Author: Lee M.

  • Romans 13 as death penalty proof-text

    There’ve been a variety of discussions and arguments among Christians in the wake of Saddam Hussein’s execution about whether it’s proper for them to support capital punishment. Invariably, someone trots out Romans 13 as a proof-text for the pro-death penalty side of the argument:

    Let every person be subject to the governing authorities. For there is no authority except from God, and those that exist have been instituted by God. Therefore whoever resists the authorities resists what God has appointed, and those who resist will incur judgment. For rulers are not a terror to good conduct, but to bad. Would you have no fear of the one who is in authority? Then do what is good, and you will receive his approval, for he is God’s servant for your good. But if you do wrong, be afraid, for he does not bear the sword in vain. For he is the servant of God, an avenger who carries out God’s wrath on the wrongdoer. Therefore one must be in subjection, not only to avoid God’s wrath but also for the sake of conscience. For the same reason you also pay taxes, for the authorities are ministers of God, attending to this very thing. Pay to all what is owed to them: taxes to whom taxes are owed, revenue to whom revenue is owed, respect to whom respect is owed, honor to whom honor is owed.

    Verse 4 in particular is frequently appealed to as the clincher: “for he is God’s servant for your good. But if you do wrong, be afraid, for he does not bear the sword in vain. For he is the servant of God, an avenger who carries out God’s wrath on the wrongdoer.”

    First off, I think there’s legitimate room for disagreement about what “bearing the sword” means in this context. Does it refer explicitly to capital punishment, or is “the sword” a more general symbol of earthly authority? Presumably this has been hashed out by people far better informed than me.

    But, even assuming that v. 4 does refer to capital punishment, are the folks who use this as an argument for Christian acceptance of the death penalty prepared to bite the bullett and accept the political stance that seems implied by the passage as a whole? As has often been pointed out, Rom. 13 seems to encourage a stance of extreme submission to the existing political authorities. At the very least this would seem to rule out any kind of armed rebellion against the state. Are we prepared to repudiate the American revolution, say, in order to endorse the principle of “be[ing] subject to the governing authorities”?

    Some theologians have argued that Paul is only referring to legitimate authorites whose rule is in harmony with the moral law, but that seems like a forced reading of the passage to say the least. So, it seems to me we’re forced, for the sake of consistency, not to appeal to it as a justification of capital punishment unless we’re prepared to assent to the teaching of the entire passage. I certainly don’t recall hearing too many pro-death penalty Christians repudiating the principles of 1776, but I’m open to correction.

    Moreover, the point of the passage hardly seems to be to encourage Christians to support the death penalty within the empire, or petition for its frequent use. It looks a lot more like Paul is telling the Roman Christians to live in such a way as to be blameless before men and God. It’s about how they should act, not how the state should organize its criminal justice system.

  • Reporting from the road

    I’m in Atlanta, traveling for work, which, ironically, gives me more time to blog since I’m sitting here in a hotel room by myself with nothing to do. Interestingly, I seem to be here at the same time that this is going on, so my hotel is full of well-scrubbed Baptist kids walking around with Bibles. Not that there’s anything wrong with that; it’s just kind of surreal – no one in the northeast walks around carrying a Bible. But if any of them try to evangelize me I’ll just brandish my Book of Common Prayer to ward them off.

    On the plane I started reading P.D. James’s The Children of Men. Very gripping and full of Christian themes. Dystopian science fiction is my favorite variety. It’s the first book of hers I’ve read, but I think I recall reading somewhere that James is an Anglican; she certainly takes some shots at modern watered-down versions of Christianity. And some of the heroes are explicitly Christian in their motivation. I wonder how much of that the new movie retains.

    We don’t have cable tv, so whenever I’m staying in a hotel I’m always astonished at how shallow and sensationalistic cable news is. I watched about 5 minutes of the Lou Dobbs show, which seems to be an extended exercise in xenophobia; all of America’s problems, it seems, are caused by foreigners – foreigners overseas who want to take our jobs, or foreigners coming here. Then the inevitable Wolf Blitzer’s show came on. The one spot of serious analysis was when Blitzer had the NYT’s John Burns reporting from Iraq on what a mess the whole Saddam execution debacle has become. Regardless of your views on the death penalty, it’s pretty hard at this point to see it as a victory for democracy or the rule of law, much less a victory for the U.S.

