Category: Theology & Faith

  • Sex and the modern Lutheran

    You may not have noticed that the ELCA has released a draft of a new social statement on sexuality, which you can read here. The Journal of Lutheran Ethics has several responses here. After a period of comment and feedback, the social statement will be taken up for official endorsement at the 2009 churchwide assembly.

    I haven’t read the whole thing closely, but on a first read-through it strikes me as pretty good, especially for something that I assume was written by committee. In particular I like how it roots our sexual ethics in incarnation and justification rather than creation alone. I also appreciate the way it develops the themes of neighbor-love and trust, which are hallowed Lutheran themes that have nevertheless taken a backseat in Lutheran social thought to other concepts like “orders of creation.” The statement does lose its focus at times and almost turns into a bit of a laundry list, but overall it’s not bad.

    Of course, the most scrutinized section will be the one on same-sex relationships, but the statement doesn’t break any new ground here. It recognizes that there isn’t consensus in the church, but upholds the principle of welcoming people of all sexual orientations into the church and of advocating for their legal rights. It also recognizes the facts on the ground – that pastoral responses to to gay and lesbian Christians will vary. This all strikes me as a pretty accurate picture of where the ELCA currently is.

    Moreover, I don’t know how much value there would be in engaging in a lot of political manuevering to get a resolution through the churchwide assembly that would radically alter the status quo. Until there’s consensus in the church, a relatively decentralized, laissez-faire approach seems best. Though, I realize this doesn’t address the question of LGBT candidates for ordained ministry, who will have to rely on “extraordinary” calls until the church changes the policy on ordination. If I were to advocate for a change at this point it would be there.

    Another thing: as much as I’m tempted to bash the ELCA at times, the church, more than some other mainline denominations perhaps, remains very Christocentric in its theology and in its social and ethical thought. For all its occasional PC excess, I’ve never seen in the ELCA much of a thirst for Spongian flights of theological fancy. Of course, it’s possible I haven’t been looking hard enough. (Or maybe it’s because being a Lutheran bishop has never been as sexy as being an Episcopal one, so there’s no point in staying on board if you don’t really believe this stuff.)

  • True patriotism

    I’m reading Walter Wink’s book The Powers that Be, an abridgement of sorts of his “powers” trilogy, and came across this quote, which seems somewhat appropriate in the wake of the Obama/Jeremiah Wright flap, but also of more general application:

    I love my country passionately; that is why I want to see it do right. There is a valid place for sensible patriotism. But from a Christian point of view, true patriotism acknowledges God’s sovereignty over all the nations, and holds a healthy respect for God’s judgments on the pretensions of any power that seeks to impose its will on others. There is a place for a sense of destiny as a nation. But it can be authentically pursued only if we separate ourselves from the legacy of the myth of redemptive violence and struggle to face the evil within ourselves. There is a divine vocation for the United States (and every other nation) to perform in human affairs. But it can perform that task, paradoxically, only by abandoning its messianic pretensions and accepting a more limited role within the family of nations. (p. 62)

  • An end to sacrifices

    I just finished reading James Alison’s Undergoing God, and the more I read of him the more I like him and think he’s onto something important. Alison, to recap, is a student of anthropologist/literary theorist Rene Girard, who has proposed a rather daring new interpretation of Jesus’ death on the cross.

    For Girard human selves and human desire are structured by what he calls mimesis, which means that we learn to want things by seeing other people want them. The problem is that mimesis all to often takes a rivalrous form: I want what you want which creates competition and potentially conflict.

    This conflict can threaten to unravel the fabric of human society, but societies have found a way to defuse that conflict, at least in the short run. They do this by means of what Girard calls the scapegoat mechanism. When rivalrous conflict gets out of hand, the members of a group will settle on someone who becomes the focus of the group’s “wrath.” This someone – the scapegoat – is “expelled,” often murderously, and this expulsion restores harmony by creating the feeling that the source of conflict has been banished.

