I was a young buck of 15 at the time, so naturally my memory of the events is filtered through rock music:
Jesus Jones, “Right Here, Right Now”
[Edited because of embedding issues.]
I was a young buck of 15 at the time, so naturally my memory of the events is filtered through rock music:
Jesus Jones, “Right Here, Right Now”
[Edited because of embedding issues.]
Ohioans will vote Tuesday on a measure to amend the state constitution and create a board of political appointees that will set standards for the treatment of farm animals. The problem, as this Mother Jones article spells out, is that any such board would be outside the normal rule-making process, immune from public comment, and is bound to be dominated by big agriculture interests, who have been the prime movers in getting this measure on the ballot.
The opposition–a loose coalition of small farmers, animal welfare groups, and even some small-government conservatives–argues that the measure would create a permanent place for special interests in the state constitution. Moreover, any measures to improve the conditions of farmed animals (like last year’s Proposition 2 in California) would have to amend the state constitution. Here’s a summary of their arguments. It’s very difficult to see this measure as anything but an attempt by a powerful and influential industry to insulate itself from pressure for reform.
In a Reason symposium on libertarianism and culture, Kerry Howley argues that libertarians should be concerned not just with minimizing government coercion, but with critiquing cultural barriers to human freedom. For instance, she points out that a woman trapped in a repressively patriarchal culture, or one that merely reinforces “traditional” gender roles, is hardly capable of fully exercising her freedom.
I agree with that. (Though I would demure at Ms. Howley’s insistence the the pill, porn, and 600 channels of TV are all on a par as examples of the “power of culture itself to liberate.”) But it’s no less true that someone who’s starving, or doesn’t have adequate access to health care, or doesn’t have clean air to breath or clean water to drink is incapable of fully exercising her freedom. Which is basically why, from J.S. Mill onward, most liberals have rejected laissez-faire in favor of some variety of state-action or welfare liberalism. In other words, valuing freedom is sometimes a good reason not to be a libertarian.
I’m sort of puzzled that the Whole Foods boycott (both the boycott itself and the controversy about the boycott) has gotten as much mileage as it has. I’m not the boycotting type myself, but the response still seems a bit disproportionate to me.
Suppose WF as a company was dedicating resources to opposing health care reform. That would be a good reason for reform supporters to boycott, it seems to me. But simply because of something the CEO wrote in an op-ed? Like I said, I don’t shop at WF, but it really has nothing to do with John Mackey’s politics.
Incidentally, I can only assume that those righteously boycotting WF have already contacted their representative and senators to urge them to vote for health care reform. ‘Cause that’s something that could actually make a difference.
But mostly because of the prices and intolerable smugness.
Link via JL Wall at Upturned Earth.