A Thinking Reed

"Man is but a reed, the most feeble thing in nature, but he is a thinking reed" – Blaise Pascal

The curious case of the shrill veg(etari)an

Great post from Jim Henley commenting on this post at the Atlantic.

Fisher, I think, overstates the case of how hard it is to be vegan. Not that I am one, but it certainly doesn’t require the heroic level of asceticism he suggests. I mean, I’m a mere lacto-ovo veggie, but, at this point, it’s really easy. Yes, there was a period of adjustment (learning new recipes, telling people, etc.), but now I’d actually have to go out of my way to eat meat. Moreover, I eat well and healthily – mine is hardly an ascetic lifestyle. So, I have a hard time imagining that eliminating dairy and eggs would be that much harder.

As it happens, I recently read Jeffrey Masson’s The Face On Your Plate, which makes the case for veganism particularly well. There’s a strong case to be made that factory farmed dairy and eggs are actually worse than meat, from the perspective of animal suffering. Even their free range alternatives involve some highly questionable practices. Masson’s book definitely made me think more seriously about taking that next step…

2 responses to “The curious case of the shrill veg(etari)an”

  1. I went vegan for Lent a few years ago, and I would say it’s a significant leap of difficulty past being vegetarian. Most restaurants nowadays have vegetarian options, but many have absolutely nothing for vegans. It’s hard to get food that really sticks to your ribs. And I wasn’t even that punctilious about it — I didn’t examine every baked good or pasta dish or whatever for hidden animal products, which they may well have had.

    This is not to discourage you from trying it — it’s just a little more complicated than vegetarianism minus a few things.

  2. Alright – fair enough, I was probably being a little glib. Still, Fish’s comparison’s seem over the top.

    (I don’t know if I’ll try the vegan thing; I’ve definitely reduced my dairy and egg consumption, but eliminating it altogtether would impose some serious inconvenience on me and others.)

Leave a reply to Camassia Cancel reply