I would say that vegetarianism is the diet of hope, an eschatological diet. It’s not morally obligatory, though it’s morally commendable, because it’s an impossible diet. No matter what we eat, we’re going to take away food from other animals. Even if we turn all of America into cropland we will inflict suffering on animals because you have to keep animals out of the field.
One problem with vegetarianism is that it often gives rise to self-righteousness, a sense of holier-than-thou purity. It can be schismatic, which I think is why the church has seldom embraced it.
It’s a diet of witnessing to your hope that, in the end, God will restore the entire world to God’s original intentions. That God will redeem humans and animals alike.
Author: Lee M.
-
Thought for the Day
-
The Other Journal
The Other Journal describes itself as “an intersection of theology and culture.”
The current issue focuses on the election and features interviews with Stanley Hauerwas, Jean Bethke Elshtain, Walter Brueggemann and others.
-
"My Kingdom Is Not of This World"
Kerry voter Hugo Schwyzer puts tomorrow’s election in perspective:
Both liberal and conservative Christians are too enamored of the power of the secular state to transform the hearts and minds and lives of its citizens and the citizens of the world. Yes, the moral character of the ruler matters. Yes, the policies of the state matter — and good Christians can differ in good conscience as to what those policies ought to be. But the God I worship had little time for great leaders when he walked the earth. Jesus was political, yes — but His politics were far more radical than anything any modern politician could possibly espouse. To claim Jesus’ endorsement for any party, any candidate, is unbiblical and profoundly offensive.
I’m tired of the question, “What Would Jesus Do?” Though a useful corrective to the self-absorbed, the question assumes that there is always a clear answer. Sometimes, the answer is clear. More often, it isn’t. I’m no bible expert, but one thing I see in the Gospel is Jesus consistently confounding the expectations of his followers. He tends to do the unexpected, the surprising, the scandalous. Even those who knew Him best were taken aback time and time again.
So do I know how Jesus wants me to vote? No, I don’t. I don’t think anyone else knows either. I know He calls us to service, sacrifice and giving. But beyond that, a humble respect for mystery does not allow me to go. I’m voting for Kerry. I want him to win. But I would never, ever, be so bold as to say that he is God’s candidate. Of course, I also categorically reject the suggestion that the incumbent is God’s favorite in this race. Ultimately, Bush and Kerry are competing to be the most powerful prince in the contemporary world’s greatest principality. And while Christians can and should take an active interest in the affairs of this world, there is no question that real justice, real transformation, and real hope cannot come from the princes of this world.
Read more here.
-
Hamlets at the Ballot Box
Andy at Among the Ruins has a post on the dilemma of voting, using Walker Percy’s novel The Moviegoer as his jumping-off point:
I just finished re-reading Walker Percy’s novel, The Moviegoer. It’s been an extremely edifying read – especially since I was guided by an extremely competent literary critic this time.
I now resonate even more deeply with Percy’s protagonist: the modern-day Hamlet, world-weary suburban playboy, Binx Bolling. I’m currently deliberating over doctoral programs (both where and what to study – assuming I’m accepted). Like Binx, vocational clarity eludes me – and it almost always has. Unlike Binx, I’m excessively scrupulous about Doing The Right Thing….
From the other direction but with the same sentiment, the authors of The Ivy Bush enlist Papa Luther in their cause by urging any and all fenceriders to “sin boldly” and help get out the vote for Kerry. (A reminder I could always use. I have a feeling Luther’s advice to me during one of my recurring Big Decision crises would be: “Less oh-so-earnest prayer; more beer.”)
It’s hard to absorb the force of these attacks. I suppose since I live in a state whose electoral votes aren’t even slightly up for grabs, I have the luxury of thinking about voting (or not voting) as my chance to make a clear statement for what’s good and true.
Unlike Andy, I don’t even have the luxury of living in a non-battleground state! But I particularly like the invocation of Luther.
-
Reconsidering Ecclesiology
In my Reformation Day post I said that one of my disagreements with Roman Catholicism was a preference for a decentralized ecclesiology (doctrine of the church) as opposed to a centralized, hierarchical one. Specifically I wrote:
For most Protestants, the local congregation is sufficient in itself for the Church to be present. The universal church is the invisible collection of all believers, past and present, living and dead. It doesn’t have an institutional expression per se. As Timothy George puts it “the invisible church emerges into visibility in the local congregation” when the Word is rightly preached and the Sacraments and rightly administered.