    What Girard argues is that the history of myth and religion repeatedly display attempts to cover over these expulsions of the innocent. The myths and rituals of sacrifice to appease god or the gods invest the scapegoat mechanism with sacred legitimacy. Thus we invest the victim with sacred power and authority, since the expulsion is that which reestablishes harmony. We cover up our crime of killing the innocent by turning it into a “necessary” part of a divinely ordained order.

    However, says Girard, the Bible “unmasks” this sacred lie by presenting the victim as unambiguously innocent. The death of Jesus, as recorded in the gospels, most clearly reveals the mendacity of the scapegoat mechanism. When the Roman and Jewish authorities come together to kill Jesus the gospels leave no doubt that it’s an act of murder, even though it’s rationalized by various parties as a means of restoring order (see especially Girard’s excellent I See Satan Fall Like Lightning).

    Alison elaborates Girard’s line of thought in more explicitly theological terms. He contends that Jesus’ death and resurrection defeat the powers of violence and scapegoating by displaying those powers’ ultimate impotence. God, who comes to us in Jesus, is completely “other than” the death and violence according to which we have structured our life together. Jesus’ death, for Alison, doesn’t satisfy God’s wrath, but shows a God of unconditional love who is willing to occupy the place of utmost shame and weakness in order to break down our stony hearts. He absorbs our wrath.

    One of the reasons I find Alison’s approach is so appealing is that it shows the gospel as something genuinely new and radical. God isn’t caught up in the same economy of payback and tit-for-tat that we seem to be. He has nothing to do with that retributive scheme. The life, death, and resurrection of Jesus are an intrusion of a fundamentally different order into the one we have built for ourselves. And this intrusion, which is followed by the gifting of the Spirit, allows us to learn to participate in this new way of being.

    Jesus, who comes to us as the “forgiving victim,” enables us to live in a way that doesn’t depend on defining ourselves over against others. And doesn’t depend on sacrificing others to our desire for security. When we live with the understanding that God is unconditionally for us, we can gradually learn to let go of the fear that makes violence and sacrifice seem necessary in the first place.

    As an anthropologist and student of texts, Girard seems to see the implications of his theory being primarily for human society, ethics, and politics. And Alison more or less follows him here; the “new creation” that we’re being invitied to participate in seems chiefly characterized by transformed relationships between human beings. As a gay Catholic, Alison deploys these insights to powerful effect in thinking about how the church has victimized gay people but also about how all Christians can begin to live together in ways that don’t depend on defining “in” and “out” groups.

    Important as this work is, I’d also like to see this line of thought developed in a way that takes into account our relationship with the non-human world. After all, if God is the creator of all that is, his redemptive action presumably has implications for the entire world, not just us. Moreover, it’s no secret that the victims of sacrifice have often been our non-human fellow creatures. The scapegoat was originally, after all, a goat. Is there good news for him here too? And for us with respect to our felt need to dominate the non-human world?

    It’s more than a little ironic that we in the “enlightened” modern world subject animals to suffering and death on a scale that might well have made priests of the most blood-soaked cults of the ancient world blush. For us, animals have long represented both the “base” part of our nature (instinct, lust, violence) and, paradoxically, pure unspoiled nature. Consequently, we project both our fears and desires onto them, investing them with a kind of mythical power. At the same time we reduce them to commodities in our industrial systems of food, entertainment, and science. On a Girardian reading, we inflict violence on them because it’s what we think we have to do to get by in this world, to suppress our fears of our own violence and to assuage our fears of death and of being victimized.

    But if Girard and Alison are right, then the death of Jesus shows us that there is no “necessary” violence. Because God loves us unconditionally, and because that love has the last word in a universe seemingly characterized by confict, enmity, and the struggle to get ahead and be on top, we can learn to let go of the need to secure our place in this world by means of violence. We don’t need to sacrifice animals to the “gods” of appetite, safety, health, and science. We can trust that God will hold us in being and that we can even occupy the “place of shame” without losing ourselves. Moreover, as the theologian Stephen Webb has argued, we can be free to make friends with the animals. Just as Jeus is the agent of reconciliation among humans, he is the agent of reconciliation between humans and the rest of creation.