    I also watched a bit of the Gerald Ford funeral coverage. Interesting that he and Jimmy Carter became such close friends (at least to hear President Carter tell it). It’s pretty hard to imagine that happening now – Carter said that he used to give Ford regular briefings on his foreign and domestic policy! I’m not one to get sentimental about presidents or the pomp of our civil quasi-religion, but Ford seems like he was a pretty decent guy. RIP.

    Not much else to report. I think I’m going to raid the mini-bar and get back to The Children of Men.

    P.S. For the record, no Gideon’s Bible in the rooms in the Atlanta Westin. I actually didn’t pack a Bible because I wanted to pack lightly and figured there’d be one in the room. I actually thought hotel-room Bibles were universal. Or is this just cut-rate chains? (Also for the record, hotels in Utah have Bibles and copies of the Book of Mormon.) Maybe I should track down one of those Baptist kids…

  • Prayer as remembrance

    Liturgical scholar Paul F. Bradshaw’s Two Ways of Praying argues for a reconnection between liturgy and spirituality which he contends have been separated in the Christian West. One of the reasons for this, he thinks, is that Christians have often been unclear about what exactly they’re doing when they pray. This is partly because there have been two “models” of liturgical prayer – the “cathedral” model which emphasizes communal praise and petition, and the “monastic” model which focuses on individual spiritual formation through prolonged meditation on biblical texts – which have not always been clearly distinguished and which call for different practices appropriate to their respective understandings of what prayer is for.

    Bradshaw’s point is not to argue for one form over the other, though he does seem to think that communal “cathedral” style praise has been neglected in favor of a more “monastic” understanding. But a balanced spiritual diet contains elements of both ways of praying. Meditative prayer such as lectio divina or praying the Rosary can and should co-exist with communal praise and petitionary prayer.

    The problem, Bradshaw thinks, is that the structure of various forms of liturgical prayer are often best suited for one form but are used for the other. For instance, the Daily Office in the Episcopal Book of Common Prayer is geared toward the recitation of the entire psalter and a more or less continuous reading of scripture. This makes it more suitable for a “monastic” approach to prayer emphasizing spritual formation through exposure to and meditation upon scripture over time. But the same form may be less well suited to the function of a service of congregational worship, which may be better served by the frequent use of particular psalms or the repetition of key passages of Scripture.

    One concept that Bradshaw introduces which I found enligtening is that of prayer as anamnesis, or remembering. He traces this to two distinct forms of biblical prayer, the berakah and the hodayah. Both of these prayer forms include a recounting and acknowledgement of God’s mighty acts which takes the form of praise. An example of the former comes from Exodus 18:10-11: “Blessed be the LORD, who has delivered you from the Egyptians and from Pharaoh. Now I know that the LORD is greater than all gods, because he delivered the people from the Egyptians, when they dealt arrogantly with them.” The hodayah, which comes from the Hebrew word hodah, meaning “thank” or “to acknowledge” or “to confess”. An example from Daniel, Chapter 2 runs “…To you, O God of my ancestors, I give thanks and praise, for you have given me wisdom and power, and have now revealed to me what we asked of you, for you have revealed to us what the king ordered.” The Berakah blesses God for what he has done and the Hodayah thanks God, but both are forms of praise rooted in the remembrance of what God has done.

    These prayers of remembrance function, according to Bradshaw, as ways by which worshippers interpret their experience in religious terms, or we might say, place themselves within God’s story. The also act as confession or acknowledgement of God, proclamation, and consecration of our lives to God. Petition then becomes a natural outgrowth of the acknowledgement and confession of God’s character. “[A]ny intercessions that are added to this nucleus are merely the explicit articulation of what is already implicit in the act of remembrance itself–the desire that God will continue the salvific activity that has been recalled, and hence sanctify those for whom prayer is made and draw all things back into a right relationship with God” (p. 50). This form of prayer continues in the New Testament, primarily in the prayers of Jesus and Paul.

