This is nuts. But waitaminute! I thought Pres. Bush=Hitler? Get your story straight, guys.
(via Pontifications)
This is nuts. But waitaminute! I thought Pres. Bush=Hitler? Get your story straight, guys.
(via Pontifications)
When we talk about ecumenism and pray for the unity of the church, what kind of unity are we looking for? I don’t have any well-thought out ideas on the matter, but Josh left a comment outlining his idea of what unity might look like that I think merits a post of its own (edited slightly):
1) Any christian, of any church which can be said to be rooted in historical orthodoxy (as represented in the creeds, and the Councils of Nicea I, Constantinople I, & Chalcedon) can participate in the sacraments in any other Christian church on the planet. I think this might be expanded to include the Eastern dissident churches as well, due to their antiquity, and possibly Unitarians and Universalists since their roots are in the 16th century Reformed churches. This might also include Quakers but would probably exclude Mormons, JW’s etc.
2) Easy transfer of membership from one congregation to another. If I want to start going to another congregation of another denomination, I should be able to just get a letter or better yet electronic transfer of membership to my new congregation without having to go though a new membership process to get plugged into the ministries of my new church home.
3) Greater co-operation in evangelism, relief and health care work, education, economic development, leadership development, and other global missions activity. This might take the form of a global missions fund or series of funds all denominations contribute to and draw from.
4) Limited clergy sharing. In groups with few real doctrinal differences like Methodists and Episcopalians or Presbyterians and Congregationalists, there should be complete sharing. For other groups there could be limited sharing, at the discrecion of the bishop, presbytery or whatever in a particular locality.
5) A recognition of the see of Rome as the primus inter pares (nothing more), not only among the bishops per se but among individual church bodies.
6) All current denominations would maitain their individual seminaries, ecclesiastical bodies, magisteriums (sorry my Latin is rusty) and polity.
7) A new TRULY ecumenical council to iron all this out and find common ground on which to base this new unity, like the scriptures, Justification by grace through faith, the creeds, love, the Holy Spirit, Christ, etc. There should also be smaller synods to meet in various nations and regions from time to time and perhaps a regular schedule of councils to meet regularly.
Any thoughts?
Andrew J. Bacevich has impeccable conservative credentials. He’s written for First Things, The Weekly Standard, National Review, is a West Point grad and a Vietnam vet. But his new book The New American Militarism is a scathing indictment of what passes for conservatism nowadays.
Tom Engelhardt’s TomDispatch is carrying an excerpt from Bacevich’s book.
Bacevich
writes that he still situates himself “culturally on the right. And I continue to view the remedies proferred by mainstream liberalism with skepticism. But my disenchantment with what passes for mainstream conservatism, embodied in the present Bush administration and its groupies, is just about absolute. Fiscal irresponsibility, a buccaneering foreign policy, a disregard for the Constitution, the barest lip service as a response to profound moral controversies: these do not qualify as authentically conservative values. On this score my views have come to coincide with the critique long offered by the radical left: it is the mainstream itself, the professional liberals as well as the professional conservatives who define the problem.”
Couldn’t have said it better myself! I voted for Bush in 2000, but couldn’t bring myself to do so in 2004 for precisely these sorts of reasons.
Since I don’t think Blogger has a “categories” feature, I’ve added a section on the right for “Think Pieces,” Manifestos, etc. – longer pieces of a broader scope than the typical link-with-brief-commentary post. I more or less stand by what I said in most of them (how’s that for a hedge?).
Casey’s showing a fourteen point lead according to this. Still, we’re talking about a race that won’t begin in earnest til a year from now. Plus, one wonders how much Pennsylvanians really know about Bob Casey, Jr. Granted he was elected overwhelmingly to the post of state treasurer last year, but I expect he’s still coasting on name recognition to a large degree.
Santorum, whatever one thinks of his performance as a Senator, is no fool; he’s been moderating his positions (or at least appearing to moderate them) on things like the death penalty and the minimum wage recently. Not to mention his support for the “moderate” pro-choice Arlen Specter last year against his pro-life challenger Pat Toomey. I’m guessing it’ll be a close race.
One more…this one’s from Lutheran Uwe Siemon-Netto, religion writer for UPI. Siemon-Netto attempts a debunking of some of the more common myths floating around.
He’s a religious fanatic who hates reason and wants to return to the Dark Ages!
He will doubtless baffle many of his former detractors by stressing the need for a return to reason, which is a central theme of his theology. For Ratzinger, the significance of reason was precisely why John the Evangelist used the word, “Logos,” in referring to Christ in the opening sentence of his Gospel.
“‘Logos’ denotes reason and meaning, but also Word,” Ratzinger wrote. “The God, who is Logos, assures us of the rationality of the world, the rationality of our being, the divine character of reason, and the reasonable character of God, even though God’s rationality surpasses ours immeasurably and appears to us as darkness.”
Ratzinger insists, “Rationality has been the postulate and the condition of Christianity and will remain a European legacy with which we can confront peacefully and positively Islam as well as the great Asian religions.”
[…]
Hence, he continued, “Europe must defend reason. To this extent we must be grateful to secular society and the Enlightenment. It must remain a thorn in our side, as secular society must accept the (Christian) thorn it its side—meaning the founding power of the Christian religion in Europe.”
