A Thinking Reed

"Man is but a reed, the most feeble thing in nature, but he is a thinking reed" – Blaise Pascal

Church shopping: update

I know I said earlier that we were thinking of reverting to Lutheranism, but after a couple of visits I have a feeling we’re going to end up at St. Paul’s Episcopal on K Street, a venerable Anglo-Catholic parish.

For me this is less about a particualr form of churchmanship than what seems to be a vibrant parish centered around Word and Sacrament, committed to beautiful and reverent worship, and serious about Christian formation and discipleship. Plus, the peoeple we’ve met have been very friendly and welcoming (even after learning that we’ve just come from the Church of the Advent in Boston who recently “stole” St. Paul’s Director of Music!).

If we end up here I think it may be time for me to consider being received into the Episcopal Church. I was never confirmed in the Lutheran Church (though I was a member of different congregations – I’m not exactly sure what the distinction is in the ELCA), and it seems like maybe I should commit to a church body. Obviously the Episcopal Church has its problems, but I can’t helpf but feel somewhat dishonest about continuing to be nourished by parish life without committing in a more formal way. Also, my theology has shifted in some ways that make Lutheranism somewhat less congenial than it once was (even though I still strongly affirm certain central Lutheran insights). I guess we’ll see…

5 responses to “Church shopping: update”

  1. I read that one of the reason John Wesley resisted leaving the Anglican Church is that he did not want Methodism to become a denomination unto itself. He thought it had more power as a movement and envisioned Methodists in all other denominations. I like to think of Lutheranism the same way. If there were more Lutherans in other denominations, we might be able to pull off this reform project after all.

    I’m church shopping myself these days, and I haven’t limited myself to Lutheran churches. Yet I know I’ll always be a Lutheran wherever I go.

  2. Your theology is shifting?

    Luther would be so disappointed…

    So I assume this has something to do with atonement?

    Discuss please!

  3. Chip, interesting comment – I don’t know that it has to do with Atonement per se. I mean, I guess my thinking about the Atonement is always shifting. It’s a topic that fascinates me for some reason. But is there a specifically Lutheran “take” on Atonement?

    Maybe it’s more that those things which I like about Lutheranism (Word and Sacrament, catholic and evangelical) seem to be easier to find among Anglicans (at least in my limited experience)?

  4. […] Here I wrote that my theology had shifted away from Lutheranism over the last couple of years. One of the respects in which that’s the case is in my attitude toward devotion to the Blessed Virgin (and the Saints in general). I worked through the theological arguments to my own satisfaction some time ago, but more recently it’s become an increasingly important part of my own devotional life. […]

  5. […] Here I wrote that my theology had shifted away from Lutheranism over the last year or so. One of the respects in which that’s the case is in my attitude toward devotion to the Blessed Virgin (and the Saints in general). I worked through the theological arguments to my own satisfaction some time ago, but more recently it’s become an increasingly important part of my own devotional life. […]

Leave a reply to Lee Cancel reply