    In Bradshaw’s view, this form of praying serves as an antidote to egocentric forms of prayer that consist primarily of our own needs and wants:

    A recovery of the richness of the biblical heritage of our prayer tradition, therefore, can rescure us from such a subjective and potentially egocentric perception and enable us to see that much more than expressing gratitude is involved in a eucharistic pattern of prayer. Recalling to mind what God has done, we are interpreting our human experience in religious terms; we are making our credal confession of faith; we are proclaiming our gospel to the world; we are restoring ourselves and all creation to a relationship of holiness to God; and all this not for ourselves but so that God may be glorified. (p. 55)

    Liturgical prayer is ideally suited for this precisely because it puts our own prayers in the broader context of the prayers and confession of the entire church. For instance, both the Anglican daily office and Luther’s Small Catechism incorporate the creed as a part of daily prayer. “Praying” the creed may seem counterintuitive at first, but when prayer is understood as remembrance of God’s salvific actions it makes a lot more sense. Likewise, the meditation on scripture familiarizes us with God’s story and helps us to interpret our own experience as part of that story. In fact, this is a helpful way to think about the liturgical year: we call to mind and recount what God has done for us, seek to be incorporated into that story, and anticipate its consummation.

    This understanding of prayer is why Bradshaw sees the need for a recovery of “cathedral” prayer. Praise and intercession are at the heart of cathedral prayer, as a response to “God’s gracious actions in the world” (p. 120). In contrast to “monastic” forms of prayer, he thinks this might require a more selective use of psalmody and scripture reading and a greater attention to the seasons of the liturgical year. Ultimately, though, he thinks that “monastic” and “cathedral” elements are necessary for a balanced Christian spirituality.

  • Jesus the Jew and Christian practice

    UPDATE: Welcome, readers of Theolog! I have responded to Jason Byassee’s comments here.

    Lutheran Zephyr and Derek the Ænglican already have good comments on this article by Amy-Jill Levine, a Jewish New Testament scholar at Vanderbilt Divinity School. Professor Levine argues for a stronger recognition of the essential Jewishness of Jesus by the Christian community, and sharply criticizes practices and rhetoric that define Jesus over against Judaism.

    She is certainly right, I think, that a lot of Christian talk still lapses into a lazy caricature of “Judaism” as Jesus’ foil. And, as Prof. Levine points out, progressives, feminists, and liberation theologians aren’t exempt from this. It’s obscene, for instance, when extreme anti-Israel rhetoric, which at times borders on the anti-Semitic, is served up in the name of Jesus.

    However, I also think LZ and Derek are both right that she seems to focus on the “Jesus of history” as normative for Christian faith in ways that are far from problem free. For instance, what are we to make of the claim that “preserving the fact that Jesus wore fringes [symbolizing the 613 commandmetns of the Torah], the New Testament mandates that respect for Jewish custom be maintained and that Jesus’ own Jewish practices be honored, even by the gentile church, which does not follow those customs”? Early on the church decided, for better or for worse, that keeping the Torah was not mandatory for Christians. So, it’s not clear what “mandting respect” for that practice would entail within the Christian community, apart from respecting the practices of our Jewish elder brothers and sisters in the faith.

    Or take Prof. Levine’s contention that “as for Jesus’ Jewish identity, neither he nor his Jewish associates would have mourned the loss of a herd of hogs—animals that are not kosher and that represent conspicuous consumption in that they cost more to raise than they produce in meat”? Does this mean that Christians, to take one of my personal hobbyhorses, are free to treat pigs and other un-kosher animals as having no dignity as creatures of God?

    What all of this gets at – and Derek, following Luke Timothy Johnson, highlights this point – is how difficult it is for Christians to simply take the “Jesus of history” (itself a problematic notion) as normative for their faith and practice in any straightforward way. First, as Derek also points out, the church has never confined Jesus’ influence to the example set by a historical figure 2,000 years ago, much less to the latest scholarly reconstruction. For Christian faith Jesus is first and foremost the living Lord whose Spirit continues to guide the church. Of course, that faith would be a mirage if the Jesus of history didn’t do and say the kinds of things recorded in the gospel accounts. But Christians aren’t committed to slavishly imitating all the details of Jesus’ life, even the religious details. That much was made clear at the Council of Jerusalem.

