Nice article at Reason on the flourishing American beer market. Despite the sneering connotations often given to the phrase “American beer,” the article notes that “More styles of suds are now brewed in America than in any other place. Along with the light-tasting lagers that still dominate the market, the new offerings include porters, stouts, barley wines, bocks, hefeweizens, pale ales, bitters, and Belgian-style farmhouse ales. American beers consistently win the highest proportion of awards in international competitions. Local and regional beer has re-emerged: There are more than 1,400 breweries in the United States, up from only a few dozen at the start of the 1980s.”
I will also come clean and say that I actually enjoy some mass-market American lagers. Just the other evening, in fact, I was partaking of the Champagne of Beers, Miller High Life, or what I like to call the thinking man’s PBR. Which is not to say that I don’t also enjoy stouts, ales, IPAs and all that good stuff, but sometimes a bottle of the High Life or a cold Bud slakes the thirst in a way that an overly complex microbrew just can’t.
Author: Lee M.
-
Go, capitalism!
-
Evolution, the Fall, and Original Sin
I enjoyed Keith Ward’s Pascal’s Fire so much (despite disagreement in places) that when I saw his Religion and Human Nature at a used bookseller for five bucks I snatched it up. RHN is part of Ward’s four-part “comparative theology” which also includes volumes on revelation, creation, and community. His methodology is to compare the treatment of these topics in various world religions as well as modern secular naturalism, and then to provide a Christian response, both where it can affirm and must deny aspects of the other views.
RHN contains really interesting and illuminating discussions of competing schools of thought in Hinduism and Buddhism in the earlier chapters, but for the purposes of this post I’m interested in Ward’s re-interpretation of the doctrine of Original Sin in light of modern evolutionary thought.
The basic picture offered us by evolutionary theory conflicts with the traditional Christian view of the fall and original sin at a number of points. Traditional Christian teaching has been that human beings lived in a state of blessedness and innocence until Adam’s sin, and that death and suffering entered the world as a result of sin. Adam and Eve transmitted to their descendents both a propensity or inclination toward sin and the guilt of the first sin (whence one argument for infant baptism).
Evolutionary theory, on the other hand, tells us that suffering and death long predated the existence of human beings, that our tendencies toward lust and aggression are part of our genetic baggage and probably helped our ancestors to survive long enough to propagate the species, and that there was likely no period when humans lived in harmony with each other and their world as depicted in the Garden of Eden story.
One popular way to reconcile these two accounts has been to see the story of Creation and Fall as a “myth,” not in the sense of a fairy tale or falsehood, but in the sense of a story that gives us a profound truth about the human condition. The way life is depicted prior to the Fall in the early chapters of Genesis represents creation not as it was some time in the distant past, but creation as it should be and will be when God’s purposes for it are finally realized. “Fallen” humanity is humanity as it is in this world.
While there is value in such an account, Ward says, it tends to sidestep the question of why a good God would create such inherently flawed creatures, and it even risks locating the source of evil in finite existence as such, rather than in a distortion of what is essentially a good creation. Instead he tries to develop a position that mediates between more literalistic and purely “mythic” ones.
Ward accepts that “Destruction and death are built into the universe as necessary conditions of its progress to new forms of life” (p. 160), but he suggests that it nevertheless is the case that moral evil entered the world at some point. Proto-humans (or whatever we want to call them) may have tendencies toward lust, aggression and greed as part of their constitutive make-up, but at some point it became possible for them to choose to indulge those tendencies at the expense of another:
Thus when humans first came into being, they were already locked into a world in which competition and death were fundamental to their very existence. In this long process of the emergence of consciousness, there was a first moment at which a sentient animal became aware of moral obligation. At some point, animal life emerged from a stage of what Hegel called “dreaming innocence,” at which moral considerations were irrelevant, since animals simply acted in ways natural to their species. At that point, a sentient consciousness discerned, or thought it discerned, an obligation to act in one way rather than another, an obligation which it was free to respond to or ignore. It seems to me plausible to say that it was at that point that truly personal consciousness first began to exist.
Two elements seem to be axiomatic about moral obligation. One is that, if a moral obligation truly exists, then it must be possible to meet it; otherwise it is not an obligation. The other is that it must also be possible to ignore it; otherwise it is not a matter of morality. It therefore seems to me beyond dispute that there must have been a first sin in the history of the planet. There must have been a moment when a conscious being decided to ignore an obligation, when it need not have done so. It is not an antique fable, it is an indisputable fact, that sin entered into the world through the free action of a conscious being which chose to do what it should not and need not have done. (p. 161)
Furthermore, this choosing of evil ruptures what may have been a “tacit” or “thematic” knowledge and awareness of God. “The Fall consisted in the loss of the sense of a felt unity with the sacred root of being, in the inability to co-operate with its gracious guidance, and so in the growth of that sense of solitude and estrangement which becomes the lot of humanity in a state of sin” (p. 162). Once this unity is ruptured, “spiritual death” is the natural outcome.
