A couple of weeks ago I said I was really digging the new album “The Infection” by Chimaira. Here’s the first video off that album.
Vodpod videos no longer available.
A while back I complained that I was never able to get into Radiohead’s post-OK Computer output. My beef was that they had sacrificed songwriting for noodly, experimental electronica.
Well, I decided to give ’em another shot and downloaded In Rainbows. Verdict: an amazing, surprisingly accessible synthesis of Radioheads past.
Liberal Democrats in Congress, starting to get uncomfortable with President Obama’s escalation in Afghanistan:
[…]American troop levels and war costs in Afghanistan will soar in the coming year, and party leaders, including Representative David R. Obey of Wisconsin, the House Appropriations Committee chairman, have warned that Democrats will most likely give the administration just one more year to get a handle on the military situation there before they start losing patience.
Mr. Obey said he would give the White House a year to demonstrate progress, just as he gave the Nixon administration a year to show progress in the Vietnam War inherited from the Johnson administration.
“With respect to Afghanistan and Pakistan, I am extremely dubious that the administration will be able to accomplish what it wants to accomplish,” Mr. Obey said last week. “The problem is not the administration’s policy or its goals. The problem is that I doubt that we have the tools there that we need to implement virtually any policy in that region.”
Mr. Obey, who entered Congress in 1969, added: “At the end of the year, Nixon had not moved the policy, and so I began to oppose the war. I am following that same approach here.”
It would be a real shame if Obama ended up the Democrats’ Nixon.
Interesting review of a new book portraying behavior of animals that can fairly be described as moral (via). I think our resistance to seeing animals as in any way “moral” might be rooted in the Kantian legacy of modern moral philosophy. Roughly, for Kant, you’re only acting morally when you’re acting for the sake of the moral law, and in opposition to some natural inclination. By contrast, the Aristotelian tradition says that a moral agent is someone with the dispositions toward and habits of performing virtuous action. By that standard, many non-human animals would count as virtuous.
UPDATE: See John’s post here. I did speak hastily in characterizing Kant; acting morally for Kant doesn’t necessarily require acting in opposition to a natural inclination, but rather for the sake of the moral law (though there does seem to be something especially virtuous about doing what duty demands even when we have a strong inclination not to). John also points out that Aristotle is closer to Kant here than my post makes it sound.
An excerpt from Keith Ward’s Why There Almost Certainly Is a God, a response to Richard Dawkins. (In Ward’s defense, he’s been debating Dawkins for years, so this isn’t cheap bandwagon jumping.)
The world of philosophy, of resolute thought about the ultimate nature of things, is a very varied one, and there is no one philosophical view that has the agreement of all competent philosophers. But in this world there are very few materialists, who think we can know that mind is reducible to electrochemical activity in the brain, or is a surprising and unexpected product of purely material processes.
In the world of modern philosophy, there are idealists, theists, phenomenalists, common sense pragmatists, scientific realists, sceptics and materialists. These are all going concerns, living philosophical theories of what is ultimately real. This observation does not settle any arguments. But it puts Dawkins’ ‘alternative hypothesis’ in perspective. He is setting out to defend a very recent, highly contentious, minority philosophical world-view. Good. That is the sort of thing we like to see in philosophy! But it will take a lot of sophisticated argument to make it convincing. It is not at all obvious.
Though this is only an excerpt, I think the objection an atheist would naturally raise is that, even if most of history’s great philosophers have been idealists (in the sense of believing that reality has something mind-like as at least one of its most fundamental constituents), we now think that many things can be explained without appealing to consciousness or purpose. Not that I think that’s a knock-down argument by any means, but it’s a challenge that needs to be addressed (and I assume Ward addresses it in the book).
The estimable John Schwenkler has pulled up roots and moved his “Upturned Earth” blog (along with co-blogger J.L. Wall) over to The American Conservative‘s site. Congrats to John for the move and to the American Conservative for a smart choice.
Rev. Thomas Williams, an Episcopal priest and distinguished philosopher, ably dismantles some of the cruder anti-Anselm polemics that blame his theory of the Atonement for, well, pretty much everything bad in Christian history.
Great post from Jim Henley commenting on this post at the Atlantic.
Fisher, I think, overstates the case of how hard it is to be vegan. Not that I am one, but it certainly doesn’t require the heroic level of asceticism he suggests. I mean, I’m a mere lacto-ovo veggie, but, at this point, it’s really easy. Yes, there was a period of adjustment (learning new recipes, telling people, etc.), but now I’d actually have to go out of my way to eat meat. Moreover, I eat well and healthily – mine is hardly an ascetic lifestyle. So, I have a hard time imagining that eliminating dairy and eggs would be that much harder.
As it happens, I recently read Jeffrey Masson’s The Face On Your Plate, which makes the case for veganism particularly well. There’s a strong case to be made that factory farmed dairy and eggs are actually worse than meat, from the perspective of animal suffering. Even their free range alternatives involve some highly questionable practices. Masson’s book definitely made me think more seriously about taking that next step…