Thinking about this some more, this seems not quite right. To be more specific, there are many forms of church polity that steer between pure congregationalism (which is what my earlier post looks like it’s endorsing) and an episcopal form like that of the RCC. Indeed, my own ELCA tries to steer just such a middle course.
This was brought home by a post at Noli Irritare Leones comparing Quaker and Anglican ecclesiologies:
…I hold no fixed theological position about how local churches ought to relate to any larger organization. But I do know that the Trinity International University faith statement version of justifying local control makes no sense to me; there has never been a time when you had only local churches and some sort of invisible church; local churches have always, rather, been part of some larger organization. It’s so now; it was so in the time of the early post-Biblical church, and it was so in Biblical times as well. Paul certainly doesn’t speak, in his epistles, as if local congregations were all there were.
I think this is right. There has to be some way that local congregations relate to one another and are accountable to the larger Christian community. Whether this means something like an episcopal structure may be a matter of prudence rather than biblical mandate, but it seems like something like episcopal oversight was prevalent very early on in the church’s history, not something to be disregarded lightly.
-
Mel vs. ESCR
A man of conscience speaking out or the continuation of the deplorable celebrity-ization of our politics? I report, you decide.
-
TNP Voting Roundtable
The editors of the New Pantagruel have published a roundtable on tomorrow’s election. It’s interesting how many were Nader voters in 2000. This may be reflective of TNP’s brand of orthodox Christian, anti-consumerist, anti-modern “conservatism.” (Dare we say green conservatism?)
-
The Libertarian Case for Bush
-
The Self-Inflation of the Punditocracy
Another article today at TCS opens with this paragraph:
Two of America’s most important Brits — Andrew Sullivan and Christopher Hitchens — have endorsed John Kerry for President. Their endorsements are important because both support an aggressive pursuit of the war on terrorism, an issue where Senator Kerry’s commitment is suspect. Their endorsements are also important because both Sullivan and Hitchens resist taking positions out of blind partisan loyalty. When they take positions, whether you agree with them or not, it is safe to assume that they have thought them through.
Now, with all due respect to Messers. Sullivan and Hitchens, I think it’s extremely easy, especially for those of us who spend a lot of time keeping up with political commentary, to overestimate the importance of what pundits say in general and with respect to their presidential endorsements in particular. For instance, I mentioned to my wife the other day that Andrew Sullivan had come out for Kerry. “Who’s that?” she asked. Keep in mind that she is a student at an Ivy-league law school and very well informed on current events and she had no idea who Sullivan was. A little perspective may be in order.
-
100,000 Iraqis Dead in War?
Around 100,000 Iraqis have been killed in violence since the US-led coalition forces invaded the country in March 2003, said a report published Friday in British medicine journal The Lancet.
More than half of those who died were women and children killed in air strikes, American public health experts said in the latest issue of the magazine.
The study, which was carried out in 33 randomly chosen neighborhoods of Iraq representative of the entire population, shows that violence is now the leading cause of death in Iraq.
More here.
UPDATE: Tim Worstall at Tech Central Station questions the accuracy of the report here.
UPDATE II: Juan Cole also comments here:
The methodology of this study is very tight, but it does involve extrapolating from a small number and so could easily be substantially incorrect. But the methodology also is standard in such situations and was used in Bosnia and Kosovo.
I think the results are probably an exaggeration. But they can’t be so radically far off that the 16,000 deaths previously estimated can still be viewed as valid. I’d say we have to now revise the number up to at least many tens of thousand–which anyway makes sense. The 16,000 estimate comes from counting all deaths reported in the Western press, which everyone always knew was only a fraction of the true total. (I see deaths reported in al-Zaman every day that don’t show up in the Western wire services).
The most important finding from my point of view is not the magnitude of civilian deaths, but the method of them. Roberts and Burnham find that US aerial bombardments are killing far more Iraqi civilians than had previously been suspected. This finding is also not a surprise to me. I can remember how, on a single day (August 12), US warplanes bombed the southern Shiite city of Kut, killing 84 persons, mainly civilians, in an attempt to get at Mahdi Army militiamen. These deaths were not widely reported in the US press, especially television. Kut is a small place and has been relatively quiet except when the US has been attacking Muqtada al-Sadr, who is popular among some segments of the population there. The toll in Sadr City or the Shiite slums of East Baghdad, or Najaf, or in al-Anbar province, must be enormous.