Patrick Cockburn reports on the situation there in the wake of the recently concluded “status of forces” agreement that’s supposed to have US troops out by 2011.
Author: Lee M.
-
Rediscovering Correggio
The Post had an article this weekend on the nearly forgotten Renaissance master Correggio (a.k.a. Antonio Allegri) who at one time ranked up there with the likes of Michelangelo and Leonardo.
What makes Correggio stand out is that his work is unconventional, even at times chaotic, by the standards of the day:
Correggio’s paintings are so idiosyncratic and so subtle that they don’t yield the sound bites history prefers, as with Titian (“Brushstroke Guy”) or Michelangelo (“Mr. Classic Nude”). Correggio’s art seems all about resisting simple views, of art or of the worlds it shows. We can’t get an easy handle on Correggio’s pictures, because they’re dedicated to flux, indirection and obliquity. He may have used that combination to stand out from the crowd in talent-packed Renaissance Italy. But, like most artistic choices, it must mostly have depended on this painter’s view of the world.
The ultimate example of Correggio’s unique vision is the huge fresco he unveiled in the dome of Parma cathedral, in 1530, after years and years of work. This is Correggio’s most innovative project, and his most influential. It seems to open up the dome to let us see a teeming host of angels in the sky beyond. (Many Catholic churches now have similar ceilings, probably without knowing that they owe them to Correggio.) And yet, despite the cupola’s stunning special effects, this is also the least legible of paintings. Correggio has taken a standard Christian story — of the Virgin Mary’s bodily assumption into heaven at the moment of her death — and painted it as something so complex, it’s hardly graspable. It may be the perfect picture for a dome: Its floating figures aren’t tied down to a single view, so worshipers below can take it in from any spot. And yet that also means that there’s no stable order to hang on to, no single take-home message you can pull out of its turmoil.
For Correggio, this is heaven: a place where nothing ever settles down and there’s no one way to look at things.
Be sure to check out the accompanying video of the Parma dome here. It’s really spectacular.
-
The greening of religion
At “The Immanent Frame,” Roger Gottlieb gives an overview of “religious environmentalism.” Not religious in the sense that conservatives sometimes say that environmentalism is a religion, but environmental concerns and movements emanating from traditional religions.
One provocative claim Gottlieb makes is that, as religions “green,” they move to the left more generally:
There is also a near universal tendency of religious environmentalism to move religions to the left. Inevitably, confrontation with the causes of the environmental crisis leads to a confrontation with global capitalism, militarism, and political repression. To capitalism environmental problems are externalities, and must remain so. To militarists every environmental problem takes a back seat to every military one. And repressive governments are too concerned with maintaining their own power to worry about ecosystem health.
This move to the left extends even to culturally and politically conservative communities. America’s Evangelical community has given rise to the vital Evangelical Environmental Network, and the religious right as a whole has been split over environmental issues, with activists taking well publicized moves to make clear that environmental concern is not solely the province of granola eating old hippies like the author of this essay. A split on this issue, however, portends at least the possibility of a split on others, and in any case necessarily leads to the questioning of unfettered corporate power.
I think one worry this might raise is that this “move to the left” would also mean abandoning the central claims of Christianity or watering them down with some bland, syncretistic “eco-spirituality.” As it happens, I’m currently reading a book called Nature Reborn: The Ecological and Cosmic Promise of Christian Theology, by Lutheran theologian H. Paul Santmire (Santmire’s more well-known earlier work–which I haven’t read–was called The Travail of Nature: The Ambiguous Ecological Promise of Christian Theology).
Santmire argues that theology can and should thread a middle way between extreme reconstructionists who want to junk the entire edifice of traditional theology and start anew (e.g. the “creation spirituality” of Matthew Fox) and apologists for the traditional anthropocentric status quo. He thinks that Christian theology already contains the resources, if often ignored, to provide the necessary response to the ecological crisis. The term he prefers for his own project is “revisionist,” aiming to be “orthodox but innovative” in mining the resources (er, bit of an ironic metaphor there, I guess) of the tradition. Santmire wants to press for a re-appropriation of the tradition that is less anthropocentric and more theocentric. Or, in other words, to formulate a more thoroughly cosmic vision of the Christian faith. I think this opens a door to a “greening” of faith without abandoning the commitments to classic creeds, doctrines, and beliefs. Christianity doesn’t need to abandon its core beliefs to address environmental issues, but it may need to dig deeper, to the roots of its own confession.