He’s a foe of ecumenism and a hard-hearted triumphalist!
Coming from the land of the Protestant Reformation, this allegedly doctrinaire Catholic has already made it clear by his very actions the journey out of the “tyranny of relativism,” whose properties are suspended ethical principles, must be an all-Christian enterprise.
Almost unnoticed by the world’s media looking for sensations at the memorial service for John Paul II, Ratzinger quietly communed Brother Roger Schutz, the Swiss Protestant pastor and founder of the vibrant ecumenical community in Taizé, France.
Benedict XVI, arguably the foremost Catholic theologian of our time, has always been an ecumenist, though never a fuzzy one. If he gives the Sacrament to a member of another Christian church—and Schutz was not the only one—he makes it abundantly clear he consider this person a fellow member of the mystical Body of Christ, which is the Church.
As happens all too often, I’ve been sidetracked from my reading schedule (loosey-goosey as it is) by a trip to the Philly public library. (The beautiful weather we’ve been having has made the walk from the office to the library enjoyable as well as edifying!)
Two acquisitions of note on the latest trip:
I’m usually one to groan when some actor or rock star starts spouting off about politics (then again, why should their opinions be worth less than some semi-anonymous guy sitting in front of a computer screen?), but I found these snippets from Bono’s new book relatively sensible (link via Thunderstruck).
Bono on G. W. Bush:
“He was much more amusing than I expected. Like, he was funny and quick. … For all the swagger, this Texan thing, he has a religious instinct that keeps him humble.”
Bono on the Iraq war:
“There are very few things I would disagree with Tony Blair about. Going to war, when he did, with Iraq would be one of them. … It wasn’t a move to make himself popular. Fairly unusual behavior for a politician. We need more of this. … There are those who believe in the long term that establishing a beachhead for democracy in the Middle East is the only way to bring peace to the region. I’m not one of them. I have only to look to my own country to see what the presence of a foreign military can do for swelling the ranks of terrorism.”
Bono the Free Trader!
“The Left may offer more money to fight AIDS or deal with the debt burden, but they scuttle off when we talk about trade reform. The [Common Agricultural Policy] of Europe so supported by the Left denies African products access to our supermarket shelves while we flood them with subsidized produce. … French cows have more money spent on them per day than most Africans earn. But you know what? This is one issue this rock star just cannot take on.”
Interesting, but to be read with some skepticism since Michael Novak is a shameless apologist for the spiritual glories of capitalism and the idea that the ideals of the American founding are in perfect sync with Christianity (I like capitalism – in a Churchillian ‘least bad of the available options’ sense – and the principles of the American founding too, but I at least expect there to be some tension there!).
Anyway, here’s Novak on the political philosophy of the new pope:
One of Cardinal Ratzinger’s central, and most misunderstood, notions is his conception of liberty, and he is very jealous in thinking deeply about it, pointing often to Tocqueville. He is a strong foe of socialism, statism and authoritarianism, but he also worries that democracy, despite its great promise, is exceedingly vulnerable to the tyranny of the majority, to “the new soft despotism” of the all-mothering state, and to the common belief that liberty means doing whatever you please. Following Lord Acton and James Madison, Cardinal Ratzinger has written of the need of humans to practice self-government over their passions in private life.
A homily from 1981:
The state is not the whole of human existence and does not embrace the whole of human hope. Men and women and their hopes extend beyond the thing that is the state and beyond the sphere of political activity. This does not only apply to a state that is Babylon but to any and every state. The state is not the totality: that takes the load off the politician’s shoulders and at the same time opens up for him or her the path of rational politics. The Roman state was false and anti-Christian precisely because it wanted to be the totality of human capacity. In that way it claimed what it could not achieve; and in that way it distorted and diminished men and women. Through the totalitarian lie it became demonic and tyrannical. Getting rid of the totality of the state has demythologized the state and thereby liberated men and women as well as politicians and politics.
But when Christian faith, faith in man’s greater hope, decays and falls away, then the myth of the divine state rises up once again, because men and women cannot renounce the totality of hope. Even when such promises dress themselves up as progress and monopolize the concept of progress and of progressiveness, nevertheless considered historically they are a going back behind the Christian thing that is new, a turning back on the scale of history. And even when they proclaim as their goal the complete liberation of mankind and the elimination of all domination, they stand in contradiction to the truth of man and in contradiction to his or her freedom, because they force people into what they can achieve themselves. This kind of politics that declares the kingdom of God to be the result politics and distorts faith into universal primacy of the political is by its nature the politics of enslavement; it is mythological politics.
To this, faith opposes the standard of Christian reason, which recognizes what man is really capable of creating as the order of freedom and can be content with this because it knows that man’s greater expectation lies hidden in God’s hands. Rejecting the hope of faith is at the same time rejecting the standard of political reason. To renounce the mythical hopes of a society free of domination is not resignation but honesty that maintains men and women in hope. The mythical hope of a do-it-yourself paradise can only drive people into fear from which there is no escape; fear of the collapse of their promises and of the greater void lurks behind it; fear of their own power and its cruelty.