I’m back from spending a very enjoyable Christmas with my in-laws in Indianapolis, where, if there’s a war on Christmas, it’s being waged on behalf of Colts fever; the amount of Colts gear and paraphernalia on display threatened to overwhelm anything Christmas-themed.
Blogging to resume at its usual erratic pace shortly.
The ATR household is off to visit family for the better part of the next week, so blogging will be light–well, even lighter than usual.
Here’s a sampling of what I’ve been reading ’round the Web lately:
Christopher has several posts on l’affaire Rick Warren that are, as usual, very much worth your time. (See here, here, and here.)
Congrats to John Schwenkler, whose blog Upturned Earth has been absorbed into the ever-expanding conservative media empire that is Culture 11.
Lynn reflects on the movie Milk and how different the atmosphere for gay rights in California has changed since the 70’s (n.b.: a couple of f-bombs).
I thought this article on St. Joseph at Slate was neat.
Jennifer reminds us that it’s T-minus one month till the Lost season premiere! (And don’t forget Battlestar Galactica on January 18th!)
Alan Jacobs and Noah Millman discuss intereligious dialogue at the American Scene. This is something I haven’t given as much thought to as I’d like. (See here, here, and here.)
Not surprisingly, beef has the highest CO2 emissions per pound, but surprisingly high also are cheese and shrimp. I wonder if transportation was included in the figuring.
This talk from the E.F. Schumahcer Institute was delivered in May, but it still seems entirely relevant to our current predicament.
Finally, I’d be remiss if I didn’t bring you Christmas wishes from Ronnie James Dio (along with the rest of the Dio-era Black Sabbath line-up).
A Catholic (Edwards) and a Lutheran (Santmire) offer nicely complementary re-tellings of the Christian story that emphasize the cosmic and ecological context of God’s presence with us.
Religion and Human Fulfillment by Keith Ward
Ward looks at controversial moral issues through the lens of various religious traditions (Christianity and sexuality, Islam and just war, Buddhism and beginning- and end-of-life issues, Judaism and religious vs. secular law); he defends a version of “transcendent personalism,” which holds that reason can discern right and wrong, but that belief in a transcendent source of being and goodness provides an extra impetus for the moral life.
God, Religion, and Reality by Stephen R.L. Clark
A clever and idiosyncratic defense of traditional/classic theism, taking the view–unfashionable in both philosophical and theological circles–that reason can demonstrate the existence and attributes of God.
The noted process philosopher/theologian argues for the essential compatibility of Rawlsian liberalism with robust religious commitment. He also addresses weaknesses in Rawls’ view regarding such issues as war and peace, abortion, and animal rights. Loving Jesus by Mark Allan Powell
Powell, a Lutheran seminary professor and self-proclaimed “Jesus freak,” offers a “post-critical” piety that engages heart and head in “loving Jesus in a complicated world.” Very helpful reflections on prayer, personal devotions, stewardship, and spiritual growth that are neither overly abstract nor simplistic.
I had a vague recollection of this from my childhood, but Andrew Sullivan posted a link to this clip the other day and I was reminded how truly, truly awful 1978’s Star Wars Holiday Special (amazingly, featuring the majority of the film’s cast, not to mention the likes of Bea Arthur, Art Carney, and Harvey Korman) was:
It is Life Day (a holiday analogous to Christmas on Earth). Chewbacca is on his way home to see his family and to celebrate the holiday, accompanied by his friend, Han Solo. Not long after departing Tatooine in the Millennium Falcon, the duo find themselves chased by two Star Destroyers, which Han derisively refers to as an “Imperial garbage scow.” After a short argument whether they should abort the mission a decision is made to move forward. Han then sends the Falcon into hyperspace.
Meanwhile, on Kashyyyk, Chewie’s family is anxiously awaiting and preparing for Chewbacca’s return. For the most part, they are going on with their everyday lives. However, Chewie’s family is a bit nervous, because Chewbacca has not arrived yet. Malla takes down a framed picture of Chewbacca; her father-in-law Itchy, notices her worries and reassures Malla that Chewie is safe, and she replaces the picture. Itchy then gets out a movie (in the form of a futuristic capsule), and gives it to his grandson, Lumpy, to play on their movie device. After the movie is over, the family begins to do various chores….
Since content will likely be light this coming week, I thought it would be an interesting exercise to offer up some representative posts from the previous four Decembers since I started blogging, as a kind of retrospective.
(Note: some of these originally appeared on my first blog, “Verbum Ipsum,” but have been imported to WP; consequently, there may be some broken links here and there.)
