Three Christian peace activists kidnapped last year in Iraq were freed on Thursday in a morning raid by multi-national forces in western Baghdad.
Fears for the three men – two Canadians and a Briton – grew two weeks ago after a fellow hostage was found dead in a Baghdad street.
Military officials said none of the kidnappers was present during the raid, and that no shots were fired.
[…]
Jack Straw, the British foreign secretary, said the rescue followed “weeks and weeks of very careful work by military and coalition personnel in Iraq and many civilians.”
However, Major General Rick Lynch, a US military spokesman in Baghdad, said a breakthrough came on Wednesday night after the arrest of two people, one of whom gave information that led to the raid.
Norman Kember, 74, of London, James Loney, 41, and Harmeet Singh Sooden, 32, were seized in Baghdad in November along with Tom Fox, a US citizen whose body was found two weeks ago.
Mr Kember was said to be in “reasonable condition” while the two Canadians were taken to hospital. Maj. Gen. Lynch said the hostages had been found bound, alone and “in good condition.”
Author: Lee M.
-
Christian peace activists in Iraq rescued
-
Who would Jesus waterboard?
Via Chris, Andrew Sullivan has a link to an alarming Pew poll indicating that American Christians (well Catholics and white Protestants anyway) are actually more likely to approve of torture than their secular (atheist or agnostic) fellow citizens. Way to go, team.
Correct me if I’m wrong, but isn’t there a well-known story about Roman soldiers torturing a suspected “insurgent” in an occupied Middle Eastern country about 2,000 years ago? I’m just sayin’.
-
Our so-called opposition party
This is a good (but ultimately depressing) article on the Democrats’ reaction to Russ Feingold’s motion to censure the president for, you know, breaking the law. Based on this account it was something of a desperation move on Feingold’s part after realizing that Congress was unwilling to do anything substantive about the warrantless wire-tapping:
Mr. Feingold said that he came to the idea of censure after three months of watching the N.S.A. issue wend its way through Congress and flail slowly into nothingness. “Even though [Senate Judiciary Committee chairman Arlen] Specter was trying to hold hearings, they were weak. [Attorney General Alberto] Gonzales wasn’t addressing the issue. They were putting up a brick wall—their legal arguments were not persuasive.
“Then, when they briefed the [Senate] Intelligence Committee on the program—well, all I can say is that it was amazing how little we were told. All they get to do is listen to the administration—even when the administration doesn’t feel like talking. And then there was this proposal to break up the Intelligence Committee so that it could work even less effectively.”
From all this self-administered Senatorial gagging came only new legislation proposed by Senator Mike DeWine (R.-Ohio) that would essentially go back and retrospectively legalize the abuses of power under the N.S.A. program. “I wanted to see the headline then,” Mr. Feingold joked: “‘Republican Senate Proposes Law to Make Illegal Program Legal.’
“What they succeeded in doing, in other words, was to sweep the illegality under the rug,” Mr. Feingold said. “I decided it was time to include that on the record and came up with the censure proposal, to bring accountability back into the discussion. And I succeeded in doing that. That’s been achieved.”
The duck-and-cover response from Congressional Dems is reminiscient of their reaction to Jack Murtha’s call for a quick withdrawal from Iraq – dissociate themselves and fail to offer any substantive alternative:
“There is no leadership in the Democratic Party,” said Terry Michael by phone on March 20. He’s a former Democratic National Committee press secretary who now heads the Washington Center for Politics and Journalism. “If only the Democratic Party leaders were alive, they could accept a debate on this. But instead, their strategy is focused on how best to muddle through.”
This goes double, in Mr. Michael’s view, for the party’s funereal flight from debate on the war in Iraq. Indeed, he said, the cower-duck-and-run maneuvers that party eminences conducted in the wake of Mr. Feingold’s announcement was almost identical to the drear chorus of prim disapproval when Pennsylvania Congressman John P. Murtha disavowed his early support of the Iraq war and called, last November, for rapid draw-downs of the U.S. troop presence.
Heavyweight aspirants to the ’08 Presidential nomination—people like Senator Hillary Clinton and Senator Joseph Biden of Delaware—clucked their disapproval and stressed how Mr. Murtha only spoke for himself. For her part, House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi mewled that she didn’t cotton to Mr. Murtha’s resolution but respected him as a veteran and part of the Democratic Party’s grand mosaic of opinion.
Then, when Republican attacks on Mr. Murtha went haywire and addled freshman Congresswoman Jean Schmidt (R.-Ohio) called the decorated Vietnam vet a coward on the House floor, Ms. Pelosi managed to stir herself to an endorsement—when all was assuredly safe and the Murtha resolution was good and doomed anyway.
Granted there’s only so much that the Dems can do as a minority party, but with a president whose approval ratings are somewhere in the 30’s, you’d think they could manage to be a little more assertive.
-
Consistent life symposium
Some readers may find this of interest. Here you can read the proceedings of a symposium on “pro-life progressivism” that was held last year at the law school of The University of St. Thomas in St. Paul, Minnesota.
(via the Acton Institute blog)
-
What’s up with the memoir?
