No insightful legal analyis from these quarters (I know enough lawyers to know how out of my depth I’d be), but, boy howdy, the nomination of Judge Sotomayor to the SCOTUS sure is bringing out the best in the conservative movement and the GOP, isn’t it?
Category: Politics
-
Republican demagoguery and Democratic pusillanimity
Well, what else is new? The American Conservative‘s indispensable Kelley Vlahos on the Gitmo mess.
-
Alternate universes
Michael Lind:
Suppose that in an alternate Rod Serling universe our other-dimensional twins paid for Pentagon spending on the basis of a dedicated national consumption tax, while they paid for Social Security and Medicare out of general taxation. In that case, opponents of Pentagon spending might have a field day denouncing the gap between the estimated federal consumption tax revenues in, oh, let’s say, 2050 and the military threats they estimate that the U.S. will face in half a century. But in this “Twilight Zone” America, neither Social Security nor Medicare, lacking dedicated taxes, would have “unfunded liabilities” any more than the Pentagon does in our world.
Read the rest here.
-
The other war
Liberal Democrats in Congress, starting to get uncomfortable with President Obama’s escalation in Afghanistan:
[…]American troop levels and war costs in Afghanistan will soar in the coming year, and party leaders, including Representative David R. Obey of Wisconsin, the House Appropriations Committee chairman, have warned that Democrats will most likely give the administration just one more year to get a handle on the military situation there before they start losing patience.
Mr. Obey said he would give the White House a year to demonstrate progress, just as he gave the Nixon administration a year to show progress in the Vietnam War inherited from the Johnson administration.
“With respect to Afghanistan and Pakistan, I am extremely dubious that the administration will be able to accomplish what it wants to accomplish,” Mr. Obey said last week. “The problem is not the administration’s policy or its goals. The problem is that I doubt that we have the tools there that we need to implement virtually any policy in that region.”
Mr. Obey, who entered Congress in 1969, added: “At the end of the year, Nixon had not moved the policy, and so I began to oppose the war. I am following that same approach here.”
It would be a real shame if Obama ended up the Democrats’ Nixon.
-
The psychology of torture
Marvin made the point in comments here that it’s depressing to even be arguing about the morality of torture. After all, the wrongness of torture is something we should all simply take for granted, and the fact that it’s become a contested topic says something really bad about where we are as a country. Personally, I have a hard time coming up with premises more basic than the wrongness of torture from which I could argue.
All of which makes me wonder: why is this coming up now? During the Cold War, when, by any objective measure, we were facing a much more dire threat, this was not an issue. Indeed, the US under President Reagan signed the UN Convention Against Torture, which prohibits torture or cruel and degrading treatment under all circumstances, including “war, threat of war, internal political instability, public emergency, terrorist acts, violent crime, or any form of armed conflict,” according to Wikipedia.
Which is not to say torture never occurred, whether committed by us or our proxies. But was anyone publicly arguing that torture was the right thing to do? Even though the threat of a nuclear-armed Soviet Union was clearly far more serious when we signed the Convention Against Torture than the threat of radical Islamic terrorism is now, I’m guessing that 9/11 made a lot of people feel more vulnerable than they ever had before. Is that what makes torture seem, to some people, like a viable option?
UPDATE: See Glenn Greenwald, who makes some similar points better and at greater length. See – this is why I don’t blog about this stuff. 🙂
-
Global warming, food shortages, and … civilizational collapse?
I got to hear a talk the other day by Lester Brown, head of the Earth Policy Institute. He talked, among other things, about the relationship between global warming, food scarcity, and the geo-political instability that could result. Scary stuff. This article provides a summary of his ideas.
-
Souter’s out, according to the Times
I wondered why their were all those reporters hanging around the Supreme Court when I was out running this morning. Now I know.
-
You too can be a right-wing hack!
This piece at Reason.com is really kind of embarrassingly bad, but it does serve a useful purpose in collecting many of the right-wing anti-environment tropes in one place for easy reference:
Point out that environmentalists want to run your life and take away your money (they’re basically communists in other words).
Feign(?) misunderstanding of scientific claims (e.g., Those crazy greens think CO2 is a “pollutant” – but we exhale CO2, so obviously that can’t be right!).
Explain that environmentalists are Luddites who hate modern life and the blessings of capitalism.
Compare environmentalism to religion (n.b.: this is a bad thing).
Quote dubious figures from a corporate-backed “nonpartisan” think-tank about the catastrophic cost of addressing global warming.
Pretend to be for “sensible” and “common sense” (preferably “market-based”!) solutions to (nonexistent) environmental problems.
Optional: make disparaging reference to Al Gore.
You might want to print this out for easy reference in case you’re called upon to a) write an angry letter to the editor of your local newspaper about some positive coverage of Earth Day they ran, b) argue with someone in a blog comment thread, or c) write an op-ed for a major conservative or libertarian magazine/think-tank.