A Thinking Reed

"Man is but a reed, the most feeble thing in nature, but he is a thinking reed" – Blaise Pascal

November/December reading notes

Also known as the lazy man’s book review, or capsule reflections on books I might not get around to posting on at greater length:

Ecology at the Heart of Faith by Denis Edwards and Nature Reborn: The Ecological and Cosmic Promise of Christian Theology by H. Paul Santmire

A Catholic (Edwards) and a Lutheran (Santmire) offer nicely complementary re-tellings of the Christian story that emphasize the cosmic and ecological context of God’s presence with us.

Religion and Human Fulfillment
by Keith Ward

Ward looks at controversial moral issues through the lens of various religious traditions (Christianity and sexuality, Islam and just war, Buddhism and beginning- and end-of-life issues, Judaism and religious vs. secular law); he defends a version of “transcendent personalism,” which holds that reason can discern right and wrong, but that belief in a transcendent source of being and goodness provides an extra impetus for the moral life.

God, Religion, and Reality
by Stephen R.L. Clark

A clever and idiosyncratic defense of traditional/classic theism, taking the view–unfashionable in both philosophical and theological circles–that reason can demonstrate the existence and attributes of God.

Rawls and Religion: A Defense of Political Liberalism by Daniel Dombrowski

The noted process philosopher/theologian argues for the essential compatibility of Rawlsian liberalism with robust religious commitment. He also addresses weaknesses in Rawls’ view regarding such issues as war and peace, abortion, and animal rights.

Loving Jesus by Mark Allan Powell

Powell, a Lutheran seminary professor and self-proclaimed “Jesus freak,” offers a “post-critical” piety that engages heart and head in “loving Jesus in a complicated world.” Very helpful reflections on prayer, personal devotions, stewardship, and spiritual growth that are neither overly abstract nor simplistic.

On deck:

Liberty: Rethinking an Imperiled Ideal by Glenn Tinder

The Word of Life: A Theology of John’s Gospel by Craig Koester

4 responses to “November/December reading notes”

  1. I read through the Dombrowski book for my MA (my research was on Rawls) and can remember that I was pretty unimpressed with the book.

    If you haven’t alreadt read it I’d recommend Michael Sandel’s Liberalism and the Limits of Justice.

  2. Yeah – I don’t think he really dug down deep enough into what bothers some critics about Rawls’ approach. In particular, I think he needed a much more in-depth discussion of the original position and Rawls’ two principles.

    Personally, I’ve always thought Rawlsianism had an excess of theoretical apparatus for relatively little payoff. I think there are better ways to get to (broadly) liberal conclusions.

    I read Sandel’s book when it first came out, so I’m a little fuzzy. In general, I think communitarians offer some valid critical correctives of liberalism, but I don’t think they’ve succeeded in offering a genuine alternative to liberalism.

  3. On the subject of Rawls yesterday I started reading Paul Graham’s introductory text imaginatively titled “Rawls” (Oneworld, 2007).

    Although an introductory text I have to admit i am impressed so far – Graham does focus on the two principles and the OP. I’ll post a review eventually.

    Also, not sure if you’re aware but last year (just!) Belknap press published Rawl’s lectures under the title “Lectures on the History of Political Philosophy” – I’ve not read it yet but have skimmed sections and it looks invaluable. I am hoping to read it soon to refresh me on the main thinkers of political philosophy.

  4. I saw the Graham book at Barnes & Noble today — it looked surprisingly readable. It’s been a long time since I’ve looked at ToJ (it sits menacingly on my shelf); maybe it’s time for a refresher.

Leave a reply to Lee Cancel reply