Since I criticized Joseph Bottum’s article on the “new fusionism,” it seems only fair to note that he has a really good article on capital punishment in this month’s FT. (Not that Mr. Bottum was losing sleep over criticisms from these parts!)
Author: Lee M.
-
Law and promise
The Christian Century on Joel Osteen.
It’s actually a pretty balanced article giving Osteen credit for having a multi-racial ministry for one thing. It also points out that the “prosperity” gospel isn’t necessarily as far from the Christian mainstream as one might think:In some ways Osteen echoes an ancient and venerable Christian tradition that borrows from Aristotle in calling itself “eudaemonistic.” That is, Christianity offers the happiest life possible. The church fathers and medieval thinkers who picked up this philosophical tradition did have ample biblical material with which to integrate it. “Delight yourself in the Lord, and he will give you the desires of your heart,” the psalmist promises. “Seek ye first the kingdom of God, and his righteousness; and all these things shall be added unto you,” Jesus says. What Christian could fail to agree that our faith claims to offer the fullest life of joy and abundance possible?
Though the author points out that Scripture has a decisively less rosy take on wealth to say the least.
Plus, there are other serious theological deficiencies in Osteen’s preaching, the writer thinks:
Osteen’s version of the gospel is full of “ifs.” If we enlarge our vision, if we choose to be happy, if we think thoughts and speak words of victory and blessing, if we give of ourselves abundantly—then God will bless us with everything we want. The conditional nature of these sentences is telling. This is not a gospel of grace, in which God acts in spite of our lack of faithfulness to redirect our wants. Instead this is a gospel of reward in which God does nothing until we get our act together. In traditional Christian theology, Protestant and Catholic alike, we can do nothing in and of ourselves to merit God’s favor. Rather, God comes to us in Christ when we are without merit, without ability to please God and without reason to think we can be saved or helped. Such a view of grace is surely part of the grumpy theology Osteen seeks to upend—but it is central to Christianity.
More here.
-
Unlimited executive power is not a moderate position
Since Alberto Gonzales does not have a public record of opposing Roe v. Wade or being otherwise pro-life, some media outlets seem to have dubbed him a “moderate” choice for the Supreme Court.
Gene Healy explains why you should be troubled by a Gonzales nomination whatever your stance on abortion (via Unqualified Offerings).
I ranted a bit about Gonzales here.
-
The rise of eugenic abortion
Disturbing piece from George Neumayr (via Amy Welborn):
Each year in America fewer and fewer disabled infants are born. The reason is eugenic abortion. Doctors and their patients use prenatal technology to screen unborn children for disabilities, then they use that information to abort a high percentage of them. Without much scrutiny or debate, a eugenics designed to weed out the disabled has become commonplace.
Not wishing to publicize a practice most doctors prefer to keep secret, the medical community releases only sketchy information on the frequency of eugenic abortion against the disabled. But to the extent that the numbers are known, they indicate that the vast majority of unborn children prenatally diagnosed as disabled are killed.
One of the more troubling things Neumayr points out is how the threat of “wrongful birth” suits provides incentives for doctors to recommend abortion of fetus that are disabled, or even may merely run the risk of having a certain disease:
In some cases, the aborted children aren’t disabled at all but are mere carriers of a disease or stand a chance of getting one later in life. Prenatal screening has made it possible to abort children on guesses and probabilities. The law and its indulgence of every conceivable form of litigation have also advanced the new eugenics against the disabled. Working under “liability alerts” from their companies, doctors feel pressure to provide extensive prenatal screening for every disability, lest parents or even disabled children hit them with “wrongful birth” and “wrongful life” suits.
In a wrongful-birth suit, parents can sue doctors for not informing them of their child’s disability and seek compensation from them for all the costs, financial and otherwise, stemming from a life they would have aborted had they received that prenatal information. Wrongful-life suits are brought by children (through their parents) against doctors for all the “damages” they’ve suffered from being born. (Most states recognize wrongful-birth suits, but for many states, California and New Jersey among the exceptions, wrongful-life suits are still too ridiculous to entertain.)