  • Thoughts for Good Friday

    “Christ’s death on the cross and his descent into Hell … reassure us that we can never wander so far astray as to be outside the humanity with which Christ has identified.” – William Placher

    “Jesus came to forgive sin unconditionally for God. Our sin, our unbelief, consists precisely in the fact that we cannot and will not tolerate such forgiveness. So we move to kill him. There is nothing for him to do then but to die ‘for our sins,’ ‘on our behalf,’ ‘give his life as a ransom for many.’ For him to stop and ask us to ‘shape up’ would be to deny the forgiveness he came to give, to put conditions on the unconditional. Thus he must ‘bear our sins in his body’—not theoretically in some fashion, but actually. He is beaten, spit upon, mocked, wasted.” – Gerhard Forde

    “Sin and death are brought to submission by the persistence of Christ’s love. All their forces are spent upon him, but he carries on loving. In the end the voices of the thief asking to be remembered in God’s kingdom, the forgiven soldier at the foot of the cross recognizing by Christ’s death that he is the Son of God, witness to love’s triumph.” – Stephen Cottrell

    “The single central thing is the conviction that for us to be at peace Jesus’ life had to be given up. It isn’t that a vengeful and inflexible God demands satisfaction, more that the way the world is makes it unavoidable that the way to our freedom lies through the self-giving of Jesus, even to the point of death. In the kind of world that you and I inhabit, the kind of world that you and I make or collude with, this is what the price of unrestricted love looks like.” – Rowan Williams

    “And what is this Gospel? It is nothing less than the conviction and experience that God loves the whole world. What we see in Jesus is the revelation of an inclusive, all-embracing, generous loving. A loving that washes the feet of the world. A loving that heals individuals from oppression, both physical and spiritual. A loving that takes sides with the poor, vulnerable, diseased, hated, despised, and outcasts of his day. A loving that is summed up in his absolute commitment to love at all costs, even in extreme suffering and death. As Sydney Evans once wrote, ‘What Jesus did on the Cross was to demonstrate the truth of what he had taught: he showed a quality of love—such that the worst that evil could do to such love was to give such love ever fresh opportunities for loving.’” – Andrew Linzey

    “The kenosis, or self-emptying, of Jesus, which expresses in historical time the kenosis, the long-suffering of God, is the sacrifice which makes possible the theosis, or raising to God of human life, enabling it to share in the eternal life of a God of limitless love.” – Keith Ward

    “God in Christ crucified cancels the curse of human vulnerability to horrors. For the very horrors, participation in which threatened to undo the positive value of created personality, now become secure points of identification with the crucified God. To paraphrase St. Paul, neither the very worst humans can suffer, nor the most abominable things we can do can separate us from the love of God in Christ Jesus (Rom. 8:31-39).” – Marilyn McCord Adams

    “The cross of Christ was not an inexplicable or chance event, which happened to strike [Jesus], like illness or accident. To accept the cross as his destiny, to move toward it and even to provoke it, when he could well have done otherwise, was Jesus’ constantly reiterated free choice. He warns his disciples lest their embarking on the same path be less conscious of its costs (Luke 14:25-33). The cross of Calvary was not a difficult family situation, nor a frustration of visions of personal fulfillment, a crushing debt, or a nagging in-law; it was the political, legally-to-be-expected result of a moral clash with the powers ruling his society.” – John Howard Yoder

    “That God, out of love and concern for us, would so humble Godself as to unite Godself with not just lowly humanity but humanity in the most dire straits—that is the sacrifice, made by God in Christ on our behalf, in death as over the course of Jesus’ whole life.” – Kathryn Tanner

    “God’s forgiveness is indiscriminate. That’s the bedrock conviction of the Christian faith. ‘One has died for all,’ wrote the apostle Paul (2 Corinthians 5:14). That simple claim has immense implications. All means all, without exception. There are no people who are sufficiently good so that God doesn’t need to forgive them and Christ didn’t die for them. There are no people who are too wicked for God to forgive them and for Christ to die for them. And there are no people whom God, for some inscrutable reason, decided not to forgive.” – Miroslav Volf

