Here’s a sober and thorough attempt to look at the “war on terror” through the prism of just war theory (via Ut Unum Sint). The author also discusses Jody Bottum’s “New Fusionism” which I wrote about here.
Author: Lee M.
-
The libertarian C.S. Lewis?
The Discovery Institute has an online book on “C.S. Lewis and Public Life” that I came across the other day. In particular this chapter where Gilbert Meilaender discusses Lewis’ views on the role of government.
Lewis, Meilaender points out, saw “omnicompetent government” as inherently antithetical to Christianity:
Christianity, with its claims in one way personal and in another way ecumenical and both ways antithetical to omnicompetent government, must always in fact . . .be treated as an enemy. Like learning, like the family, like any ancient and liberal profession, like the common law, it gives the individual a standing ground against the state. (from “On the Transmission of Christianity” in God in the Dock)
Meilaender argues that Lewis had an “Augustinian” view of politics in that he distinguished sharply between virtue and justice. The task of the state is to maintain justice, but it’s too blunt an instrument to inculcate virtue.
To ask of sinful human history more than it can give is often the quickest way to achieve less good than is possible. We can make comparative judgments of better or worse, just as Augustine admired the ancient Romans more than those of his own day, but we cannot transform our communities into the City of God. An obvious conclusion follows, and Lewis states it clearly: “The practical problem of Christian politics is not that of drawing up schemes for a Christian society, but that of living as innocently as we can with unbelieving fellow-subjects under unbelieving rulers who will never be perfectly wise and good and who will sometimes be very wicked and very foolish.” Lewis does not, therefore, expect much from the political realm.
More important still, he thinks it would be a mistake for us to use its power in our efforts to achieve moral goods that go beyond that justice which government exists to provide. Whether we lack or possess political power, it will be equally true that “those who torment us for our own good will torment us without end for they do so with the approval of their own conscience.” Good ethics and good politics are therefore not the same. The political realm seeks not virtue, only justice. If Lewis is hesitant to recommend the use of political power in service of morally desirable goals, that does not mean that no social transformation or improvement of our communities is possible. It means only that our efforts to promote good ethics should not make use of political power. Thus, the sharp distinction between ethics and politics becomes a distinction between the social and the political. [footnotes omitted – ed.]
This led to some positions that some of Lewis latter-day admirers might find alarming:
Lewis not only makes this distinction, he clearly seems to think that the social is in one important sense more fundamental than the political.”The law must rise to our standards when we improve and sink to them when we decay.” That position governs Lewis’ judgment, for example, about both sexual conduct and sexually explicit literature; although he believes that “masturbation, perversion [i.e. , homosexuality], fornication and adultery” are wrong, he realizes that many of his contemporaries no longer regard such conduct as morally evil. Because, in his view, laws will necessarily reflect the mores of a people, the law cannot be expected to continue to support his own moral judgments on these matters and attempts to make it do so are likely to lead only to confusion and hypocrisy. He suggests that the law might rightly still concern itself with adultery because it is an instance of injustice, when promises on which others have depended in significant ways are broken, but not because adultery is an instance of sexual immorality.The law must concern itself with injustice, not with forms of sexual wrong-doing that, however wrong, are not unjust.
It makes you wonder where, if anywhere, Lewis would feel at home on our political spectrum.
-
Truck and barter
Marcus has posted a comment-box discussion between me and him on the merits of free trade vs. protectionism. As I said over there, I’m still agnostic on the matter.
One thing that confuses the issue, as I’ve mentioned before, is that “free” trade agreements are often elborate schemes of government-managed trade. For an example of the “purist” free trader argument against such agreements see here.
Marcus also directs our attention to this article by theologian John Cobb, Jr., which looks interesting.
-
Frugality vs. justice?
Kim-Loi Mergenthaler (congrats on that new baby!) posts on the tension between trying to consume less and live more simply and trying to make socially conscious choices with one’s money:
If everyone were upper middle class like many of the environmentalists I’ve met, we could all drive hybrid cars, install solar panels in our homes, and buy organic, but what if we can’t afford to make those choices? I’d gladly support farmers by purchasing fair trade coffee if it weren’t so darn expensive. I wish I could justify spending $3.00/dozen for farm fresh, locally grown, organic eggs but can no longer do so when regular eggs were on sale for $.77/dozen at the supermarket last week.
She also makes some good observations about how cheap goods have broader social costs. More here.
-
Luther and Sola Scriptura
Some comments in the post below got off on a tangent about Stanley Hauerwas and the use of Scripture in the church and it got me thinking about the meaning of the Protestant principle of “sola scriptura.” After a bit of poking around I found an article by David W. Lotz of Union Theological Seminary called “The Proclamation of the Word in Luther’s Thought.”
Here’s a relevant bit:
The Holy Scriptures are justly called Word of God, the written Word, because they have God the Holy Spirit as their ultimate author: the prophets and apostles all spoke and wrote under the inspiration of the Spirit. Yet the Scriptures are the Word of God in a seconday or derivative sense because they always point beyond themselves to Jesus Christ, the incarnate Word, who is their matchless content; to the prophetic and apostolic gospel of Christ, which is their glorious theme; and to the church’s continuous proclamation of this biblical gospel, which is their true reason for being. The Scriptures possess sole normative authority for the church’s faith and life inasmuch as they are the source and standard of its teaching and preaching. Preachers must “extract” their message from the Scriptures to insure that they are now preaching the same gospel taht the prophets and apostles once proclaimed as the foundation of the church. Their message must be tested by the Scriptures to insure that it is truly gospel and so Word of God. Thus the Bible’s authority is ultimately rooted in the authority of the gospel of Christ, namely, that original spoken Word which brought forth the Scriptures and which is now available only in the Scriptures.
