A conservative critique of the bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki from Bill Luse.
(via Paul Cella)
A conservative critique of the bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki from Bill Luse.
(via Paul Cella)
By day, I shop for organic produce in local health food stores and farmers’ markets. I talk with people about what’s in season, new vegan recipes, the next fermented food craze, and how to displaced cooked, junk foods – excuse the redundancy – in our families’ diets. I meet many people who are trying to reverse the hardship and disease that our modern food and medical industries have wrought. These are thoughtful people, open minded and willing to make huge changes in their lives. They are taking responsibility for their own health.
By night, I socialize with freedom lovers. I feel a true sense of relief that I can comment against taxes, inflation, government schools, in fact all manner of regulation and coercion. These people agree with me and show admiration for my choices in life. They are a fellowship of honest, moral and wise people. Libertarianism is a club in which I am proud to have membership.
More here.
The American Conservative has published it’s endorsements for the presidential election. Those fractious paleos just couldn’t agree on one candidate!
Unfortunately, this election does not offer traditional conservatives an easy or natural choice and has left our editors as split as our readership. In an effort to deepen our readers’ and our own understanding of the options before us, we’ve asked several of our editors and contributors to make “the conservative case” for their favored candidate. Their pieces, plus Taki’s column closing out this issue, constitute TAC’s endorsement.
Howard Phillips for Peroutka (Constitution Party)
Alan W. Bock for Badnarik (Libertarian)
Bill Keezer and Kevin the Big Hominid both have good posts on the intersection of religion and politics.
In response to Kevin’s question about whether it’s possible to separate one’s religion from one’s political beliefs and actions, I’m inclined to say it’s not. If my conscience is well-formed by my tradition, how can I somehow turn that off when I enter the voting booth? But does this require that I attempt to legislate my religious beliefs?
I think it doesn’t require it, for a couple of different reasons. First off, it might be imprudent for me to attempt to legislate my religious beliefs, since the wheel of fortune will eventually turn and I might find myself as part of a religious minority. I think it was C. S. Lewis who said he wouldn’t want to legislate Christian marriage for all of England any more than he would want Muslims to outlaw alcohol!
Secondly, I think we can find embedded in our traditions reasons for not being quick to impose sectarian religious doctrines on others. Christians are called to be humble, and one aspect of this humility is epistemic humility. That is, we shouldn’t assume that we already posess the whole truth, and this ought to lead us to engage in respectful dialogue with those who hold different views. This is not a position rooted in skepticism, or Enlightenment rationalism, but one rooted in the virtues a Christian should exhibit. I suspect there are tendencies in other traditions that would point in a similar direction.
Finally, I would distinguish between a sectarian religious belief and a moral belief which may be shared widely across traditions (I realize this distinction can get fuzzy in practice). If I think abortion or the death penalty are wrong, I can seek to persuade my fellow citizens that those things are wrong based on premises that they accept from their own traditions. I can’t accept the Kerry line (if it is the Kerry line) that opposition to abortion is a matter of faith that must remain essentially private. Kerry clearly doesn’t think that care for the environment or economic justice must remain matters of “private” belief, even though those positions can be, and often are, rooted in faith.
If American conservatism is individualist social-contract theory combined with anti-statism, then it has very little in common with Christianity, according to James W. Skillen:
George F. Will, drawing from what he considers “the best political book in years” (John Micklethwait and Adrian Wooldridge’s The Right Nation), writes in a recent column that “the emotions underlying conservatism’s long rise [in America] include a visceral individualism with religious roots and anti-statist consequences” (Washington Post, 10/10/04). According to Micklethwait and Wooldridge, religiosity is what “predisposes Americans to see the world in terms of individual virtue” and to be skeptical of government.
This is why American Christians ought to be conservatives, right? And doesn’t it also mean that in today’s culture Christians should vote for the evangelical and politically conservative George W. Bush rather than for the politically liberal John Kerry, who happens to be Catholic?
Regardless of how you choose to cast your vote on November 2, to presume that religiously political conservatism harmonizes with Christianity is a serious mistake….
More here.
(via Byzantine Calvinist)
This is a very powerful movie based on the experiences of Allied POWs in a Japanese prison camp during WWII. These men lived under horrific conditions and were forced to construct a railroad between Thailand and Burma.
The heart of the film, though, is in the prisoners’ struggle to maintain their dignity by studying philosophy, literature and music, and, ultimately, by forgiving their captors. The narrator is a young Scotsman who eventually went on to become dean of the chapel at Princeton University.
Highly recommended.
Via Michael Gilleland comes this sermon from Fr. Jim Tucker – “A Primer on Prayer.” I’ve found that many pastors seem averse to offering this kind of “nuts and bolts” advice on living the Christian life. But some of us are in great need of it!