The Inquirer had an article this morning about poet/”memoirist” Mary Karr whose new book of poetry reflects on her recent conversion to Catholicism at age 40. What puzzles me here though is the idea of a “memoirist.” I get the idea that you might want to read the memoirs of a famous person or someone who’s accomplished some amazing feat. But what’s up with more or less random people writing their memoirs? Karr, according to the article, is working on her third set of memoirs! Isn’t that a bit presumptuous?
Of course, the same thing might be said about the blog…
-
By the roots
VI gadfly and all-around swell guy Josh has a great post about the past and future of those who call themselves liberals or progressives. The pope and Lenin both make an appearance, so you won’t want to miss it.
-
Thought for the day
A rich self has a distinct attitude toward the past, the present, and the future. It surveys the past with gratitude for what it has received, not with annoyance about what it hasn’t achieved or about how little it has been given. A rich self lives in the present with contentment. Rather than never having enough of anything except for the burdens others place on it, it is “always having enough of everything” (2 Corinthians 9:8). It still strives, but it strives out of satisfied fullness, not out of the emptiness of craving. A rich self looks toward the future with trust. It gives rather than holding things back in fear of coming out too short, because it believes God’s promise that God will take care of it. Finite and endangered, a rich self still gives, because its life is “hidden with Christ” in the infinite, unassailable, and utterly generous God, the Lord of the present, the past, and the future (see Colossians 3:3). — Miroslav Volf, Free of Charge, p. 110
-
A blogger’s right to change his mind
One of the things I’ve noticed in writing this blog is that I have a tendency to worry about seeming inconsistent or failing to present a coherent perspective on the topics I write about. This is ironic because one of my reasons for starting the blog was as a way of thinking aloud about things that I didn’t necessarily have fixed views on (that and sparing my long-suffering wife of my tedious rants on the issues of the day).
My sense, though, is that once you become aware that you’re writing for an audience (however tiny!), there is a pressure (maybe self-imposed) to present a voice that is self-assured and confident in its arguments and conclusions, rather than tenative and exploratory.
So, in the interest of getting back to the original mission of this blog, what are some issues (political, religious, philosophical, etc.) that I’ve changed my mind and/or am uncertain about? Here are a few just off the top of my head:
- I don’t have a settled view on Atonement theory. I do think that the classic Anselmian satisfaction theory gets short shrift from many of its critics who seem frequently to attack straw man versions of it, but I wouldn’t confidently say I think it’s right.
- I’m much less certain than I used to be that human beings have libertarian free will (in the metaphysical sense) and that it necessarily matters if we do.
- At one time I was a strict political libertarian. I’m not anymore, but I still think they get important things right. And I still find myself unable to embrace liberalism or conservatism in any straightforward way.
- I think pacifism is incorrect, but I’m not sure that it is.
- I’ve gone from being mildly in favor of the death penalty to being opposed.
- I don’t know what the proper legal response to dealing with abortion is, even though I’m fairly confident that there’s no non-arbitrary moral line to be drawn between a fetus and a newborn infant.
What about you? What big ticket issues have you changed your mind about or are an incorrigible squish on? Or, is there something on the above list where you’d like to show me the error of my ways?
P.S. For what it’s worth I’ve also changed my mind on things like the existence of God and the truth of Christianity, but that predates my blogging days and those are settled convictions that wouldn’t be easily overturned. The issues above are ones I’m decidedly squishy on.
-
Apocalypse not yet
This bit from a news account of a speech President Bush gave yesterday in Ohio on the state of the Iraq war made me chuckle:
One woman asked Bush if the war in Iraq and rise in terror were “signs of the Apocalypse.”
“Hmmm,” Bush replied. “I haven’t really thought of it that way. … I guess I’m more of a practical fellow.”
Translation: leave me alone, crazy lady!
Despite his reputation as the poster boy for the Christian Right, Bush has always struck me as pretty much in the mainsteam of the evangelical wing of mainline Protestantism in his religious beliefs (he is a Methodist after all). By contrast, I seem to recall that the not particularly pious Ronald Reagan gave a considerable amount of thought to apocalypticism when he was in the White House.
-
Whole Foods vs. Trader Joe’s
Slate has an article on the “dark side” of Whole Foods and an insider’s guide to Trader Joe’s for New Yorkers who are apparently about to get their first store (can it really be that Philly is ahead of the curve for once?).
The article on Whole Foods makes the point that buying organic and buying local can, and frequently do, come into contact. Leaving aside the question of the health and/or environmental value of organic produce, taste-wise you’re almost always better off buying local. Not that I think there’s necessarily any extraordinary virtue in buying local on principle, but it sure makes a difference when it comes to produce.
Personally I almost never shop at Whole Foods, but shop at Trader Joe’s often. This despite the fact that the byzantine Pennsylvania liquor laws prevent us from getting access to the two buck Chuck and other delights that are available at the TJ’s in more civilized states like California or Indiana. Whole Foods always strikes me as almost insufferably smug (not to mention pricey) compared to the atmosphere of wacky friendliness I find at TJ’s. Of course, we do our main shopping at the local big grocery chain; TJ’s is more for supplemental goodies.