Rowlands lived with a wolf he adopted for many years and learned lessons from him about what it meant to be happy and to be human. He also makes the provocative claim, with which Gray concurs, that, with humanity, a new possibility for evil enters the world, and that when humans are compared to wolves it’s the wolves who are getting the short end of the stick:
In evolutionary terms humans belong in the ape family, and if apes are intellectually superior to other animals it is because of their highly developed social intelligence. Some of the most valuable features of human life – science and the arts, for example – are only possible because of this intelligence. But it is also this type of intelligence that enables apes – some kinds of ape, at any rate – to engage in forms of behaviour that, when more fully developed, embody types of malignancy that are pre-eminently human. As Rowlands puts it: ‘When we talk about the superior intelligence of apes, we should bear in mind the terms of this comparison: apes are more intelligent than wolves because, ultimately, they are better schemers and deceivers than wolves.’ The ability to scheme and deceive requires a capacity to enter the minds of others, which other animals seem not to possess in anything like the same degree. But the human capacity for empathy brings something new into the world – a kind of malice aforethought, a delight in the pain of others that aims to reduce them to the condition of powerless victims.
Gray, that inveterate critic of optimistic rationalist humanism, likes to point out that, once you leave behind the metaphysics of Christianity, you really have very little solid ground to stand on in asserting the innate superiority of human beings to other animals. C.S. Lewis made a similar point in his writings on vivisection: if might makes right in justifying cutting up animals for our own benefit, why wouldn’t it also justify cutting up “defective” humans or class enemies or other races? In Lewis’s view, it was the Christian worldview that undergirds both justice for humans and mercy toward other animals.
(Incidentally, Rowlands’ Animals Like Us is one of the best introductions to animal rights issues I’ve read. It’s rigorous, but clear and straightforward.)
Quick: name the people who gave the invocations at the last five presidential inaugurations. Four…? Three…? Anyone…? Bueller…? Bueller…?
This is something that everyone will forget about on January 21st.
Just because a lot of pundits and bloggers are talking about it doesn’t make it hugely important.
That said, I don’t think it’ll come as any great surprise to readers of this blog that I’m not a huge fan of Rick Warren, and especially not of his stance on gay people or his apparent views on political assassination. And I can certainly understand why LGBT folks in particular would see this as a slap in the face.
Beyond that, I’m not at all a fan of the whole idea of draping the presidency with the appearance of religious sanction. I’m a church-state separation guy primarily for religious reasons. Religion tends to become corrupted when it identifies too closely with political power. Ceremonies like this, however innocuous or benign they might appear, do little more than breed coziness between the religious and political establishments as far as I can tell.
The one silver lining I can detect is that, if you’re going to have religious leaders involved in the ceremony, there is something to be said for including people who strongly disagree with the president. This not only reinforces the idea that the office holder is the president of all Americans, but emphasizes that the clergy aren’t the kept priests of the state. After all, there are societies where dissenting clergy are not only not invited to speak at presidential inaugurations, but are silenced and executed. (Which is not to say that there’s never been suppression of political dissent here.)
But even here there are limits, obviously. As we saw with the Jeremiah Wright brouhaha, someone who genuinely opposes American exceptionalism very quickly becomes political persona non grata. And I doubt Daniel Berrigan was on the short list either.
Is it time to start the inevitable “best of” lists already?
Well, I know that you all have been waiting with baited breath for my top heavy metal albums of 2008. I make no claim that these are “the best” in any objective sense, just that they’re the ones I listened to and enjoyed the most (in no particular order and along with clips):
Theo Hobson argues that John Milton was a great (and underrated) theorist of a distinctly Christian liberalism. He was a strong proponent of a secular state, but also of a Protestant ethos throughout society:
So was he an early “secular liberal”? Not in the dominant contemporary sense, which assumes that politics should be post-religious. He thought it should be post-ecclesial, but that liberal Protestant Christianity was the necessary foundation of a free society. This must be the national ideology, but it must not be identified with any religious institution. In effect, he was inventing the American approach to church-state relations.
Hobson apparently has a book just out on the subject that looks like it would be worth checking out.
This piece is both incredible and infuriating. Incredible because it describes in detail how intelligent the orangutans are in devising increasingly sophisticated ways to escape from their jailers (oops-“keepers”) at the San Diego Zoo. Infuriating, well, because such obviously intelligent and social creatures are being held captive against their demonstrated preferences. Really, what is the justification for this?
It’s interesting that one of the arguments against the case for animal rights is that animals lack the ability to assert or claim their own rights (to life, freedom, etc.). I don’t accept this argument as a matter of principle because I think there are many cases where sentient beings are owed moral considerability even if they can’t make those claims on their own behalf (infants, the disabled, other “marginal” cases). But, supposing you do accept that principle: here’s an example clear as day of animals claiming their rights to freedom and self-determination.