The ultimate human choice, from a theistic viewpoint, is not so much a choice between good and evil, abstractly conceived, as a choice between relationship with God, as the source of love and power, and a form of self-determination which inevitably leads on to self-regard. (pp. 163-4)
The effects of this choosing of evil reinforce human being’s already existing drives toward dominating and exploiting others, making it difficult, if not impossible, to not choose sin. And this condition is spread, Ward thinks, because future generations are born among those who’ve already turned away from God, making it even harder for them to choose the good, much less restore the lost unity with the divine. He therefore adopts a view that Original Sin is propagated by social and environmental conditions rather than being passed in some quasi-physical fashion.
The import of the Genesis story is that our world is one in which at a very early stage all humans rejected God. It is that original and massive embracing of desire that has drastically altered the moral situation of all subsequent human descendents. (p. 167)
For anyone born into such a world, the choice of good and evil is no delicately balanced, dispassionately contemplated decision. In a world of greed, hatred, and delusion, one must either be an oppressor, a victim, or a resister. One will be born as a child within one of these groups, and one’s historical responses and learned activities will be shaped accordingly. (pp. 168-9)
Even if someone managed to always make the correct moral decision, she would still not experience the unity in relationship with God that is the real purpose of human life. Instead of experiencing morality as the natural expression of a life lived in friendship with God, we usually experience it as a burdensome obligation and an obstacle to fulfilling our desires, at lest where it “pinches.” In our fallen condition our inclinations and our obligations are frequently at variance. To be delivered from our condition requires overcoming our estrangement from God, and the consequent transformation of our desires and inclinations. But this isn’t something we’re capable of pulling off.
To be continued (but not until next week probably, since I’m going camping this weekend!)…
-
A day that will live in infamy
It’s not everyday that we get a bill that constitutes a massive executive power grab and effectively authorizes torture (or “torture-lite” if you insist). What a great day to be an American!
Republicans like Denny Hastert and their media echo chamber keep accusing people who oppose this sort of thing as wanting to “give rights to terrorists.” Two things: first, we’re talking about people accused or suspected of being terrorists (or supporting terrorists). Big difference, one would think. Second, yes, even terrorists have certain rights that can’t simply be cast aside. They are human beings, after all.
Balkinization continues to be the best one-stop-shopping spot for analysis of all this that I’ve found.
-
"The Muslim Gandhi"
A friend of mine sent me this article from the New Yorker on the life and death of Mahmoud Muhammad Taha, a radical Islamic cleric in Sudan who was executed for opposition to the government. The twist is that Taha was a radical progressive, an exponent of a liberal reinterpretation of Islam.
Taha’s direct influence seems small, but the article suggests that the Sudanese are wearying of Islamism and that a vision like Taha’s may have a futre in the Islamic world. It’s a long, but fascinating, read.
-
Links a poppin’
Marvin has a three part series on the Emergent Church, offers some critical questions, and wonders how a congregation like his, which is not located in a hip, urban enclave might make use of some “emergent” ideas.
Brandon writes that Richard Dawkins’ reading of scripture makes fundamentalism look sophisticated and he also questions whether it’s correct to say that Islamists are motivated by an unwavering faith, as “anti-religionists” like Dawkins and Sam Harris assume in making their case.
There’s a lively discussion of Andrew Bacevich’s New American Militarism at Connexions (which your scribe participated in briefly).
At Sinning Boldly, Andy considers Christian views of immanence and transcendence.
Thomas at Without Authority continues his series on Kierkegaard’s Works of Love.
You may have seen this article at Christianity Today on the resurgence of a conservative brand of Calvinism within evangelical – Baptist in particular it seems – churches. Jenell Paris and Hugo Schwyzer look at it from the angle of gender roles.
-
Unintended consequences
“Recent history shows us that there is no civil war so bad that it cannot be made worse – prolonged, intensified, made more bloody and intractable – by the intervention of Western liberals.”
Daring to contradict such geopolitical experts as George Clooney, Brendan O’Neill offers a contrarian take on the campaign to “Save Darfur.”
(Link via Antiwar.com)
-
Further adventures in Anglo-Catholicism
This Sunday Abby and I went to our first “Solemn Mass” at the Church of the Advent. Until yesterday we’d been going to the earlier Sung Mass, which follows the Rite II Eucharist from the Book of Common Prayer pretty closely with just a couple of flourishes, such as the “Prayer of Humble Access.” In form and content, though, it’s not terribly different from the Lutheran liturgies we’re used to.