    This doesn’t mean that Jesus’ Jewishness is unimportant, and Prof. Levine is correct to warn against the kind of crypto-Marcionism that seems to be a recurrent temptation in the church. The Jewish tradition and the Hebrew Bible/Old Testament constitute the matrix out of which Jesus came and out of which our faith comes. But the ongoing tradition and experience of the church isn’t necessarily bound by the details of the Judaism of Jesus’ day, anymore than contemporary Rabbinic Judaism has to ape the Judaism of the 1st century.

    But, to say this also presents a challenge for contemporary Christians. Often the imitatio Christi is thought of in terms of simply copying the lifestyle of the historical Jesus (usually one favorite particular version), and this is sometimes presented as a superior alternative to the life of the institutional church. Or the Jesus of the gospels is treated as having ready-made answers to all of our moral dilemmas. If Christians believe in a risen Lord, though, attempting to mimic a 1st century Jewish rabbi, or wonder-working sage, or cynic philosopher, or whatever the Jesus du jour is, rather misses the point. One follows Jesus precisely by being incorporated into his body through partaking of the holy mysteries and hearing the Lord’s word. By being part of that body, we believe that we gradually, if haltingly, come to be formed according the pattern of Jesus, his life of self-giving service and love (again, I think L.T. Johnson is very good on this – see The Real Jesus and Living Jesus; both of these books had a big impact on me). In other words, why chase after a historical reconstruction when the living Jesus makes himself available to us here and now?

  • The year in book blogging

    Inspired by a post from Elliot, I thought it might be neat to collect in one post the year’s book blogging here at VI.

    January:

    Keith Ward, What the Bible Really Teaches (here, here and here)

    Rowan Greer, Christian Hope and Christian Life (here and here)

    Thomas Nagel, The Last Word (here and here)

    February:

    Austin Farrer, The Glass of Vision (here)

    Oswald Bayer, Living By Faith (here)

    March:

    No book blogging!

    April:

    Rod Dreher, Crunchy Cons (here)

    Gerald O’Collins, The Tripersonal God (here)

    May:

    Anders Nygren, The Essence of Christianity (here)

    Andrew Linzey, Animal Theology (here)

    June:

    Noam Chomsky, Hegemony or Survival (here)

    Paul Fiddes, Past Event and Present Salvation (here, here, and here)

    July:

    Stephen Finlan, Problems with Atonement (here)

    Bill Kauffman, Look Homeward, America (here)

    August:

    John MacQuarrie, Mary for all Christians (here, here, and here)

    Keith Ward, Pascal’s Fire (here, here, here, here, here, here, and here – whew!)

    David B. Hart, The Doors of the Sea (here)

    September:

    Keith Ward, Religion and Human Nature (here)

    October:

    Ward, Religion and Human Nature, continued (here)

    C.W. McPherson, Grace at This Time (here)

    November:

    Jon Sweeney, St. Francis Prayer Book (here)

    Henry Chadwick, History of the Early Church (here and here)

    Andrew Linzey and Richard Kirker (eds.), Gays and the Future of Anglicanism (here)

    December:

    Stephen R.L. Clark, The Political Animal (here)

    That’s no small amount of book blogging! Keith Ward clearly comes out as the most-blogged-about author this year at VI. Also, an impartial observer might point out that it wouldn’t hurt me to read more fiction.

  • Animal cloning and "granting things their space"

    I don’t suppose it’ll come as a surprise to anyone who reads this blog that I think that cloning animals for meat and milk is a bad idea. Leaving aside the health considerations, what bothers me is that it’s one more step in reducing animals (and, by implication, the rest of nature) to the status of commodities or resources which are entirely at our disposal. Animals are viewed as raw material to whom anything can be done in order to increase their productivity (and the profits that generates). Cloning is one more step away from the semi-mythical idyllic family farm toward the complete mechanization and industrialization of animal husbandry.

    In his interesting book Animals Like Us, philosopher Mark Rowlands argues that this instrumentalist view of animals (and nature) has implications in the way we treat other human beings. Seeing the world around us as fundamentally a resource for our use has a “spillover” effect in our perceptions of the value of persons. “This is the logical culmination of the resource-based view of nature: humans are part of nature, and therefore humans are resources too. And whenever something – human or otherwise – is viewed primarily as a resource, things generally don’t go well for it” (p. 196)

    It’s hard not to see similarities in the application of cloning to the meat industry and the application of similar technologies to human beings. Embryos – i.e. nascent human life – are turned into a commodity to be used either for reproductive technologies or for scientific research. Lauadable as the goals of some of these enterprises may be, the instrumentalization of human life is disturbing. And one of the reasons it’s so disturbing is that we have a hard time articulating why we find these sorts of things disturbing. Our public language of costs and benefits doesn’t incorporate values that may transcend the starkly utilitarian. Satifsying people’s felt needs (e.g. for cheaper meat; or, perhaps more accurately, for greater meat industry profits) without creating tangible harm to people’s health is all the government spokesmen permit themselves to be concerned with.