In 2003, Ob-Gyn Savita Khosla of Hackensack, N.J., agreed to pay $1.2 million to a couple and child after she failed to flag Fragile X syndrome, a form of mental retardation caused by a defective gene on the X chromosome. The mother felt entitled to sue Khosla because she indicated on a questionnaire that her sibling was mentally retarded and autistic, and hence Khosla should have known to perform prenatal screening for Fragile X so that she could abort the boy. Khosla settled, giving $475,000 to the parents and $750,000 to the child they wished they had aborted.
Had the case gone to court, Khosla would have probably lost the suit. New Jersey has been notoriously welcoming to wrongful-birth suits ever since Roe, after which New Jersey’s Supreme Court announced that it would not “immunize from liability those in the medical field providing inadequate guidance to persons who would choose to exercise their constitutional right to abort fetuses which, if born, would suffer from genetic defects.”
According to the publication Medical Malpractice Law & Strategy, “court rulings across the country are showing that the increased use of genetic testing has substantially exposed physicians’ liability for failure to counsel patients about hereditary disorders.”
The publication revealed that many wrongful-birth cases “are settled confidentially.” And it predicted that doctors who don’t give their patients the information with which to consider the eugenic option against disabled children will face more lawsuits as prenatal screening becomes the norm. “The human genome has been completely mapped,” it quotes Stephen Winnick, a lawyer who handled one of the first-wrongful birth cases. “It’s almost inevitable that there will be an increase in these cases.”
The combination of doctors seeking to avoid lawsuits and parents seeking burden-free children means that once prenatal screening identifies a problem in a child, the temptation to eugenic abortion becomes unstoppable. In an atmosphere of expected eugenics, even queasy, vaguely pro-life parents gravitate toward aborting a disabled child.
-
The Thomas Frank thesis in action
From Newsweek (via Get Religion):
Keeping Republicans and their conservative kin together won’t be easy. For the first time in a nomination fight, corporate lobbyists are determined to play a leading public role. They are concerned that an obsessive focus on abortion and gay marriage will jeopardize what they regard as a once-in-a-generation chance to unshackle commerce from the grip of federal regulators. To hold their hands, they have not only [GOP lobbyist Ed] Gillespie—whose lobbying firm maintains a roster of big-business clients—but former senator Fred Thompson of Tennessee, the actor-lawyer-lobbyist, who signed on as the “sherpa” who will walk at least one Bush nominee through the confirmation process (think Virgil in Dante’s “Inferno”).
So, what happens if the pro-lifers and social cons get sold out for someone who will “unshackle commerce”? Will they desert the GOP? Do they have anywhere to go?
-
"That they may all be one"
Frederica Mathewes-Green compares Roman Catholic and Orthodox views of what the unity of the church means (she’s Orthodox).
Ms. Mathewes-Green says that RCs focus on membership, or belonging to an institution, whereas Orthodox focus on shared belief.
From a Roman Catholic perspective, unity is created by the institution of the church. Within that unity there can be diversity; not everyone agrees with official teaching, some very loudly. What holds things together is membership. This kind of unity makes immediate sense to Americans: Whatever their disagreements, everyone salutes the flag, and all Catholics salute, if not technically obey, Rome’s magisterium.
When Roman Catholics look at Orthodoxy, they don’t see a centralized, global institution. Instead, the church appears to be a jumble of national and ethnic bodies (a situation even more confused in the U.S. as a result of immigration). To Catholics, the Orthodox Church looks like chaos.
But from an Orthodox perspective, unity is created by believing the same things. It’s like the unity among vegetarians or Red Sox fans. You don’t need a big bureaucracy to keep them faithful. Across wildly diverse cultures, Orthodox Christians show remarkable unity in their faith. (Of course there are plenty of power struggles and plain old sin, but the essential faith isn’t challenged.) What’s the source of this common faith? The consensus of the early church, which the Orthodox stubbornly keep following. That consensus was forged with many a bang and dent, but for the past millennium major questions of faith and morals have been pretty much at rest in the Eastern hemisphere.