    “The taking on of the servile and sinful human condition, as foretold in Second Isaiah, is presented by Paul as an act of voluntary impoverishment: ‘For you know how generous our Lord Jesus Christ has been: He was rich, yet for your sake he became poor, so that through his poverty you might become rich’ (2 Cor. 8:9). This is the humiliation of Christ, his kenosis (Phil. 2:6-11). But he does not take on the human sinful condition and its consequences to idealize it. It is rather because of love for and solidarity with others who suffer in it. It is to redeem them from their sin and to enrich them with his poverty. It is to struggle against human selfishness and everything that divides persons and allows there to be rich and poor, possessors and dispossessed, oppressors and oppressed.” – Gustavo Gutierrez

    “Because Jesus is at once the ‘yes’ of God to humans in fidelity and also humanity’s ‘yes’ to God in faith, we are lifted into a higher life than we could ever imagine, a sharing in the life—and the eternal dance of gifts given and received—of the triune God.” – Luke Timothy Johnson

    “[W]hat was really exciting to Paul was that it was obvious from Jesus’ self-giving, and the ‘out-pouring of Jesus’ blood,’ that this was the revelation of who God was: God was entirely without vengeance, entirely without substitutionary tricks; and that he was giving himself entirely without ambivalence and ambiguity for us, towards us, in order to set us ‘free from our sins’—‘our sins’ being our way of being bound up with each other in death, vengeance, violence and what is commonly called ‘wrath.’” – James Alison

    “Because [Jesus] died for us, we never die alone without representation, without hope for personal identity beyond the grave. We will never have to die alone on a Godforsaken hill outside the gate. We can die in a communion of his love, in the assurance of the forgiveness of sins, with undying hope for resurrection and eternal life. Because Jesus died the death of the sinner as the sinless one, assuming our lot by his love, he can be our representative. Because he died the death under the law as the man of love, full of life to share and taking time for others, he can be our representative. He can be our representative because, in being raised from the dead, he was approved by God as having the right credentials to be the ambassador of the human race. — Carl Braaten

    Love bade me welcome: yet my soul drew back,
    Guilty of dust and sin.
    But quick-eyed Love, observing me grow slack
    From my first entrance in,
    Drew nearer to me, sweetly questioning,
    If I lacked anything.
    A guest, I answered, worthy to be here:
    Love said, You shall be he.
    I the unkind, ungrateful? Ah my dear,
    I cannot look on thee.
    Love took my hand, and smiling did reply,
    Who made the eyes but I?
    Truth Lord, but I have marred them: let my shame
    Go where it doth deserve.
    And know you not, says Love, who bore the blame?
    My dear, then I will serve.
    You must sit down, says Love, and taste my meat:
    So I did sit and eat.
    —George Herbert

  • Why resurrection?

    Slate has a pretty decent article on why resurrection, rather than the immortality of the soul, is the key Christian belief about life after death. Though I do sometimes think these two notions are needlessly set in opposition. It seems to me that the insistence of bodily resurrection qualifies a too spiritualistic idea of human life, but on the other hand, the NT, Paul in particular, is keen to qualify a too physicalistic notion of resurrection.

  • The progress delusion

    It’s become commonplace to observe that atheism can display many of the same traits as the religions it criticzes, but British political thinker John Gray is a master of exploring the quasi-religious themes in the myth-making of secular modernity, something he’s done for everything from communism, to global capitalism, to human uniqueness, to the idea of progress itself. Here he takes on the “new atheists” (via The Topmost Apple).

  • What I did on my winter vacation

    I wanted to say something about my trip to Germany. I stayed in Berlin, in what was formerly part of East Berlin, a neighborhood called Prenzlauer Berg. Under communism it was a locus for dissidents and artists but is now almost indistinguishable from trendy yuppie neighborhoods in DC or about a dozen other cities I could think of. My college buddy Patrick has been working as a reporter over there for about 7 years, so he hosted me and gave me the grand tour.