    This doesn’t mean that I think we should embrace the views of some extreme environmentalists that human beings have no special worth, or that it’s wrong for us to use nature for our benefit. I think a recovery of the sense of the natural world as God’s good creation would, if taken seriously, go a long way toward creating a more humble approach to our dealings with nature. For instance, we might come to see animals as having their own role in God’s providential ordering of the world, beyond being things which exist solely for our use. There are tantalizing hints in the Bible of God having a covenant, not just with human beings, but with all flesh (cf. Genesis 9)

    Expanding on this in his article “The Covenant with all Living Creatures,” philosopher Stephen R.L. Clark (about whose political philosophy I blogged a bit the other day) argues for taking the idea of just such a covenant seriously. Clark concludes:

    The covenant God made, we are told, in the beginning and affirmed since then, is to grant all things their space. `The mere fact that we exist proves his infinite and eternal love, for from all eternity he chose us from among an infinite number of possible beings’. Every thing we meet is also chosen: that is a good enough reason not to despise or hurt it.

    By “grant[ing] all things their space,” Clark means, among other things, allowing them to live “according to their kind.” This requires us to recognize that animals have their own telos, under God, that may be quite independent of our interests. To clone animals in order to make them “better” from the point of view of our purposes is, it seems to me, a pretty clear example of refusing to grant them their space.

  • A uniter, not a divider

    Gerald Ford, R.I.P.

    I’d say the pardoning of Nixon is outweighed by the fact that he presided over my birth, surely a great boon to the Republic.

    More substantively, he doesn’t seem to have done nearly as much active harm during my lifetime as a number other presidents I can think of. For one thing, he avoided war in the Middle East. And he did appoint John Paul Stevens to the Supreme Court, who is currently holding the line against some of the more unfortunate encroachment of executive power that the current administration favors.

    Of course, not having started any wars or presided over any massive expansion of government power, he fatally blew his chances of ever being ranked as a “great” or even “near-great” president by historians.

    P.S. On the other hand, I’m reminded that President Ford was the first to inflict both Dick Cheney and Donald Rumsfeld on the long-suffering American public.

  • Against keeping Christmas to ourselves

    Two worthy Christmas posts. First, from Siris:

    And so we see the significance of Christmas. Annunciation is the Feast of the Incarnation, the Word made flesh; Epiphany is the Feast of His manifestation to the world as flesh. But Christmas grabs us, seizes us, because it is the Feast of His Humility, that he did not regard equality with God something to hold tight, but emptied himself, taking the form of a servant, coming in human likeness, found in human appearance, humbling himself. God wrapped in a blanket, lying in a trough in some cave in a tiny little town because no one had room for him elsewhere; unheralded and unsung except by angels in the heavens and shepherds coming in from the fields. Luke knew what he was doing; what he wrote down was one of the most memorable religious images in all of history. It seizes the mind, overwhelms it, sets it alight, and moves it to action.

    This is why, incidentally, I am always wary about Christians criticizing people for celebrating Christmas, which we often do. We should not do this — no, not if they put up their lights and tree ten weeks early, nor if they listen to inane songs, or whatever other random fits of daffing with which they may go crazy. They are caught in the grip of an image that cannot be shaken; it inflames them with a fever that they can hardly bear. It grabs their hearts by their handles and pours them out until they are half-mad and all irritable from the strain of it. And, absurd as some of the festivities may be, the fire that lights them is a little bit contagious; even on the fringes, where people isolate themselves as much as possible from the religious side, one still feels its influences. It’s not always the healthiest madness, but it is a forgivable one. When Dionysius descends, can people not be caught up in the bacchanal? How can they hold back, and not romp in reverence? Is there nothing to be enthusiastic about in the celebration of God’s own humility, rich in giving, unashamed to be poor? By one gift beyond all expectation, we are inspired in our own myriad little ways, however faulty, however absurd. But if God was so humble that he did not shirk being a poor baby boy laid in a trough, we are called to the same humility; to humble ourselves in giving, and, failing that, to humble ourselves to those things others do that we deem foolish or absurd or tacky. God had to put up with your own folly and absurdity and tackiness, but He did not hesitate to endure it, and, more than endure it, associate Himself with it, if that’s what it took to bring you to light. And that’s what it took. We should all let the humility rub off on us a bit.