How do Protestants fit in here? The Augsburg Confession, Article 7, for instance, says this about the unity of the church:
The Church is the congregation of saints, in which the Gospel is rightly taught and the Sacraments are rightly administered.
And to the true unity of the Church it is enough to agree concerning the doctrine of the Gospel and the administration of the Sacraments. Nor is it necessary that human traditions, that is, rites or ceremonies, instituted by men, should be everywhere alike. As Paul says: One faith, one Baptism, one God and Father of all, etc. Eph. 4, 5. 6.
On the face of it, this seems closer to the Orthodox view, at least as Ms. Mathewes-Green describes it.
-
Paradigm shift
Good article from Alan Bock on the United States’ “Middle Eastern Paradigm” (MEP) and how it ought to change. Bock argues, leaning on the work of Leon Hadar, that the paradigm the U.S. has used in dealing with the Middle East grew out of the Cold War and a perceived need to counter Soviet influence there.
Bock quotes Hadar:
Central to this MEP was the belief that competition with the Soviet Union made American involvement in the Middle East a costly but necessary way to protect American interests as the leader of the Western alliance.
However, with the end of the Cold War:
[T]he Arab-Israeli conflict had become, from the standpoint of core U.S. interests, simply another regional conflict that was likely to continue until both parties were exhausted enough to end it, but whose outcome had about the same genuinely geostrategic implications as Bosnian-Serb, Azerbaijani-Armenian, or any of a dozen or more other regional conflicts in the world. The continuing American effort to mediate or “do something” about the conflict, he argued – let alone American subsidies to the military capabilities of both sides – more likely prolonged the conflict rather than shortening it because it prevented the parties from shouldering the full economic and social burdens of war, thus postponing the day when they were ready to end it or negotiate a settlement.
Not only is our extensive involvement in the Middle East no longer necessary to counter the Reds, but it exacerbates problems there by delaying a settlement of the Arab-Israeli conlflict, and it has led us to prop up despotism like that of Saudi Arabia who, while not pro-Israel, could be counted on the be anti-Soviet much of the time. But of course the Saudis became one of the biggest promoters of Wahabi Islam, the source of so many of our problems today.
Bock also claims that the the idea that we must remain involved in the Middle East to keep the cheap oil flowing is a myth:
Leon Hadar argues that it is time to develop a new paradigm for relations with the Middle East. He notes that “the American economy is not dependent on Middle Eastern oil – 70 percent of American energy supplies do not originate in the Middle East.”
The United States is actually more dependent on Latin American oil than it is on Saudi and other Persian Gulf oil. And the notion that American policy in the Middle East helps to provide Americans access to ‘cheap and affordable oil’ makes little sense if one takes into consideration the military and other costs – including two Gulf Wars and the current Pax Americana in the Middle East – that are added to the price that the American consumer pays for driving his or her car. (p. 154)
He does not say so directly, but implies that U.S. military force is quite likely not necessary to maintain access to Persian Gulf oil, either for the U.S. or for Western Europe and Japan. The oil-producing states have few resources other than oil, and if they don’t sell oil to somebody they will have little wealth with which to maintain their power and curb domestic challenges. So they need to sell oil more than the United States needs to buy it. If political and military influence is required to keep the oil flowing to Western Europe and Japan (and increasingly to China) – which I rather doubt – the countries that are truly dependent should be the ones to bear the cost.
What we need, he says, is “constructive disengagement” – i.e. stepping back and letting the regional powers (and the Europeans, if necessary) deal with conflicts. This involves giving up “the idea that the U.S. should be the final arbiter, if not the actual ruler, in disputes throughout the world, which would mean not only tolerating but welcoming European activity in regions the U.S. viewed as essential during the Cold War. Abandoning what might be viewed as the imperial attitude that every problem in the world is automatically an American problem that requires American action will not be easy.”
