A Thinking Reed

"Man is but a reed, the most feeble thing in nature, but he is a thinking reed" – Blaise Pascal

Our overly credulous media

The lack of sophistication in the reporting on the Gospel of Judas has been nothing short of astounding. For instance, in today’s Philadelphia Inquirer there is an inane story asking the proverbial man (and woman) in the pew how the “news” that Judas may not have betrayed Jesus after will affect their faith. Most of the people are admirably skeptical and dismissive of the importance of it, except for one lapsed-Catholic-turned-atheist who darkly intones that “the Catholics won’t like this.” Call in Opus Dei! Time for another cover-up! Where’s Dan Brown when you need him?

Very little attempt in the story to put any of this in context, explain what gnosticism is or why orthodox Christianity regards it as heretical. And then we get this stellar quote from The Rev. Beverly Dale, of the Christian Association at the University of Pennsylvania (which is the liberal/progressive campus Christian group):

“It points to the need for every generation to find their own meaning of the good news,” she said. “This can shake loose those who want to keep Christianity in a rigid box. If your faith can’t be pushed or be tested, it’s not much of a faith.”

Now, in fairness to Pr. Dale, this quote may well have been taken out of context, but couldn’t she have made some effort to say something like “It points to the need of every generation to substitute its own spurious ‘revelation’ for the mercy and love of God revealed in the life, death, and resurrection of Jesus Christ, the incarnate Son of God”? Nah, that’d probably be asking too much.

5 responses to “Our overly credulous media”

  1. It also seems sometimes as if the people most skeptical of the New Testament documents as trustworthy records of events are the first to accept, almost at face value, the historical credibility of any document that takes issue with the New Testament. If the Gospel of Judas is so revealing about “what actually happened,” why not the Gospel of John?

  2. One of my students visited the Christian Association a while back and was suitably impressed — they seem to be a lively ministry that creates and sustains a Christian community among UPenn students. So as unfortunate as the quote in the story is, I’m not sure it reflects on Rev. Dale or the Christian Association’s commitment to Christian revelation.

  3. Chris, that’s good to know, and I didn’t mean to cast aspersions on the CA, which, for all I know, is a fine and upstanding outfit, though my comments perhaps inevitably came across that way. Thanks for the report.

  4. No problem — just thought I’d throw in my $0.02. πŸ™‚ Some days it feels like practically no one in mainline campus ministry cares about putting students and Christianity together, so I’m defensive of folks who seem to be successful at it. πŸ™‚

  5. Judas wasn’t needed to betray Jesus – if the gospels are true. JC was well known, not least for the Temple disturbance and all his travels, alleged miracles – and walking around on the water.

    Pretty crazy thing to do!

Leave a reply to Anonymous Cancel reply