    And one from Connexions:

    The commercialism and materialism of Christmas is such a soft target, I almost wonder why we bother. If everyone agrees it’s wrong (At last! Something the whole church can agree about!) why do we bother talking about it? I want to suggest that even in the materialism of a modern Christmas, there’s a lesson for God’s people if we are willing to hear it.

    Christmas is a supremely materialistic festival. We celebrate the fact that God took human flesh — became incarnate — and lived among his people. He did not enter the world as a glorious heavenly being. He came as a baby, doing all the things that babies do. Forget the sentimental carols and Christmas cards. If the Christian gospel means anything at all, it is that “God is with us”. Through the incarnation, God takes fallen human flesh and makes it holy. I think it was Irenaeus who put it this way: “He became what we are, that we might become what he is.” So if ever there was a time to celebrate our flesh with eating, merrymaking and music — this is it! Christians should not be on the sidelines looking po-faced. We should be showing the world how to party!

    The real trouble is not with Christmas, but with the rest of the year. In the west we live every day as though it were a party. The reason we over-indulge to such excess at Christmas is that we over-indulge the rest of the year. The target of the church’s complaint should not be the materialism of Christmas, but the materialism of a lifestyle in which excess is not only lauded, it is practically compulsory.

    When I went through my thoroughly anti-religious phase, I still retained a love for Christmas, with its sense that, at least one night of the year, something magical and transcendent was possible. Maybe it was just sentimentality, but presumably God can take natural sentiment and transpose it into something more significant. For a lot of people, that little spark may be all they have, but surely part of the job of the church is to fan those sparks into flames of faith and love whenever that’s possible.

    I’m not really in favor of the attitude that simply asks secular people to leave religion to “us” religious people and stop co-opting “our” holidays. For one thing, secularism is, at least in part, the offspring of Chrstendom, and Christians can’t simply disown it and disavow any responsibility for it. If nothing else, a society thoroughly purged of its Christian residue is likely to be far worse than what we have now, with all its compromises and half-measures. And secondly, doesn’t the church exist for the world rather than to provide a religious club for like-minded members? I’ve always liked the parable of the sower, who promiscuously spreads his seed to take root where it will. And that has always seemed to me like a pretty decent image for what the church should be up to.

    I’d wager that it’s when Christians really celebrate Christmas with the joy appropriate to the occasion, rather than acting like sour-faced scolds, that non-Christians, marginal Christians, half-Christians, and “cultural” Christians will be drawn into the fullness of life that we believe is possible when God comes near us, as he did in the Incarnation of his beloved Son.

    Happy Christmas to all, and to all a good night!

  • Will the last Christians to leave the Middle East turn out the lights?

    Christians in the Middle East are being put at risk by the “short-sighted” and “ignorant” policy on Iraq of Britain and its allies, the leader of the world’s Anglicans has said.

    Doctor Rowan Williams, the Archbishop of Canterbury, warned Saturday that Christians could be chased out of the region due the hostility created by the invasion of Iraq, in an article for The Times newspaper.

    The Church of England leader accused coalition countries of endangering the lives and futures of thousands of Christians in the Middle East, who were now being viewed by their countrymen as “supporters of the crusading West”.

    He said that despite concerns being voiced in the build-up to the March 2003 US-led invasion of Iraq, there was plainly no strategy for handling the risk that Middle Eastern Christians would be put under.

    More here. Abp. Williams’ original article here.

    Arab Christians obviously find themselves in a very tough situation – caught between Islamist elements in the Middle East, and western military powers for whom they’re largely invisible, or potential enemies. Abp. Williams has some thoughts on how western Christians might practically improve the situation of our brothers and sisters in the Middle East.