For Luther, according to Lotz, the oral proclamation of the gospel is primary because it is this proclamation which effects faith and salvation. This is God’s word in a more fundamental sense than the written word because it is the very act by which God calls sinners to salvation. It was necessary, however, to have a written testimony to make sure the church was preaching the same gospel that the apostles preached. That is why the Scriptures remain the source and norm for the church’s teaching and preaching.
-
Da Pope on concern for animals
The new Pope has spoken movingly about the exploitation of all beings, particularly of farmed animals. When he was asked about the rights of animals in a 2002 interview, he said, “That is a very serious question. At any rate, we can see that they are given into our care, that we cannot just do whatever we want with them. Animals, too, are God’s creatures . . . Certainly, a sort of industrial use of creatures, so that geese are fed in such a way as to produce as large a liver as possible, or hens live so packed together that they become just caricatures of birds, this degrading of living creatures to a commodity seems to me in fact to contradict the relationship of mutuality that comes across in the Bible.”
More here (via Andrew Sullivan).
-
Neither free nor fair
Here’s a good example of how “free trade” agreements are often anything but:
For American drug companies, this agreement [i.e. CAFTA] extends the time period during which brand-name pharmaceuticals have exclusive access to markets, postponing the entry of generic drugs and thus limiting competition. For Central Americans, the cost of drugs will soar, straining budgets and gutting health care. The result may be a death sentence for many.
In agriculture, small farmers would be placed on a collision course with U.S. agro-business and their heavily subsidized farm exports. The United States exported paddy rice, for example, at a price almost 20 percent lower than the cost of production in 2003, making it impossible for Central Americans to compete.
Read more here.
-
Celebrate diversity
The Inquirer has jumped on the trying-to-understand-those-kooky-evangelical-Christians bandwagon, running a series of stories over the past few weeks on various aspects of modern evangelicalism.
Yesterday’s paper, though, had two pretty good stories higlighting the often underreported diversity of political views among evangelicals. They emphasized the concerns many have beyond the usual triad of abortion, gay marriage and “judicial activism,” such as poverty, sex trafficking and global warming.
This piece on Colordao Springs megachurch pastor Ted Haggard focuses on the ways in which these are not your fathers evangelicals. Even among conservatives, people like Jerry Falwell and Pat Robertson are less and less representative.
Another article looks at the diversity of political views among evangelicals, with quotes from the ususal suspects like Ron Sider and Tony Campolo. Also note the interesting sidebar graph showing the breakdown of religious affiliations and their corresponding political identifications.
-
Trade, protectionism and justice
Via Eve Tushnet comes this article making the case for trade, rather than aid with Africa. It blames U.S. agricultural subsidies for directly contributing to African poverty (and raising the cost of living for American consumers to boot):
U.S. agriculture policy undermines U.S. efforts to alleviate poverty because it drives down global agricultural prices, which in turn cost developing countries hundreds of millions of dollars in lost export earnings. The losses associated with cotton subsidies alone exceed the value of U.S. aid programs to the countries concerned. The British aid organization Oxfam charges that U.S. subsidies directly led to losses of more than $300 million in potential revenue in sub-Saharan Africa during the 2001/02 season. More than 12 million people in this region depend directly on the crop, with a typical small-scale producer making less than $400 on an annual cotton harvest. By damaging the livelihoods of people already on the edge of subsistence, U.S. agricultural policies take away with the right hand what the left hand gives in aid and development assistance.
Some want to correct that problem by increasing foreign aid, but transfer payments have failed to stimulate economic growth in Africa where the average income per person is 11 percent lower today than it was in 1960. State-to-state aid is inefficient because it is often based on geopolitical considerations, not on economic criteria. As a consequence, the least deserving regimes often obtain aid. International organizations such as the World Bank are also largely ineffective. In 2000, for example, the bipartisan Meltzer Commission found that the World Bank’s aid projects failed 55 to 60 percent of the time.
The aid is ineffective because of the appalling way in which Africa is governed. In recent decades, of each dollar given to Africa in aid, 80 cents were stolen by corrupt leaders and transferred back into Western bank accounts. In total, Nigerian President Olusegun Obasanjo estimated, “corrupt African leaders have stolen at least $140 billion from their people in the [four] decades since independence.” All that is left when these regimes eventually collapse is a massive public debt.
Of course, the Pat Buchanan protectionist types would argue that the U.S. government has an obligation to protect the livelihood of U.S. agricultural (and other) industries. Plus, “free trade” agreements like NAFTA and CAFTA are often themselves backdoor forms of protectionism since they frequently incorporate sweetheart deals for certain U.S. industries doing business overseas.
I’m not sure what the solution is – a lot of depends on thorny issues of what is owed to whom by the U.S. government – to its own citizens as well as to poor people in other nations. It can’t be reduced simply to raising our “standard of living.”
-
"Creator of heaven and earth, of all things, seen and unseen"
Marvin has a most excellent post on the creationism vs. evolution debate.
I don’t object, in principle, to people pursuing things like “intelligent design” (which is not the same thing as “young earth creationism” or Genesis-literalism). I don’t know enough about it to say what its merits as a theory are; it seems to me more of a philosophical than scientific theory, though.
But regardless of the merits of ID, my faith is not affected by it, because I’ve always taken the creation accounts to be (divinely inspired) pictures of God’s realtionship to creation and humankind.