The Solemn Mass, though, is another animal. First off, it’s in Rite I language. There are also various “introits,” “graduals,” and “sentences” here and there whose provenance is somewhat unclear to me. But the most notable difference is that the Kyrie, the Gloria, the Sursum corda, and the Sanctus and Benedictus are all sung only by the choir and in Latin. The choir, which returned for the first time yesterday after being off for the summer, has a (well-deserved as far as I can tell) reputation for excellence and it was on full display. Another distinctively Anglo-Catholic touch was the responsive recitation of the Angelus at the very end of the service. With all these bells and whistles the whole affair stretched to about an hour and a half (and that’s with the sermon being less than fifteen minutes).
While there’s no denying the beauty of this form of worship, I couldn’t help but think that I was missing out on something by not directly participating as much. I’m no great singer (though I can carry a tune all right), but I find that singing the hymns and the liturgy enables me to worship in about as un-self-conscious a way as I’m able. When I’m passively observing, by contrast, I find it’s much more likely that my mind will wander. Part of what attracted me to liturgical worship in the first place is that we’re given the words with which to respond to God. One learns the language of prayer by speaking (or singing) it in the course of the service.
Don’t get me wrong, in many ways it was a wonderful service, and on a holy day in particular it’s hard to see how you could beat it, but I have a hard time imagining it as my “weekly bread.” Of course, I can’t discount the possibility that greater familiarity would change my experience. Or maybe I’m just too Protestant. 😉
-
Compromised
The gist of what I’ve been reading is the “compromise” between the White House and the “dissident” (ha!) Republican senators in regards to the treatment of terrorist suspects in light of the Geneva Convention standards on torture consists in essentially giving the President everything he wanted.
Ari Berman at The Nation says that “Democrats chose to outsource their policy on military tribunals to John McCain. And McCain did what he’s done best the last year: capitulate to Bush.”
Also at The Nation, “Torture Is a Moral Issue.”
Lots of analysis from the blog Balkinization. This post in particular is worth highlighting. Marty Lederman writes that “The result, unfortunately, is a very constrained conception of what constitutes ‘cruel treatment’ — a much narrower conception than a fair or reasonable interpretation of Geneva Article 3(1)(a) would provide. And therefore the bill would appear to exclude from the definition of ‘cruel treatment’ many cases of actual cruel treatment prohibited by Common Article 3. And when that occurs, it is likely the Executive will construe the statute — and Common Article 3, as well — to permit some forms of cruel treatment that Geneva in fact proscribes, i.e., the ‘alternative’ CIA techniques. Indeed, it’s happened already: The ink was hardly dry on the draft when numerous Administration spokespersons were gleefully informing the press that the bill is a green light to the CIA to reinstitute the ‘alternative’ techniques that Hamdan had effectively interdicted. Byron York has gone so far as to relate that ‘both sides appear to believe that the agreement permits the CIA to continue to use sleep deprivation, cold rooms, and other such techniques,’ even though such techniques do, in fact, constitue a breach of our Geneva obligations.”
At the American Prospect blog Deborah Pearlstein writes that “[t]he real problem, once again, is that the administration would like to continue to rely on the historically fallible ‘trust us’ method of ensuring the executive branch remains true to its word. A law — any law — that is not effectively enforceable in an independent court is not much of law at all. Yet by purporting to strip the federal courts of authority to enforce any provision of the Geneva Conventions, the compromise legislation not only treads dangerously on the powers promised by the Constitution to the judiciary, it calls into serious question the United States’ commitment to taking its own obligations seriously.”
Also at Tapped, Charles Pierce lays into the Democrats for essentially sitting on the sidelines during the entire debate.
Libertarian blogger Jim Henley says that “[t]he Senate has made it official: torture is official government policy so long as it meets the strict test of being called something else, said test to be proctored, taken and graded by the President in consultation with . . . the President.”
And finally, at Antiwar.com, Alan Bock writes on “torture chic” as a sign of imperial decadence. -
Another example of my lameness
I seem to have completely missed the whole “indie rock” or “indie music” boat. I don’t even know if the terms are supposed to refer to an actual genre of music or just to any band not signed to a major label. What are examples of “indie” groups? What do they sound like?
-
Blogging lameness
I’m starting to realize that my heart isn’t really in the quickie link-plus-two-sentences-of-pithy-commentary posts these days. And I really can’t bring myself to work up an opinion on the “hot” topic of the moment (whatever that happens to be at any given time) simply for the sake of having one, hence the relative lack of posts lately.
I feel like it’s really easy for a blog to become purely reactive, either to something you read in the news, or something some blockhead said on some other site, or whatever, and that gets really old fast, at least to me. There’s a danger of getting mired in ephemera. That, and you end up saying the same thing over and over again.
I’m thinking about ways of refocusing this place, maybe toward lengthier but less frequent posts. (My schedule doesn’t really permit frequent lenghty posts.) Do readers have any preference here? What kind of posts do you like best? I started this primarily as a way to organize my own thoughts, but I’ve really come to value the interaction with commenters and other bloggers.