A Thinking Reed

"Man is but a reed, the most feeble thing in nature, but he is a thinking reed" – Blaise Pascal

Bad Protestant

I’m late posting on this obviously but last night I went to a Mass in honor of Our Lady’s Glorious Assumption. It was heart-breakingly beautiful in parts, set as it was to music from Mozart’s Spatzen-Messe, KV 220 (Those words mean nothing to me; I copied them directly from the bulletin. All I know is that the music was amazing).

Here I wrote that my theology had shifted away from Lutheranism over the last couple of years. One of the respects in which that’s the case is in my attitude toward devotion to the Blessed Virgin (and the Saints in general). I worked through the theological arguments to my own satisfaction some time ago, but more recently it’s become an increasingly important part of my own devotional life.

I know that there are Lutherans who accept devotion to Mary and the other Saints, but the fact of the matter is that it’s simply not part of the practice of any Lutheran church I’ve ever been to. At some point it becomes exhausting to try and maintain such practices without the support of a church community. Not that this would necessarily be a “deal-breaker” for me, but I like being part of a congregation that can pray the Ave together or sing “Ye Who Own the Faith of Jesus.”

3 responses to “Bad Protestant”

  1. That’s more or less what brought me to Independent Catholicism. I knew I could probably find other Lutherans who had the same extremely high-church liturgical commitments and fairly Catholic ecumenical commitments that I had, but at some point you want not to be fighting to build movements on three or four fronts in your home church! (All those things were more or less tolerated in the UCC, where I was sojourning at the time, but it was even less possible to put them together positively in community.)

    I do wish we Indies could put on Masses with old choral music more often, though — we usually don’t have the numbers. But I think I’ve talked my bishop into getting a group together to sing Byrd’s Mass for Three Voices! 😀

  2. This is an area I really struggle with. The pull of a place that venerates Mary is growing increasingly strong for me. As clergy, however, there is a whole other set of additional complications for pursuing that. I am glad that you have found a place that feeds you in this way. Man, if Lutherans only knew what we were all missing out on!

  3. Derek the Ænglican

    Welcome to the smoky side… 😀

Leave a reply to Derek the Ænglican Cancel reply