Recently, I spoke to an audience of college kids. The subject was our president. For 20 minutes or so, I gave them my assessment of George W. Bush, that he is a spoiled rich kid who wasted his youth partying with his frat-boy buddies and then woke up one morning and decided to become president. I pointed out that his domestic policy has been disastrous and his foreign policy idiotic.
We came to the question-and- answer session. “So who are you voting for?” one of the students asked.
“Why, George Bush, of course.”
More here.
(link via The Corner)
Last week I attended a discussion at our church on “Christians and the Upcoming Election.” The featured speaker was Rev. Philip Krey, the president of the Lutheran Theological Seminary here in Philadelphia. The purpose of this gathering was not to decide on one candidate or the other, but to clarify the context in which Christians, specifically Lutheran Christians, understand politics and our role in the political process.
The discussion was good – it was civil, for the most part, and serious, substantive issues were discussed. The gist of Dr. Krey’s presentation was that a Lutheran understanding of politics is based on Luther’s doctrine of the “two kingdoms.” The idea being that politics is the sphere in which reason, prudence and compromise must hold sway rather than religious notions of right and wrong. This is similar two Augustine’s idea of the “two cities.” The essential functions of government are to defend from external attack, keep the internal peace, and protect the poor. (Luther would’ve agreed with G.K. Chesterton who quipped that the poor object to being governed badly, while the rich object to being governed at all.)
The role of the church, with respect to politics, is to hold political leaders accountable when they go astray. Luther was not shy about criticizing the German princes when he thought they were misgoverning (most infamously in his exhortation to the princes to put down the peasants’ revolt). However, the church, per se, doesn’t wield the sword, i.e. hold political power.
Dr. Krey is clearly a Kerry man. He criticized the Bush administration (and “Christian fundamentalists”) for trying to blur the distinction between the two kingdoms. He said that this is part of a movement to jettison our Enlightenment heritage and return to the model of the Middle Ages where the church held sway over political authorities. He also emphasized what he saw as the “arrogance” of the current administration’s attitude to the rule of international norms.
The question that I put to Dr. Krey was how we can simultaneously hold that it’s dangerous for the President to be swayed by religious beliefs in making policy, and that the church should criticize political leaders (since this assumes that we think political leaders should listen to the church)? In other words, how is the church supposed to “speak truth to power” as they say, without transgressing the very boundary that the doctrine of the two kingdoms is supposed to uphold?
His response was to tell a story about Bishop Mark Hanson’s (the presiding bishop of the ELCA) visit to the White House during the run-up to the war. According to Dr. Krey, Bp. Hanson warned President Bush that a pre-emptive war in Iraq was likely to unleash chaos and result in much suffering. This was an example of church leaders seeking to hold politicians accountable.
But in this case, I asked, was the Bishop speaking as a religious leader or as an amateur geopolitical analyst? If the former, then it looks like we’re back to square one with religion seeking to influence the President’s decisions. If the latter, then the Bishop is speaking with no special authority, since he wouldn’t have been any better informed about the likely outcome of a war than other sources of information at the President’s disposal (though, of course, Bp. Hanson turned out to be largely right). What do Christians have to bring to the political table if they’re not speaking as Christians?
All of which indicates, to me at least, the inadequacy of the “two kingdoms” view as applied to our modern (or post-modern) situation. It may be that Luther could allow “reason” to hold sway in the realm of politics because he thought natural justice was largely identical with the revealed moral law. Attempts to paint Luther as a proto-liberal have to reckon, it seems to me, with the fact that nearly everyone in his political milieu was Christian and would have had similar views about the common good. In this situation, it makes sense to think of clergymen criticizing political rulers on the basis of a shared morality.
But one of the most salient differences between our time and Luther’s is that not only is their wide disagreement about particular religious claims, there is also wide disagreement about what the natural law requires in the way of political and social justice. For that matter, there is wide disagreement about whether there even is a natural law! Alasdair MacIntyre’s question seems appropriate: Whose justice and which rationality will guide our political decisions?
Modern liberalism (and, in this sense, many “conservatives” are liberals) rests on the notion that we can bracket or indefinitely defer questions about the good life and the ultimate nature and destiny of human beings as far as politics is concerned. Is this the same thing that Luther had in mind when he delegated authority over the political realm to reason?
Various bloggers have weighed in on the issue of voting.
One of the more thoughtful is Tom at Disputations who has done a series of posts from his Catholic perspective (there are lots of good posts from Oct 7th to today).
Also, Among the Ruins has several worthwhile posts (here, here and here). Link via Camassia.
Not to get monomaniacal on the subject, but, hey, what’s a blog for if not to indulge in what preoccupies me at the moment?