Catholic Obama supporter Melinda Henneberger makes the case against the “Freedom of Choice Act” (FOCA), which, it appears, could result in Catholic hosptials (a third of all hospitals in the US, according to Henneberger) shutting their doors rather than being forced to provide abortions. Many of these hospitals rely on Medicade and Medicare funds to keep operating, and FOCA would require recipients of federal funds to provide abortion services. On top of that, FOCA would make it even harder to come to some kind of political compromise on abortion than it already is, as it would sweep aside existing restrictions.
Category: Politics
-
Of Palin and poultry
I’m with Jim Henley – there’s nothing particularly disturbing about this Sarah Palin interview at a turkey farm (well, except insofar as Sarah Palin is inherently disturbing). Where exactly do people think Thanksgiving turkeys come from?
Jim’s also right that the farm where the interview takes place is, by all appearances, far more humane than, say, this.
I did find it grimly amusing how the MSNBC anchor introduced the clip by saying that the video had been “sanitized” as much as possible, but that parents might want to have kids leave the room, etc. If animal slaughter is so unspeakably horrible, maybe there’s something, y’know, wrong with it? At the very least, isn’t there a problem if you think that our food production process is so awful that it needs to be shielded from public view?
-
Mainline on the sidelines
Political theorist/theologian Charles Mathewes reviews a book on the public witness of the mainline and its decline. He makes what seems to me a crucial point: the ineffectiveness of much of the mainline is in large part a function of the fact that the denominational bureaucracies often don’t represent the people in the pews. And DC polciy makers know this. (The comparison with the Religious Right, Mathewes says, is instructive; politicians paid attention to Jerry Falwell because they knew he spoke for a large constituency.)
This points, according to Mathewes to a fundamental problem with the mainline denominations: they see themselves as speaking to the public at large rather than to the people in their congregations. Thus Christian formation is not a priority. This may be a legacy of the mainline’s former status as the de facto establishment; you didn’t need to form Christians when everyone was more or less Christian by default. (Or at least it could seem that way, but see, inter alia, the works of Søren Kierkegaard!)
Whatever you might want to say about the merits of that situation, though, it no longer obtains. Consequently, mainline churches need to be much more intentional about Christian formation. Incidentally, I don’t see this as meaning that the mainline should become more “conservative.” Rather that they should become more Christian. That means immersing its members in prayer, Bible study, Bible-based preaching, works of mercy, etc. The public witness of the churches would, then, grow organically out of this formation, rather than coming from top-down denominational diktats.
-
Less Friedman, more Schumacher
Patrick Deneen calls for an economic re-thinking on the Right.
It remains to be seen, I think, whether the Right or the Left will be the first to seriously re-examine the assumptions underlying an unlimited growth/unlimited consumption economy.
The Left has a long history of attending to social justice issues and questions of equality, but, at least in the US, this has usually gone hand-in-hand with a commitment to an ever-expanding economy (partly to underwrite its social welfare programs, partly to expand the benefits of economic growth to those left out).
Personally, I think we’re going to need the Right’s sense of limits and trade-offs and the Left’s passion for social justice and equality in order to craft a social and economic order that is capable of weathering the end of the cheap energy era.
Unfortunately, the Right is currently in a state of disarray with most of its hardcore supporters looking to double down on the true Reaganite faith, with an extra dose of culture war vehemence (Palin 2012!).
Meanwhile, there are signs that the Obama administration is going to end up being staffed by many of the old Clintonite, “third way,” neo-liberal hands who, to put it mildly, don’t seem like the best candidates for re-evaluating the fundamental basis of our economy.
-
Prospects for conservatives, “left” and otherwise
Russell Arben Fox has a thoughtful meditation on the prospects for his brand of “left conservatism” in a bluer America. Hard to believe that we were talking about a permanent Republican majority four years ago. All the more reason to be wary of overconfident (or dire, depending on your view) pronouncements about the triumph of liberalism. In politics there are no permanent victories; I fully expect a conservative resurgence at some point (though hopefully only after it’s had sufficient time to sit in the corner and think about what it’s done). In that vein, John has some thoughts on conservatism’s future that are worth checking out.