A Thinking Reed

"Man is but a reed, the most feeble thing in nature, but he is a thinking reed" – Blaise Pascal

Irony and hunting

Turns out that Sarah Palin’s RNC speech was written by former Bush speechwriter Matthew Scully, who also happens to be the author of Dominion, a conservative polemic on behalf of animal rights. (An excerpt from Scully’s book that appeared in the American Conservative several years back actually helped set me on the path to vegetarianism.):

The Palin-Scully pairing is anything but a guaranteed fit, though. Palin is known as an avid hunter; Scully is best known for his vigorous defense of animal rights. A vegetarian who is regularly critical of the NRA and much of the hunting community, he is a passionate advocate for doing away with the more brutal versions of blood-sport, including aerial hunting, which Palin supports.

Personally, I’m ambivalent about hunting. I never hunted myself, but I grew up around hunters; every male member of my family and most other men I knew hunted. The first day of deer season was a de facto school holiday. And I think there are important distinctions between subsistence hunting (hunting to survive), sport hunting (hunting for recreation, but consuming the meat), and trophy hunting. It’s the last that seems most indefensible to me, especially as many of them are “canned” hunts where the animals are confined to a particular area and the hunter is virtually guaranteed a kill. How this is “sporting” is beyond me. And the same goes, best as I can tell, for “aerial” hunting.

(Time article link via Erik Marcus.)

p.s. See also Christopher for some wise words.

4 responses to “Irony and hunting”

  1. It’s also worth noting that the Safari Club International, on which Scully spends so much time in “Dominion,” is the same outfit that vigorously lobbied the Alaska legislature to allow aerial hunting, spending hundreds of thousands of dollars on legislators and advertising. In numerous writings, Scully has made clear his hatred for exactly this aerial hunting, which his candidate Palin proudly supports. It has to be a bitter irony for him.

    In a newspaper column a couple of years back, Scully wrote:

    “…this is a group of 30,000 or so people whose all-consuming passion in life is killing big game, with all sorts of competitions to see who can kill the most and biggest “trophy animals.” To win the highest award, for example, you have to kill upward of 360 animals – from an African elephant to an exotic sheep in Russia (yes, there are actually sheep safaris) to some wolf or polar bear minding his own business in the farthest reaches of the Arctic…Go to their annual convention in Reno, as I did a few years ago, and you can find, for the right price, hunts offering every conceivable type of game butchery – aerial hunting, hunts employing baits, hunts with sleds and packs of dogs and, of course, the bow hunts that are now a mania among sportsmen, heightening the pleasure of the stalker and the suffering of the victim.”

    http://www.matthewscully.com/sportsman_politics.htm

  2. I loved Scully’s book – but wow, it was hard to get through. Most things connected with brutality to animals are difficult for me to read and/or see, though.

    I can’t see, either, how anybody can condone the kind of trophy hunting he was talking about. It’s perfectly mad.

    Disclaimer: I have nothing against subsistence hunting at all.

  3. […] Posted on September 6, 2008 by lutherpunk Two interesting articles from Lee and Christopher. Lee points out that much of Palin’s rah rah speech was written by Matthew Scully, a conservative […]

  4. i just posted about this if you are interested. Nice article!

Leave a comment