Unfortunately for this view, this idea of the U.S. as global fixer of problems is shared by people across the political spectrum. How often does one hear from liberals who denounce American imperialism in one breath that the U.S. should impose a “just peace” on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict? This is also one of the pitfalls of a UN “collective security” model – it tends to elevate every regional conflict into a global problem.
-
Braaten update
Lots of comments over at Versus Populum.
Pastor Frontz has posted a very thorough explication of the kind of “liberal Protestantism” Braaten seems to have in mind:
In the contemporary “Protestant” culture, Braaten and others see a Kulturprotestantismus which differs in its assumptions about the culture but is one with the primary assumption that Barth critiques: the idea that one can know God and God’s will through other means than through Christ. In our context, this means: there is no mediator – God or Christ primarily speaks to us through our experience of self and world and the experience of those who are oppressed, whatever their experience may be. Neither the Scriptures nor the Church are truly sources of authority – at best, they become the confirmation of God granting me my own authority as authentic self-interpreter. When they contradict my view or my culture’s view of reality, they may be set aside because they do not define Christ for me: rather, my own understanding and experience defines Christ for me. This may best be summed up in our day by what is now the unofficial creed of our full communion partner, the United Church of Christ: “God is still speaking,” and its unofficial symbol, the comma. How does God speak? Not through Bible, Sacrament, Creed, confession, or community, but through my own imaging of who God might be and my own unique experience of reality. This necessarily leads to a plurality of truths, which in effect is a negation of truth, for the notion that there can be more than one truthful answer to a specific question is logically bankrupt.
This strikes me as very incisive. All too often Christianity has been subjected to innovations because the experience of “modern man” (or some subset thereof) seems to demand it. Theology and peity have been tested by anthropological criteria rather than Christological.
And yet a question I still have is this: in some sense the Scriptures and the Tradition are mediated to us through our experience, aren’t they? It’s not as if we can ever break loose of our own cultural moorings and personal limitations to have an unmediated encounter with the tradition. To put it crudely, won’t what we hear God saying through the tradition differ from what our ancestors heard?
Pr. Frontz mentions the question of homosexuality as symptomatic of the loss of an adherence to an authoritative tradition, and I do think that’s in some ways the elephant in the room in Braaten’s letter. Still, what would Braaten say about, say, divorce, women’s ordination, or birth control? These are all areas where the tradition spoke with a unified voice until relatively recently. Would Braaten disavow those innovations? And if not, then it seems to me we do need some account of how the tradition can change in light of new experiences. (Or we can become Roman Catholic, where they have – with varying degrees of success and credibility – held the line on these things.)
This is not to take a position on one side or the other of the homosexuality debate. But it does seem to me that there’s a logical space for those of us who earnestly want to be faithful to the tradition and yet still struggle with some parts of the tradition as they’ve been handed down to us. I think of someone like Abp. Rowan Williams, who I don’t think it would be fair to characterize as a theological liberal, but who has been willing to re-think the church’s traditional position on certain moral views. Do those kinds of changes necessarily entail a slippery slope to the abandonment of our evangelical and catholic heritage?
-
A specter is haunting philosophy…
Remember the BBC poll to determine the greatest philosopher in history?
Well, they’ve announced the winner and it’s none other than Uncle Karl himself! And by a significant margin too!
Here’s how the vote broke down:
Marx: 27.93%
Hume: 12.67%
Wittgenstein: 6.80%
Nietzsche: 6.49%
Plato: 5.65%
Kant: 5.61%
St. Thomas: 4.83%
Socrates: 4.82%
Aristotle: 4.52%
Karl Popper: 4.20% -
Are the bad guys really this stupid?
Maybe I don’t understand terrorist strategy or something, but I can’t see how blowing up little kids is a good way to win friends or influence people. I mean, presumably, even Iraqis who are hostile to the occupation would abhor this kind of depraved act.