneasiness with electing a Mormon amounts to a de facto religious test, but that’s surely nonsense. Voters are free to vote or not vote for a candidate for any reason they like. However, are there good reasons not to vote for someone simply because he or she is a Mormon? I’ve known a few Mormons and nothing about them makes me fear the idea of a Mormon in office any more than, say, your average Southern Baptist or Unitarian. I mean, yeah, Mormons hold some unorthodox beliefs, many of which I find pretty wacky. But then, I find some Methodist beliefs pretty wacky too* and I voted for George Bush. (Of course, we see how that turned out…) If anything, someone who comes from a minority religion may well turn out to be more sensitive to church and state issues, and more aware of the fact that most of his fellow citizens don’t share his views.
I suppose one argument might be this: Anyone who believes things that are so transparently weird (and therefore presumably false) has, at best, a tenuous grasp on reality and therefore shouldn’t be elected to public office. But “weird” is decidedly in the eye of the beholder, isn’t it? It’s pretty weird to believe that a crucified itinerant rabbi is in fact the Second Person of a Three-personed God who is nevertheless not three gods but one. On the other hand, there are some religions whose intrinsic weirdness and manifest falsity would probably prevent me from voting for them. One of the commenters at The American Scene mentions how he would never vote for a Scientologist, which I would tend to agree with.
What say you, readers? Are there good reasons not to vote for someone sheerly on account of his or her religion?
——————————————-
*Just ribbin’ ya, Methodist readers!
The Lutheran Zephyr has asked for reflections on What It Means to Be Lutheran. I’m going to split this into two parts: why did I become Lutheran and why do I stay Lutheran.
Embarassing as it sounds, I literally picked the local Lutheran church out of the phone book. My then-fiancée and I were obliged by the church we were getting married in to undergo some kind of pre-marital counseling. Neither of us were churchgoers at the time, and the church where we were supposed to be married was in another city (as well as somewhat theologically uncongenial), so we needed to go local. We ended up receiving counseling from a local Lutheran pastor, a wonderful guy, and started attending worship at his church. Five and a half years and three moves (two of them out of state) later, and we’re still Lutheran.
As to why I stay Lutheran, I’d say it’s because I’ve come to appreciate the way Lutheranism balances the evangelical and catholic elements of the Christian heritage. We have the liturgy, believe in the Real Presence, and hold to the creeds and confessions of the early church, but understand all this through the prism of God’s free saving grace in Jesus. The center of Lutheran faith is undeniably Christological and evangelical. Unlike some, the Lutheran exultation in paradox and dialectic often baffles me. I’m a rationalist at heart and have a hard time making sense of signature Lutheran themes like Law/Gospel, sinner/saint, kingdom of the left/kingdom of the right, etc. But I think documents like Luther’s On Christian Liberty and his Catechisms contain an attractive and compelling vision of evangelical Christianity.
I also like the way that the ELCA, for all its flaws, remains a more or less centrist institution (despite what you may have heard) whose unity is grounded in the Gospel more than in a particular social or political agenda. This doesn’t please the ultra-conservatives or the ultra-liberals, but so far the center has managed to hold. In a time when most people, including many Christians, seem to see religion primarily as a project for moral improvement or social reform (at best), the stubborn Lutheran insistence on putting the good news of Jesus Christ at the center is worth holding onto.
P.S. Feel free to offer comments on what drew you to your tradition, or what you find especially compelling about it.
Lutheran church holds “Worship with the Beatles.”
Gag. At least U2 sings about Jesus sometimes.
(link via Here We Stand)