-
Huxley, the perennial philosophy, and the scandal of particularity
Aldous Huxley is best remembered for his chilling depiction of a totalitarian state in Brave New World. I’ve long thought that Huxley’s vision was in many ways more accurate than Orwell’s, at least as far as the West is concerned. We seem more likely to fall for a spiritually dead consumerist dystopia than a boot-on-the-neck Stalinist one (though one shouldn’t be overly optimistic!).
This article, however, makes the case that Huxley’s later writings that set out his positive spiritual, philosophical, and social vision deserve consideration. His mature philosophy appears to have been an attempt at synthesizing Eastern thought with an appreciation for modern science, and the author suggests that it can speak to many of our current social and spiritual problems.I remember reading Huxley’s Perennial Philosophy years ago and I still have a certain affinity for that outlook. (I’d identify E.F. Schumacher, especially in his Guide for the Perplexed, and Huston Smith as other proponents.)
Huxley defined the perennial philosophy as
the metaphysic that recognizes a divine Reality substantial to the world of things and lives and minds; the psychology that finds in the soul something similar to, or even identical with, divine Reality; the ethic that places man’s final end in the knowledge of the immanent and transcendent Ground of all being. (The Perennial Philosophy, p. vii)
This philosophy, in Huxley’s view, underlies the great religious traditions of the world, especially in their more mystical forms. Thus the differences between traditions are somewhat relativized.
Christianity, of course, contains a certain tension between the universal and the particular: the logos is the light that enlightens every person, but that logos became incarnate in a particular human being with a particular culture and history. Some versions of Christianity emphasize the universal to the detriment of the particular, seeing the historical Jesus mainly as a symbol of a universal truth. However, there’s also a danger–or so I’d argue–in the opposite view. Some schools of Christian theology posit a sharp discontinuity between Christian revelation and all other perceptions of the divine, whether they belong to other religious traditions or to “natural” reason.
I don’t think any version of Christianity that wants to lay claim to orthodoxy can sever the religious life from the particular history of Jesus; Christians believe that God was manifested in the life, death, and resurrection of Jesus in a way that makes a permanent difference for the life of the world. And yet, an important tradition in Christianity–represented, for instance, by several of the early church fathers–holds that non-Christian wisdom points to the same “divine Reality” that became incarnate in Jesus. Moreover, the Bible itself often portrays “outsiders”–people who not only existed before Jesus, but were outside the chosen people–as knowing God and offering him true worship.
This position is basically sound in my view, but there is a fine line between affirming that knowledge and true worship of God is possible outside of Christ and dismissing the importance of the Incarnation. After all, if God can be known apart from special revelation, why is it necessary for God to become man? Is the knowledge of God available to non-Christians saving knowledge, or does it have the status of a “preamble to faith” as natural knowledge of God is referred to in some Catholic theology? What exactly is it that God achieves for us in Jesus that wasn’t possible otherwise?
-
The oil crash: a very inconvenient truth
I just finished watching this extremely well-done documentary (if you subscribe to Netflix you can stream it from their site as I did). If anything, it was more terrifying than An Inconvenient Truth. I think that’s because the consequences–drastic economic dislocation, a series of resource wars, etc.–are more immediate and viscerally disturbing. (Obviously the two problems are closely related.)
The usual response to this–that the magic market-god will provide–seems to completely ignore the fact that no source of energy that could actually fill the role currently played by oil and other fossil fuels is even on the horizon of large-scale viability. Demand won’t simply produce a new source of energy out of thin air, and there’s every reason to think that our fossil fuel binge is a one time affair.
Not exactly an uplifting film, but recommended.