    Berlin’s a fascinating city for reasons almost too obvious to mention, with visible remnants of the imperial, Nazi, and Cold War eras intermingling alongside the modern post-1989 Berlin. Not far from the Reichstag there’s a sparkling new complex of ultra-contemporary glass and metal government buildings that spans the eastern and western parts of the city, symbolizing reunification and transparency in government. And capitalism has sprung up with a vengeance in what used to be the heart of socialist East Berlin; Communist-era apartment buildings house trendy shops and restaurants.

    I spent my days on long meandering walks through the city, visiting churches and museums, gawking at Stalinist-era architecture on “Karl Marx Allee,” checking out the remnants of the Berlin Wall, eating a lot of surprisingly good Italian food, visiting the graves of Dietrich Bonhoeffer and Hegel, and just trying to soak up the atmosphere. The nights were spent hanging out with Patrick and his motley assortment of ex-pat reporter friends (mostly Brits as it happens) and partaking liberally of the many fine beers Germany has to offer.

    On my second to last day there Patrick and I took a day trip to Wittenberg (or Lutherstadt Wittenberg, to use the official name). Unlike Berlin, which has relatively few traces of the pre-modern era, downtown Wittenberg still looks like a medieval village with its windy cobblestone streets lined with shops and presided over by the Castle hurch. That’s where Luther nailed up the 95 theses (now immortalized in bronze on the church door) and where he and Philipp Melancthon are buried. We also saw St. Mary’s, the parish church where Luther preached and where the first Protestant service was held, and which is still, I’m happy to say, a functioning parish. See pics here. We then spent some time at the house Luther and Katie lived in, a former monastery, which now houses the world’s largest Reformation museum, containing neat Reformation-era artifacts like the robe Luther preached in and a copy of an indulgence.

    I’ve been reading Alister McGrath’s recent book on Protestantism, and the differences he discusses between the iconoclastic Reformed protestants and the Lutherans are well-illustrated by Wittenberg. St. Mary’s church, far from being whitewashed and bereft of images like so many other Protestant churches were, still looks like a medieval church in a lot of ways. There is a beautiful altarpiece by Lucas Cranach illustrating the principles of the Lutheran reformation as well as other highly pictoral and symbolic art around the inside of the church. McGrath suggests that Reformed Christians might have felt the nead to “cleanse” the churches of their imagery not only because of a rigorist reading of the second commandment, but to break decisively with the catholic past. However, he says, the human urge and need to use images to depict the transcendent was too strong to be suppressed permanently. Luther seems to have recognized this with his affirmation of religious art and music as both catechetical tools and means for praising God.

    The last six months have definitely been a spritual dry spell for me. Pracitces of daily devotion have gone out the window, I’ve missed church more times than I’d care to admit, and there have been at least one or two times when I’d seriously considered hanging up the whole business. But I did feel a connection being there at the birthplace of Protestantism, similar to what I’d felt at the catacombs in Rome a couple of years ago: a sense of being a link in a chain stretching back centuries. I’m not sure just feeling like part of a tradition is sufficient for the life of faith, but it’s something. And Luther himself was no stranger to doubt, after all.

    Anyway, the best part of the whole trip, really, was just getting to spend a lot of time hanging out with an old friend, doing the things we used to do in college: talk about love and relationships, argue about politics, and joke around. Most of my longtime friends are scattered to the four winds these days and quality time is hard to come by. I’ve moved around a lot over the last 10 years and have found, unsurprisingly, that it can get really tough to maintain those close friendships. In college in particular you spend a lot of time with your friends, an experience it’s hard to replicate in the “real world.” (I’ve even heard it suggested that the reason people look back so fondly on college is because it’s the closest most of us come to the experience of living in primate packs, which is likely the kind of social environment we evolved in.) So it was nice to relive it a little bit, even if we’re all a bit older and wrinklier than we were then.